4 ms·
It's not untrue, but it is nuanced. Basically, Malthus was right for some people. More people tends to benefit capital and harm labor, because it increases bo
by nostrademons 8y ago
It's not untrue, but it is nuanced.
Basically, Malthus was right for some people. More people tends to benefit capital and harm labor, because it increases both the potential labor pool and potential market size for capitalists & entrepreneurs but increases competition for laborers. It tends to benefit specialists and harm generalists, because specialists can more easily find buyers for their skills while generalists have to try harder to stand out from everyone else. It tends to benefit landowners (who already own part of the fixed supply of property) at the expense of renters (who must compete with more people for housing).
While I'd agree that more population is overall good for humanity (if only because there's more of it), what's good for humanity is not necessarily good for individual humans. However, since the groups that it is good for tend to be the groups that set the prevailing narrative, these distinctions usually get papered over.
There's a credible theory that Black Death lead to the Renaissance, because the depopulation of Europe allowed laborers to bargain for higher wages and kickstarted the growth of a permanent middle class. There's a bunch of resources on this if you google [black death lead to renaissance], but the Wikipedia page has a good overview:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_the_Black_Death#Social,_environmental,_and_economic_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consequences_of_the_Black_Deat...
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoThe linked article nowhere mentions the Renaissance, except in the title of an article mentioned as a reference. Also, I don't think that the Renaissance depended a whole lot on the middle class. The middle class was critical to the economic changes that transformed Europe, sure, but that was kind of separate from the Renaissance itself.