6 ms·
Even with a tariff on panels, the cost of a solar installation, with incentives, is still significantly cheaper than grid electricity. With federal and state i
by gwbas1c 8y ago
Even with a tariff on panels, the cost of a solar installation, with incentives, is still significantly cheaper than grid electricity.
With federal and state incentives, my panels work out to about 4-5 cents a kilowatt hour. Normally I'd pay about 17 cents a kilowatt hour.
(This makes running a space heater cost about as much as running a natural gas furnace.)
Furthermore, my panels are financed with a fixed-rate loan instead of tied to market price of energy. That means the cost will never go up, but instead go to zero at the end of the loan.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoWith free fuel and falling supply chain costs this is all well and good. Worth noting is that the value of solar electricity goes down fairly sharply as a function of market penetration because of the intermittency. Once you start adding massive chemical electricity storage costs and environmental impacts get more gnarly.
- murph-almighty 8y agoWhat kind of environmental impacts? Also, what do we do with dead solar panels? Is there a recycling program, or research going into such a thing? I'm so excited for this news and I feel like these are pretty minor cons though.
- phinnaeus 8y agoGiant batteries aren't great for the environment because they involve heavy mining.
- jerrycruncher 8y agoAnd have a one to two decade lifespan, at best. After which you have to dispose of them.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThey are fully recyclable and aren't dangerous to do so.
- microcolonel 8y agoLithium polymer batteries are highly recyclable, they primarily just have to be unwound, possibly reformed if something structurally changes in the cathode/anode, and the trace elements need to be washed off and processed.
- jerrycruncher 8y agoMea culpa. Thanks for the info!
- toomuchtodo 8y agoLithium is harvested from evaporation pools, not mined. If you're referring to cobalt content, there are several researchers working to remove the need for that element from the production process.
- dnissley 8y agoI'm guessing they meant battery production, which requires the mining of rare-earth elements: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_element#Environmental_Pollution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare-earth_element#Environment...
- tedsanders 8y agoBatteries do not use rare-earth elements (as far as I am aware). You may be thinking of cobalt, which is expensive and mostly mined in the Congo. Reducing the cobalt content of cathodes is a big priority for the industry: https://cleantechnica.com/2018/06/09/cobalt-free-car-batteries-in-the-works-for-panasonic-tesla/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/06/09/cobalt-free-car-batteri...
- bunderbunder 8y agoI'm curious to know why other storage methods aren't taking off more. I would have assumed that the long-term costs of something like hauling something heavy up a hill (which could easily be a manmade earthworks in flat areas) would be quite a bit lower, on account of the equipment in question having a longer life span than batteries.
- gmueckl 8y agoThe keyword here is energy density. Batteries are really good when measured in electrical energy stored per volume. Your proposed mechanical potential energy store (lifting mass) cannot compete. The amount of stored energy is aurprisingly low in comparison. I did the math over a decade ago because I had the same idea and the numbers were underwhelming.
- lutorm 8y agoYeah, but energy density isn't really significant. You may get less energy out of a m^3 of water pumped to a reservoir than you get out of a m^3 of battery, but even the smallest reservoir has a usable volume that probably surpasses the volume of all batteries ever built. You can just keep pumping.
- gmueckl 8y agoNo, you can't just keep pumping. To build a reservoir at the scale that you seem to imagine, you depend on locations that provide a suitable topography. Very few such places exist.
- pjc50 8y agoThe energy density of gravity storage is terrible. But there's still a few plans for it: https://www.wired.com/2016/05/forget-elons-batteries-fix-grid-rock-filled-train-hill/ https://www.wired.com/2016/05/forget-elons-batteries-fix-gri... > 9,600 tons of rock- and concrete-filled railcars up a 2,000-foot hill. > $55 million > The Nevada project has a power capacity of 50 megawatts and can produce 12.5 megawatt-hours of energy. Using the 4 cents/kWh figure upstream, that's ... $500 of electricity per round trip.
