3 ms·
This is very interesting reading and I don't want to discount what was discovered. I would however like to see what other possible explanations are possible and
by karmakaze 8y ago
This is very interesting reading and I don't want to discount what was discovered. I would however like to see what other possible explanations are possible and come up with tests to determine one or the other.
It is good to think in terms of why bees have this ability. Identifying patterns in flora is beneficial, how do these differences arise? It could be that certain patterns appear with others in correlated or inversely correlated couplings. As far as the bees are concerned the amount of sugar is correlated with a card shape of paper which hasn't expressed circles or triangles. Perhaps that same blank card if left for a while will have some symbols and less sugar. The 'concept', if we can even call it that, is that the presence of symbols reduces the sugar concentration. I would definitely say they grok an inverse relationship and that a blank card has a 'small quantity' of symbols. I can't think of an experiment to tell if the bees consider a blank card to be a small quantity or zero.
A good thought experiment is if we trained an AI similarly with these same cards. If when presented with a blank card as yet unseen and a card with one or six symbols, it chose the blank one, I don't think many would be arguing (yet) that the AI understands zero, rather that it's pattern matching wiring just classified it one way or the other.
Even AlphaGo when playing Lee Sedol apparently had gaps in its play and the team was uncertain if they would be uncovered or not. Many, not all of these were discovered and 'trained out' earlier working with Fan Hui who developed a sense of where such weaknesses remained in some way to the way Kasparov could sus out Deep Blue's 'thought patterns'. I wish there were more details on this and how much less susceptable AlphaZero is to it.