4 ms·
How about: "That's none of your damn business"?
by mpweiher 8y ago
How about: "That's none of your damn business"?
- nothrabannosir 8y agoNot a convincing argument. You need people to agree with you if you want to win in a democracy. This attitude, while entirely understandable, will leave you alone and naked.
- mpweiher 8y agoIt's not an argument. It is a statement. > win in a democracy This is why fundamental rights such as this are enshrined in constitutions and not up for grab by normal political processes. An important aspect of liberal democracies is protection of the minorities. The majority can't just do what it wants, there are limits.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoIf the majority is big enough it bloody well can. And it will. Protection of minorities only exists because the majority wants it. Not that it is relevant in this conversation: “people who value privacy” are not a group considered a minority who need protecting from the majority. If you want people to help you protect your privacy, you need to convince them, plain and simple. Asking the electorate for help in electing privacy conscious officials and telling them to fuck off when asked why is going to get us absolutely nowhere. That’s the plain truth of our privacy debate today: we are losing, and we need help but we can’t convince people to help us. Ideas of civil liberty are not cutting it. Evidently. If you need any more convincing, look at how the public sees Snowden. And weep.
- everdev 8y agoYes, that's the surface response, but what's deeper than that? Ultimately I think it's a rational fear of being ostracized (or worse) for having believed or done something deemed by the group to be "not OK". The right to privacy shoes us to explore the nature of ourselves without harming others and without putting us in danger of violating social norms. The counter argument might be that with more visibility and openness, the more tolerant we all might be if each others faults, but unfortunately history does not seem to demonstrate this.
- matz1 8y agoInformation wants to be free, its make more sense to promote openness and transparency. LGBT is gaining acceptance, one of the reason is I believe its because its more visible.
- Bakary 8y agoThere should still be some way for individuals to have the possibility to experience different facets of themselves. To give a stereotypical example, a middle-aged software programmer might want to experiment with psychedelic substances once in a while without the hassle of having to explain it to people in more mainstream spheres of his life. If every encounter has to be accounted for and recorded, this introduces significant mental strain and ends up impoverishing our lives.
- matz1 8y agoSo the issue is, in this context, to be able to experiment with psychedelic substances without hassle. Why do I have to explain it to people in the first place? Maybe because lack of information of knowledge about psychedelic substances ? More transparency and openness can help. Another example, Why I do I feel the need to close the bathroom door when I take a dump ? Because it considered taboo or weird. But if more and more people take a dump with the door open, it will be less weird. Its a hassle too to have to keep things private.
- Bakary 8y agoI mean it more in the sense of different social worlds. For instance you might relate differently to your relatives than with your friends. You might act in a certain way with some friends and not with other circles without it being duplicitous, but rather different facets of your identity that could not find an adequate expression if every aspect of your life was socially interlinked with every other. Even if norms change to be far more permissive, there will still be issues with this. Besides, norms are never that permissive in absolute terms since some form of hierarchy quickly sets itself up in response to changing circumstances. For instance in some past contexts a young man might want to hide his promiscuity and adventurous experiences, whereas in some modern contexts he might want to hide his lack of promiscuity and adventurous (instagrammable?) experiences.