4 ms·
> But what it should be is a lesson for cities to adopt a young entrepreneur license for like $10/year. What happens when the lemonade stand with a $10 licence
by DanBC 8y ago
> But what it should be is a lesson for cities to adopt a young entrepreneur license for like $10/year.
What happens when the lemonade stand with a $10 licence poisons people? https://foodsafetyinfosheets.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/6-13-07.pdf https://foodsafetyinfosheets.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/6-1...
Death from norovirus is rare, but it does happen.
https://www.cdc.gov/features/norovirus/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/features/norovirus/index.html
> CDC estimates that each year in the United States norovirus causes 19 to 21 million illnesses, 56,000 to 71,000 hospitalizations, and 570 to 800 deaths.
- loeg 8y agoWhat happens when a lemonade stand with a $300 license poisons people? What distinction are you trying to draw here?
- learc83 8y agoThe lemonade stand with a $300 license is inspected several times a year and awarded a health score, and the employees are required to undergo food safety training. They are also running a real business that required a real investment, so they should be more risk averse. I don't know if the risks from kids running lemonade stands is high enough to justify regulation, but presumably all the above makes a business with a $300 license less likely to poison customers.
- abfan1127 8y agoyou're buying powdered lemonade from kids. If you can't identify the risks involved in such a process, maybe you shouldn't be doing other things in everyday life like driving...
- sincerely 8y agoI mean, there's a significant amount of the population that isn't capable of passing a driving test but that we as a society still let buy food on their own.
- loeg 8y agoWe usually let them drive, too :-(.
- abfan1127 8y agoand they seem to get through life without debilitating food poisoning, so maybe worrying about food poisoning via a child's powdered lemonade stand is a bit excessive.
- sincerely 8y agoWell, they get through life without debilitating food poisoning in large part because of existing government regulation regarding selling food....
- ben509 8y ago> ... so they should be more risk averse. It lessens risk, but doesn't eliminate it, so the original question still stands: what does happen when the $300 license holder poisons someone?
- DanBC 8y agoThe victim sues and gets a pay out for their losses from the food vendor's public liability insurance that is a requirement of the licence.
- loeg 8y agoRequiring liability insurance is entirely orthogonal to the cost of the business license. A locality could hand out business licenses for free and require liability insurance.
- learc83 8y agoYou seem to be forgetting the whole point of this thread--a proposal for $10 licenses that kids can afford. There's no point in making a license affordable for kids if they still need to have completely unaffordable liability insurance. It's pretty clear that when the OP suggested a $10 license they were also suggesting removing other regulatory costs. The proposal is useless otherwise.
- mywittyname 8y agoThe distinction is not cost. People preparing food for public consumption should have their facilities inspected and receive proper training on safe food handling and storage.
- stickfigure 8y agoNah. I'm perfectly content to eat in my friend's uninspected home, or judge random street vendors by sight and/or yelp. I suggest you travel more broadly. I'm guessing you've never been to a part of the world with a vibrant street vendor scene, because once you have, you weep over the sad sterile* world we've legislated here in the US. * Excepting the mass salmonella poisonings we get from large-scale mechanized food preparation.
- mywittyname 8y agoAfrica and SE Asia have a massive problem with food-borne illnesses and deaths related to it. You can take a look at the WHO's numbers, as they track food-related illness around the world [1]. Results start on page 61 and are broken down by region. They report impact of food-related illness in terms of years of life lost. America, Canada, W. Europe, and Australia are in the range of ~10 years lost per 100k people to food related illness. Africa is around 1200 per 100k and SE Asia is at 800 per 100k. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/199350/9789241565165_eng.pdf?sequence=1 http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/199350/97892... So maybe America is a "sad, sterile" world, but it's also legislated away something that remains a major problem in plaguing the rest of the world.
- stickfigure 8y agoMaybe I'm misreading this, but page 78 seems to be the money shot and it's 35 for the US, 40-50 depending on what part of Europe you're in, and 140 for Mexico - which I consider to be the gold standard for street food. There's also a huge problem inferring that health inspections and street vendor licensing have anything to do with the results. Mexico is probably no different from Thailand in this regard, and yet there's a 10X difference in years lost. I'll bet there are stronger correlative factors of climate (tropical = more parasites and diseases) and quality of public drinking water. Rich northern countries score better than equatorial countries on these benchmarks too. It's quite a stretch to say that folks are going to start dying left and right if the health board takes a day off. I'd be perfectly happy to live with the health inspection regime (and the rich food culture) of Mexico, especially if it's combined with our public water and sanitation system.
- DanBC 8y agoIt feels weird to have a regulation that does nothing. If you're going to regulate do it well, but also proportionately. If you're not going to regulate don't regulate, but provide some education. There's no point in providing toy registrations.
- loeg 8y agoA $300 license for a one- or two-time pop-up lemonade stand hardly feels proportionate.
- bitkarma 8y agoI think that most people know that little kids are disgusting and covered in germs and viruses. People buy the lemonade because they want to support the kid, not because of the quality of the beverage. Last summer I noticed several of the lemonade stands in my neighborhood had bottles of hand sanitizer and that the kids were actually using it. Maybe there is some level of awareness out there. At least little kids will usually wash their hands because their parents tell them to. High school cheerleaders with no oversight are a different story.
- ben509 8y agoYou have the same problem with people having parties and accidentally poisoning their guests. At most, you can have a proviso in the license that they have to display a notice that the stand is not inspected or regulated by the health department.