2 ms·
There's a difference between the stated purpose of flashing, and how it is used in practice. > Flash orders give some 3rd party the opportunity to fill your or
by beagle3 16y ago
There's a difference between the stated purpose of flashing, and how it is used in practice.
> Flash orders give some 3rd party the opportunity to fill your order.
Alternative way to look at it: Flashing advertises your order to several parties, and gives them one full second to front run you at ARCA, where the best price currently is. (Oh, and they have the option to fill it directly at ARCAs price immediately).
> If they decline, your order is routed to ARCA where it is filled at $50.01 (and ARCA receives the commission), and you pay a routing fee.
Except, one of the guys the order was flashed to, (who declined) has already bought that 50.01 at ARCA, so now the NBBO price is 50.02; incidentally, by a pure coincidence, it's being sold by the same guy who just bought it 50.01.
I've played the HFT game for the last 10 years. Don't believe a single word of the official propaganda about why something is employed; It's all there to generate more traffic for the exchanges; e.g., in the case described above, ARCA gets two transaction fees instead of one, and the broker gets their routing fee AND some kickback from the flashee.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFirst of all, flashing gives one party a user-configurable time period (typically 30ms) to fill your order. A full second is nonsense. Also, the person placing the order can turn it off. Second, the motives in your hypothetical don't make sense. Direct Edge is the venue allowing flash orders. ARCA gets two commissions, but DE gets nothing. Why would DE want to give commissions to their competitors? And if this happened to any significant degree, why would customers continue to set their "please flash me" flag to True? Lastly, front running based on flash trading is illegal, not to mention pretty easy to prove in court. And it's pretty easy to find people doing it based solely on an electronic search of the tapes. If it happened to any significant degree, how come the SEC didn't find it?
- beagle3 16y ago> A full second is nonsense. Also, the person placing the order can turn it off. If I'm not mistaken (and I might be, it's been awhile since I looked), Interactive Brokers were flashing their clients orders up until recently as well; they didn't call it flashing, they called it "smart routing" -- but if you opted out, you paid routing fees whereas if you opted in, those fees would often be waived. > Direct Edge is the venue allowing flash orders. ARCA gets two commissions, but DE gets nothing. DE is the last flashing exchange. They get their fees if they fill the 2nd order by the flashee, or routing fees if they direct to ARCA. The only way they get nothing is if nothing ever gets traded in the entire transaction except the first, which usually is NOT the case. > If it happened to any significant degree, how come the SEC didn't find it? Are you asking that seriously? The SEC is in bed with the industry. They don't look for anything, and they don't find anything. (google "Harry Markopolos" and "Madoff" if you want an insight into how the SEC works. Read ZeroHedge and Denninger to see DAILY examples of undeniable fraud and insider trading that the SEC never looks at. Seriously, if you trust the SEC to do anything, you shouldn't be in finance)
- lrm242 16y ago> If I'm not mistaken (and I might be, it's been awhile since I looked), Interactive Brokers were flashing their clients orders up until recently as well; they didn't call it flashing, they called it "smart routing" -- but if you opted out, you paid routing fees whereas if you opted in, those fees would often be waived. IB has two types of routing, SMART routing and direct routing. SMART routing allows IB to seek the best price possible in the various liquidity sources it knows about. Direct routing sends your order directly to an exchange, where it may be matched, booked, or routed according to NMS rules. This has 0 to do with flash orders.