4 ms·
I'm frustrated that everyone here seems to be hung up over an argument about the definition of computable numbers and some nattering about Cantor, when the real
by ajross 8y ago
I'm frustrated that everyone here seems to be hung up over an argument about the definition of computable numbers and some nattering about Cantor, when the real meat of the abstract seems to be this:
> This alternative classical mechanics is non-deterministic, despite the use of deterministic equations, in a way similar to quantum theory.
Wait, what? What does "a way similar to quantum theory" mean? Is he able to derive quantum postulates from information theory here, or is this just handwaving becuase "uncertainty" emerges like it did for Heisenberg?
Not expert enough to read the paper. Anyone?
- wizeman 8y agoI'm very far from being an expert, but as far as I understood the reasoning, it seems that the author is arguing that as time passes, the current conditions of chaotic physical systems are going to start depending on more and more information regarding (or "binary digits" of) the variables defining the initial conditions. Since the deterministic equations of classical physics are defined over the real numbers but physical variables cannot contain infinite information, at some point some of the information/binary digits of the initial conditions that (partially) defines current conditions must be a random digit -- although this conclusion is only reached after arguing that almost all of the real numbers are numbers that contain random digits (as random as they can be, because they have no structure and can't be named/characterized/defined). As a layman, I'm not really convinced by this reasoning (if indeed this is what the author argues), but this is the gist of what I understood.
- chriswarbo 8y agoNot an answer to your question, but it reminded me of something one of my quantum mechanics professors said during undergraduate physics. Paraphrasing: "Quantum physics may seem hard, but it's much easier than classical physics. We can describe a quantum system using a finite set of integer (or half-integer) quantum numbers. In classical physics the properties are continuous, and describing the deeper decimal places would require knowing the entire history of all the objects involved. We could also never repeat an experiment exactly, due to these infinite decimals." Of course, we're not totally screwed in classical systems; the far decimals are only a problem in chaotic systems. Still, might be related to the author's claim.
- gowld 8y agoOf course that argument is silly, because if you tried to compute the quantum physics of a simple object like a pair of spheres in a vacuum, you'd be hopelessly lost. Classical physics is only hard (in the given sense) if you care about computing infinite decimal details, which no one does.
- hpcjoe 8y agoNot quite ... classical orbits over extended time periods (T >> 1 orbital period) tends to require significant precision thanks to the "chaotic" aspects of the diffeqs. See [1] for some additional details. Many orbital sims use high order methods, predictor-corrector type approaches. As for "quantum physics of a simple object like a pair of spheres in a vacuum" ... I gotta say, as a (non-practicing) physicist, I haven't the foggiest notion about what you are thinking of. Do you mean the collective wave function of the entire ensemble of atoms? Or the valence/band electrons? Or something else? Basically, we've been exploiting symmetries for many years to reduce insanely hard problems to less insanely hard problems. For crystalline material, we exploit periodic boundary conditions to reduce the size of the Hamiltonian to something reasonable. We still have to deal with O(N^3) and higher multicenter matrix elements like <phi_i(R1) | Operator_k(R2) | phi_j(R3)>. This is computationally hard for anything but small N (say 1000-10000). [1] http://carma.astro.umd.edu/nemo/pitp/papers/gd2_s3.4.pdf http://carma.astro.umd.edu/nemo/pitp/papers/gd2_s3.4.pdf
- thraway180306 8y agoThere are no equations and no citations to relevant formalisms so your guess is good as anyone's. The author had a spat with arXiv who, while not being a peer-reviewed venue do their best to keep out the crackpottery, rejected some of the stuff coming from his vicinity. Gisin's complaint was loud, ended up published in Nature, and now it seems anything goes. Then went a flood of similar gems. Such like over-the-top argument for physical time (deep problem formal in nontrivial ways), because thinking requires time thus obviously https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01497 https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01497 (doubtful any creative time went into that). I think figure 5 therein anwsers your question best as the author can.
- jessriedel 8y ago> https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01497 https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.01497 Note that this is in the "history and philosophy of physics" section of the arXiv, so it's not flooding the arXiv in general. I've heard a small handful of practical physicists complain that Ginsin is getting too much status by posting on the arXiv, but I haven't heard any philosophers of science complain that his papers are particularly bad, much less that they are so obviously worthless that they are a net negative due to taking up space on the daily list of what's new in that section.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- edna314 8y agoLooking at figure 2 in the paper you were mentioning helped me a lot in understanding his thought process.
- no_identd 8y agoYou might find an answer via the papers I've assembled here, in another comment sub-thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17295787 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17295787
- no_identd 8y ago>>This alternative classical mechanics is non-deterministic, despite the use of deterministic equations, in a way similar to quantum theory. That conclusion strongly reminds me of a claim made in the following paper: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Vladimir_Garcia-Morales/publication/259578204_Quantum_Mechanics_and_the_Principle_of_Least_Radix_Economy/links/5688127e08ae1e63f1f73000/Quantum-Mechanics-and-the-Principle-of-Least-Radix-Economy.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Vladimir_Garcia-Morales... Garcia-Morales, Vladimir - Quantum Mechanics and the Principle of Least Radix Economy To quote: "… The formulation provides an explanation of how determinism and random statistical behavior coexist in spacetime and a framework is developed that allows dynamical processes to be formulated in terms of chains of digits. …" (A note about that paper: It seems, to me, that it incorrectly uses a non-general formula to calculate radix economy, one which only applies to unsigned number systems. A fact making the rest of the paper - which unfortunately goes rather beyond my math & physics skills - somewhat dubious, albeit not wrong, to me.)
- cyphar 8y ago> > This alternative classical mechanics is non-deterministic, despite the use of deterministic equations, in a way similar to quantum theory. > What does "a way similar to quantum theory" mean? I'm not an expert (though I have studied undergraduate physics). I imagine what he's trying to reference is that while the equations of quantum mechanics relating to states are entirely deterministic, the measurements we make are probabilistic in nature (I am careful to not say "non-deterministic" -- because it would not be correct to phrase it that way). I've skimmed through the paper and I see no reason that this peculiar nature of quantum mechanics (which we still don't understand) applies to a mathematical reformulation of classical mechanics. I imagine the reason the author mention quantum mechanics is that they have published the paper in the quantum mechanics section of arXiv... But personally my biggest issue with the abstract is this: > Since a finite volume of space can't contain more than a finite amount of information, I argue that the mathematical real numbers are not physically relevant. This conflates several concepts from different fields in a single sentence and is utterly ludicrous. The author appears to be talking about the Bekenstein bound (which states that there is a maximum amount of entropy for a given region of space with a given amount of energy -- otherwise you could violate thermodynamics by placing such a system into a black hole). But he is conflating the concept of entropy (or "information") from thermodynamics with his own concept of "number information". If this conflation was accurate then one could assume that the amount of entropy in a system is related to the decimal expansion of variables related to that system -- which is just a ridiculous thing to argue (especially if you consider that you can change the decimal expansion of a number by changing units).