3 ms·
Yes, exactly. Imagine trying to explain to people that you participated in something where you did horrible things for structural reasons. To really pull that o
by wpietri 8y ago
Yes, exactly. Imagine trying to explain to people that you participated in something where you did horrible things for structural reasons. To really pull that off, you need to convince every interlocutor that they too would be prone to this. When it's much easier for your audience to believe that it's just you that's horrible, and they are fine and decent people who wouldn't do as you did.
Especially decades later, I'd be very reluctant to naively credit people's explanations here.
- shkkmo 8y agoExcept we don't have to, we have experimental evidence that shows what happens and what happens is not what 'happened' in the SPE.
- wpietri 8y agoWe don't have to what? I could believe that the SPE doesn't really get at it, but people do end up doing horrible things for structural reasons. That doesn't change the incentives for trying to explain that to people who weren't there.
- pas 8y agoWhat's the p-value on these? How many trials were there? We have separate events, and we try to compare them, and use them as "evidence". I don't think the SPE is great science, but people are very easily driven by circumstances, and it'll take a lot of time to fully unpack the dynamics and ethical consequences of that.