3 ms·
Watching this thread from yesterday, I feel that HN tries to dismiss not an experiment and its conclusions (which are indeed falsely true and inexact if argumen
by wruza 8y ago
Watching this thread from yesterday, I feel that HN tries to dismiss not an experiment and its conclusions (which are indeed falsely true and inexact if argumentation against it is true). It tries to dismiss a phenomenon and fix this forever as in “no, we are not like that”. But what Zimbardo seemed to try to conduct is resembling a typical SU prison-camp. Where all the people inhabitating the entire area were given some rules (both law and “thief law”, perverted and mostly uncontrolled) and began to create a social mess. It wasn’t sadistic or directly harmful, but in these conditions people do smart or dumb moves that lead to big trouble (often referred to as “get into the odd”) to themselves or someone other, thus having a power impossible to have in a regular society, along with all long going implications.
While most SU prisons were not insane hell movie-likes at first sight, it is still a wrong move to state conditions and effects similar to Zimbardo’s as disproven in a wide sense simply because he messed this one up.
Main problem here is that one probably cannot make such an experiment without actually building a prison and hurting people (and that they know their deeds will not be punished). The only reliable sources are 20th century books on civil wars and prison camps, but these are a read too long for HN format, and a common knowledge on that is so vague that isn’t even worth discussing.
- watwut 8y agoAccording to article, researchers themselves pushed guards toward being more aggressive on multiple occasions. E.g. resulting behavior was not just what emerged in absence of external control, but what emerged when you authority explicitly pressures guards to be tough and legitimize or praises that behavior. That is pretty big difference in terms of meaning of results.
- ZainRiz 8y agoHow different is that from a new prison guard being pressured by their supervisor or co-workers to be tough on prisoners? It indicates that a bad situation can be created by bad management, and a new person introduced to an existing bad system can turn bad as well.