4 ms·
That's not too compelling to me. One of the principles of a jury is that it is of your peers, which implies that to some extent you do know them and they know y
by hammock 8y ago
That's not too compelling to me. One of the principles of a jury is that it is of your peers, which implies that to some extent you do know them and they know you. A jury of perfect strangers unrelated to you is not constitutional.
- duxup 8y ago>A jury of perfect strangers unrelated to you is not constitutional. Is there actually a legal case that can be won to be made there?
- hammock 8y agoBatson vs Kentucky, 1986. The dismissal of all the black jurors on a black defendant's jury was ruled against. (And if it wasn't clear earlier, when I say "unrelated" of course I'm not talking about familial relations, but social relations)
- lmkg 8y ago> jury is that it is of your peers, which implies that to some extent you do know them and they know you Does not follow. I'm not aware of any context where that's part of what "peer" means. > A jury of perfect strangers unrelated to you is not constitutional. Generally speaking, if you're not a perfect stranger, you're kicked off a jury for conflict of interest. A "jury of one's peers" means people in the same social class as you, i.e. a jury that is not biased against you. The word "peer" is a hold-over from English society with more pronounced social classes, and is meant strictly as a counterbalance against those social classes. Note that the Consitution itself doesn't actually contain the word "peer," but rather uses the phrase "impartial jury."
- hammock 8y agoIf they are in the same social class as you, then you know that about them. Not sure how that refutes my argument.
- bilbo0s 8y agoJust to be evenhanded here, I suspect that in most criminal cases the jurors are likely NOT in the same social class as the defendant. That said, having jurors be people you know seems a little unfair too. So a jury of perfect strangers seems greatly unfair in the postulated context of asymmetric privacy, and a jury of friends seems unfair as it's possible they would let you off regardless of evidence. Problem is, asymmetric privacy is a reality today. So, yeah, tough problem.
- jogjayr 8y ago> to some extent you do know them and they know you If a juror actually knew you (or you knew them) wouldn't that be grounds for their dismissal from the jury due to a possibility of bias? Obviously if a public figure or celebrity is on trial, the jurors will usually know of the accused, but still not necessarily know them.