5 ms·
I'm not not sure if Prof. Torbjörn Lager of the University of Gothenburg knows this, but in America "Make X Great Again" has very political overtones. To those
by ModernMech 8y ago
I'm not not sure if Prof. Torbjörn Lager of the University of Gothenburg knows this, but in America "Make X Great Again" has very political overtones. To those of us with colored skin, "MAGA" has been yelled with racial overtones.
Best to keep this kind of stuff away from programming, maybe?
- anothergoogler 8y agoYes, please do that.
- tomcam 8y agoMAGA has nothing to do with race. Ask Larry Elder, Candace Owens, Kanye, Thomas Sowell, or Walter Winchell.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- abiox 8y agoto me, the fact that you're earnestly enumerating individuals is itself noteworthy. if things were so simple and so obvious, i feel like the idea of naming people would be absurd, because the examples would be legion.
- frostburg 8y agoIt's very likely to be a joke about the Trump campaign. The chance of it being in unironic support of the original use of the slogan is very small.
- grewil2 8y agoProf. Torbjörn Lager was my teacher in a few courses back in around 2005, I even had a beer or two with him. He is a very smart and funny guy - I can say with 100% certainty that he means it as a joke.
- carapace 8y agoNo doubt, but that's not the point. He made the joke in public, and to a portion of his audience it falls flat (to put it mildly.)
- ModernMech 8y agoThat's my point. Some of us will read this paper and not even notice the reference. Some will notice the reference and not be bothered by it. But then there are those of us who have experienced overt racism connected to this phrase who won't be able to read this paper without thinking about that trauma every other line. We talk a good talk about making tech more inclusive, but it seems when we have an easy and obvious choice, there is resistance. Taking the MAGA reference out of this paper would do nothing to diminish it on a technical level, and it would cause more people to read it. Perhaps even this thread would have related to the technical merits of the paper, rather than the derailment I caused. Yet there are multiple responses here expressing resistance to the idea on principle. Again, an idea that would result in better outcomes for everyone.
- nurettin 8y agoHow do you suggest the author replaces the sentiment to make prolog great again in text to cater to your sensibilities?
- panic 8y agoThey could easily remove it. It bothers me that the parent comment has been downvoted so heavily—"MAGA" does have racial overtones and probably doesn't belong in a technical document. I'm sure the author meant it as a joke (especially as a European who isn't familiar with American culture), but that doesn't invalidate the criticism.
- porker 8y agoI didn't know it had racial overtones. Here in the UK it's usually said with a sarcastic laugh when we want to mock Trump and hit him with a slogan we remember from the US presidential campaign. The inference being he's really not 'great' and he's devalued the USA by being its president. Good to know, I will avoid in future.
- ModernMech 8y agoWe use it that way as well. As in: "Added $1T to the deficit and still no universal healthcare! #MAGA" But minorities in this country have to put up with being told to leave now on a regular basis. Hate crimes are on the rise. You're now labeled a racist for standing up to racism. Racists are emboldened and cite the President as the reason for their newfound brazenness. People who simply support the President want to pretend that it's just a slogan, but they're in company with very unsavory people (the KKK aren't Democrats) who use that slogan as a weapon every day. Every. Day. And so to expect to be free from that onslaught in a paper about Prolog I don't think is much to ask. But clearly this is still Trump's world.
- protomyth 8y agoIt only has ‘racial overtones’ to people trying to disparage a little under half the country. The author should probably remove it, but the continued perverting of people’s arguments and slogans to make them appear racist is not helping anyone.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago"Make X great again" was once a neutral phrase, and has now been misappropriated and politicized. I say - let's make it neutral again! And kudos to Prof. Lager for doing just that.
- ModernMech 8y ago> was once a neutral phrase, and has now been misappropriated and politicized If the phrase was politicized, you'll have to blame Trump for using it as the slogan for his political campaign.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoI'm not interested in blaming or praising anyone, I just want to use simple phrases like "let's make math joyful again" without worrying someone might associate it with racism or other things that didn't even cross my mind. It's not about MAGA anymore, it's just more and more often people's innocuous statements are interpreted in an offensive way, and at some point you just prefer not to speak anymore because you don't know what can be offending, and you don't ever touch important matters, keeping your opinions to yourself, maybe allowing a watered-down version that actually doesn't make any point - and that's the public discourse today.
- M_Bakhtiari 8y agoThat's completely preposterous, along with this whole "dog whistle" conspiracy theory that they are pushing in the US.
- ModernMech 8y agoYou're saying it's preposterous that people use coded language to affect racist policy goals in order to avoid political backlash for anti-social beliefs? Really, that's preposterous?
- M_Bakhtiari 8y agoYes, that is preposterous. Let's assume for the sake of argument that it's true. The people who promote the theory seem to be the only ones capable of hearing this whistle, the theory itself being political backlash, so it clearly defeats its own purpose in that regard. And of course it does nothing to prevent backlash from the actual policy goals. It's simply an attempt to get away with arguing against straw men. Taking a perfectly reasonable statement, such as "enforce established immigration law" and take it to be "code" for something completely indefensible like "keep out those subhuman spics". It's hard to argue against the former, much easier to argue against the latter. Of course it does nothing to change the mind of your opponent who already knows and agrees that people of any given ethnicity are not less than human, but it does prevent those in your own camp from taking anything your opponent says as a reasonable statement. Scott Adams described the phenomenon in a recent blog post: http://blog.dilbert.com/2018/06/10/why-democrats-hear-a-secret-racist-dog-whistle-and-republicans-dont/ http://blog.dilbert.com/2018/06/10/why-democrats-hear-a-secr...
- skocznymroczny 8y agowhite is a color too
- arkh 8y agoThis comment generalizing a US centric problem to the world is full of imperialist overtones. Best to keep this kind of comment away from sites with a global audience.
- carapace 8y agoThe paper is in English.
- ModernMech 8y agoMarginalization of minorities in tech is a global problem.
- giardini 8y agoModernMech says>"...in America "Make X Great Again" has very political overtones..." Sometimes, but only rarely. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. Your labeling of every possible phrase of the form "Make X Great Again" does violence to the English language by disallowing certain forms of speech. As one other poster states herein, by banning phrases of those you politically oppose, you could eventually circumscribe the entire language and prevent most all free speech. When I was 4 years old I learned that "Sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never harm me." and I absorbed the concept <b>fully</b> at that age. Were you to not have absorbed that lesson yet or to have rejected that concept, having reached adulthood, would be unfortunate. Indeed, because you do not appear to be stunted intellectually, I do not believe you have not heard and absorbed that lesson. I _do_ however, believe that you, in a Machiavellian manner, are attempting to gain advantage by restricting argumentation arbitrarily.