- nl 8y agoReflow batteries have low environmental impact, and are cheaper than lithium ion. The only real downside is that they are about 25% mode bulky for the same energy storage, but for many domestic installations this isn't a big problem. Many solar plants are now pairing with large scale energy storage facilities too (eg, liquid salt, pump hydro, even some batteries).
- Arnt 8y agoRight. So why add "massive" chemical etc? People who install solar panels have a choice: ⓐ Restrict their power usage at night, ⓑ install batteries or blah, or ⓒ get power elsewhere. Or a combination. Many people seem to think that option ⓐ does not exist. Ie. ⓑ+ⓒ has to be massive as you put it, because ⓐ cannot lighten the load.
- prewett 8y agoOoh, I really like your usage of ⓐ. How do you type those without looking them up on a Unicode chart and copy/pasting?
- Arnt 8y agoI use linux/X11, with a compose key and a large repertoire. If I type compose ( 4 ) (that's four keystrokes, in sequence) I get ④, compose ~ e gives me ẽ, which I'm sure some language uses but I've no idea which. http://rant.gulbrandsen.priv.no/xcompose http://rant.gulbrandsen.priv.no/xcompose describes my configuration (as it once was).
- WalterBright 8y agoAgain, I'll bring up what nobody seems to mention. With minute-by-minute pricing of electricity, intermittent supply problems can be greatly mitigated without batteries, peaker plants, etc. On the consumer side, elastic electricity uses can be switched on/off through an app connected to the internet. Elastic uses are things like charging car batteries, electric water heaters, A/C, refrigerator, etc.
- sp332 8y agoPeaker plants are expensive to run and electricity from them is priced accordingly. If peaker plants are turning on, it's because no cheaper source of electricity was able to meet demand, and demand was inelastic enough to pay the higher prices.
- briffle 8y agoPeaker plants are now more [1] expensive than solar+battery storage. And battery storage that without solar (ie, soaking up night time base-load) are even cheaper. [1] https://electrek.co/2017/12/13/solar-batteries-to-take-10gw-natural-gas/ https://electrek.co/2017/12/13/solar-batteries-to-take-10gw-...
- WalterBright 8y agoMy electric rates are fixed at the same price, 24/7. Trying to maintain this will be very expensive for the grid when faced with fluctuating supply. Are there any utilities in the US that offer minute-by-minute pricing, or even hour-by-hour? If not, then we cannot conclude that demand is inelastic.
- rb808 8y agoAgreed, I wanted this but the utility can't even do day by day metering.
- oaktowner 8y agoOut of curiosity -- what timeframe are you using to calculate that figure (4-5 cents a kWh)? (I bought a solar system just under a year ago).
- jakebaker 8y agoMost people would calculate this against the term of the loan. So if you have a 10 year loan vs a 20 year loan, that would change the price. The price is what you actually pay, which in many cases would just be the cost of the loan divided by the amount of energy produced.
- tachyonbeam 8y agoWhat I'm wondering is if they're calculating this figure based on peak rated panel power, because if so, that's probably off by a large margin.
- oaktowner 8y agoAgreed -- that wouldn't make any sense.
- oaktowner 8y agoInteresting. I would have thought that you do it by (expected) lifetime of the panels. I haven't had my system for a full year yet so I don't have complete numbers, but it seems to be anywhere from .5 (winter) to 1.1 MWh per month. Assuming I end up generating 8 MWh per year, I'll use that number along with an expected lifetime of, say, 20 years. So: lifetime production of 160 MWh, and my system (after incentives) was something around $18K. $18,000 / 160,000 kWh = $0.11 / kWh. If my system lasts 25 years, that goes down to 9 cents per kWh. (note: I think I have a 10 year loan but will likely pay it off way earlier than that, but it wouldn't factor into this calculation other than interest)
- mmt 8y ago> I would have thought that you do it by (expected) lifetime of the panels. That would certainly make the most sense to me, and maybe even based on the warranty period, with accounting for replacing failing or underperforming panels after that. That way, the statement, which sounds too good to be true, "and then the cost drops to zero" doesn't enter into the conversation. Sure, the monthly cashflow cost may be zero for a while, but that might just be accounting trickery.
