7 ms·
When does this level of rhetoric approach criminal negligence? From the previous HN discussions about Tesla’s,s running into stationary objects, the problem see
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago
When does this level of rhetoric approach criminal negligence? From the previous HN discussions about Tesla’s,s running into stationary objects, the problem seems like a fundamental design issue not likely to be fixed with software. This has already killed people. What happens when some poor person relies on Musk’s ‘full autonomy’ and gets killed?
Elon Musk is the Elizabeth Holmes of self driving cars.
- _ph_ 8y agoThe headline misquotes Musk. He did not announce full autonomy.
- rayiner 8y agoThat's exactly what he announced: > With V9, we will begin to enable full self-driving features The caveat ("begin to enable") doesn't change things. You might be at the beginning of pregnancy, but you're fully pregnant.
- piker 8y ago> The caveat ("begin to enable") doesn't change things. You might be at the beginning of pregnancy, but you're fully pregnant. That would be correct if the Musk quote said they would "begin to enable" full autonomy. That assertion is distinguishable from beginning to enable features related to autonomy.
- rayiner 8y agoYou're changing the meaning by adding the word "related." Say Microsoft stated it would "will begin to enable full 8K features" on the XBox One. That would mean that something would be in 8K--maybe just for movies but not games. It wouldn't mean "features related to 8K" but not a actually being able to display 8K video anywhere.
- piker 8y agoYour interpretation seems to be that if the car is ever in a "fully autonomous" state, then it's "fully autonomous". Thus if a "fully autonomous feature" is enabled (such as on the highway), that's full autonomy even if that feature is disabled automatically in other situations (such as in the city). Some people would interpret "fully autonomous" to mean end-to-end autonomy, sort of like enabling a "full encryption" feature on a chat application doesn't make chats on that application "fully encrypted". [EDIT: Given the medium and proposition, the appropriate interpretation seems to be the narrower one.]
- rayiner 8y agoThat is my interpretation, yes. "Fully self-driving features" means the car is self-driving at least some of the time. So a fully autonomous mode that's only active on the highway in good weather counts, but not modes where the human still has to pay attention, or features that only support but do not actually enable full autonomy at least some of the time. Even limited full-autonomy seems totally out of the reach of Tesla given what we know to date.
- JackCh 8y agoWhether or not rayiner is correct in his interpretation, I think it's pretty clear his interpretation is not an outlandish one. By that I mean many other people in the general public will share his interpretation, and unlike rayiner many of those people will be blissfully unaware of the problems with automation Tesla has been having. What this means is that a large number of people are going to be deceived by statements like this from Musk, even if you think what Musk is saying is technically true, because they interpreted/misinterpreted Musk's statement the same way rayiner did.
- itsslo 8y agoIf say, Tesla would now be able to parallel park all the time without human intervention or oversight, would that not be considered a fully autonomous feature?
- rayiner 8y ago
- _ph_ 8y agoSome features of self driving, not the whole package. Eg. a better parking assistant.