2 ms·
Business licenses for even mundane things have been around for well over a hundred years, particularly in cities. So generic complaints about over-regulation ha
by wahern 8y ago
Business licenses for even mundane things have been around for well over a hundred years, particularly in cities. So generic complaints about over-regulation have little historical resonance. Not only did those debates happen, as you say; they happened a very long time ago.
But a child's lemonade stand, AFAIK, never required a business license. That's new. I don't know if laws, enforcement practices, or public awareness have changed, but I don't get why people insist on defending it.
My guess is that enforcement has changed, and that's partly because of the push to take discretion (de jure and de facto) away from agencies to minimize prejudiced, unequal enforcement of the law. One of the takeaways is that, because the laws were always more strictly enforced against disfavored classes, the privileged are finally getting a taste of the mundane, prosaic injustices minorities have always faced. That doesn't excuse the injustices, but it hints at why it may be difficult to address them--permitting a white kid to sell lemonade at the end of his driveway also permits a black kid to sell Coca-Cola on the street corner, which might cause consternation among some people (think of recent SF ordinances taxing soda).
- karmajunkie 8y agoWhat's probably more accurate to say is that a child's lemonade stand always required the same license, but the law was never enforced (as you point out the enforcement disparity that has always existed.)