- weberc2 8y agoThis probably varies by climate. What state are you in? Also, do you get to sell energy back to your power co? And at what rate? Or do you just store it?
- twothamendment 8y ago> Even with a tariff on panels, the cost of a solar installation, with incentives, is still significantly cheaper than grid electricity. That all depends on where you live. I could cover my house with panels and not have enough in the winter. It would work great in the summer. It also depends on how your utility bills. During the spring and fall where my bill is the lowest (low usage of heat or a/c) half of my bill is just for being connected to the grid. Since I can't ditch the grid because I need it in the winter, solar doesn't come close to paying for itself in my situation. Power is under 7 cents/kwh, but there is a nearly $40 a month fee for being hooked up to the grid. That said, it is still exciting to see the price come down. I'll likely get a few panels just so I have a little juice when the grid is down.
- briffle 8y ago> 'll likely get a few panels just so I have a little juice when the grid is down. Most grid tie inverters have a shut-off switch that kills all power in case of a power outage. This is usually mandated by safety regulations, to protect linemen working on the downed lines. (there are a few that provide very limited solar power during an outage, but not full power, something like 2000W)
- vpeters25 8y agoI can confirm, I have grid-tied solar panels and have gotten outages in the middle of sunny days which is usually the time my panels are actually supplying surplus power to the grid. Only way to have juice during power outages in my configuration is to add something like the 7K Tesla battery.
- twothamendment 8y agoYes, a point to keep in mind when buying equipment. I had a very disappointed neighbor when I finally convinced him to shut the power off to his whole house and see what would happen. The salesman sold him on having power when the grid was down. It takes more work, planning and some battery to have some power when the grid is down. I plan have enough to charge phones, power radios, power propane appliances and maybe keep me on the internet. I'd like to have enough for a refrigerator, but that starts to get expensive.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoAre you factoring in the price of your financing? I very often see that ignored. You either need to include financing costs, or opportunity costs. Spending e.g. $20k isn't free, either you don't have it and need to borrow, or you do and you need to forgo putting it in the S&P500 and getting 7% on it long-term inflation adjusted, which is about $120 a month that you could spend on electricity. For comparison, the average US home uses 900 kWh per month, which is about $90 at average electricity prices in the US. You can argue the numbers (e.g. 'you're wrong, the S&P500 has lower or higher returns' or 'I paid just 10k, not 20k of my own money'), I'd agree, but you need to consider everything. I find most calculations are often way too generous and omit important aspects. That's not a reason to not do it, btw... I'd say, if you're underperforming the S&P500 by a little bit while going 100% green on your consumption, that's terrific. But you'd have to admit it's more than just a financial story. The other side of the story is that you likely aren't consuming your own energy. i.e., you're not paying for storage or expensive peaker-plant backup capacity. If you were the only consumer, or if all consumers were like you, your panels alone would not be sufficient. In other words, there's a cost that has to be paid, and someone else is paying it now. At some point utilities are going to pay you 4-5c per kWh that you put back into the system, and charge you 17c. There is no reason to believe today's feed in tariffs will continue indefinitely. So whatever calculations you make today may not fly in the future, unless you buy your own storage or excess capacity, but then you're not going to get anywhere near the 4-5c figure. I'm a big believer in solar and I'd love for us to commit more resources, even if it increases prices, it's too important. But we also tend to overstate how cheap everything has become, the narrative on solar is too positive, often portraying solar as if it's ideologically-neutral and financially-interesting when reality iis the opposite. We're still only at 1% of total energy production and we're subsidising it up the wazoo from state and federal incentives to utilities paying retail prices for your energy, and it's still not particularly interesting once you figure in opportunity costs. We still have a long way to go.