3 ms·
OK, so they found that "the spread or yield of newly issued local municipal bonds increased" after local papers closed. But from the title, I was expecting some
by mirimir 8y ago
OK, so they found that "the spread or yield of newly issued local municipal bonds increased" after local papers closed. But from the title, I was expecting some actual data on local government spending. But no, it's all based on borrowing costs. The stuff about local papers having acted as watchdog agents is just interpretation.
Here's the abstract of the study cited in the article:
> Local newspapers hold their governments accountable. We examine the effect of local newspaper closures on public finance for local governments. Following a newspaper closure, we find municipal borrowing costs increase by 5 to 11 basis points in the long run. Identification tests illustrate that these results are not being driven by deteriorating local economic conditions. The loss of monitoring that results from newspaper closures is associated with increased government inefficiencies, including higher likelihoods of costly advance refundings and negotiated issues, and higher government wages, employees, and tax revenues.
- matt4077 8y agoBorrowing costs obviously are (part of) government spending. But, more importantly, the idea is to use the market as a sort of proxy, or research instrument: it's the best known structure to judge the financial future of various entities, including governments. Borrowing costs, in an efficient market, perfectly represent society's consensus opinion on those cities' financial future. While it's possible that markets aren't perfect in pricing these bonds, they are almost certainly better at it than any single research team could ever hope to be.
- Nasrudith 8y agoUntil they aren't anyway. Look at the AAA rated junk mortgage backed securities. Or Theranos - due diligence from a biology processor making money on the side could have told you that not all blood is sourced equal and the statistical minimum sizes to be able to detect certain components of low concentration accurately. Attempting to screen blood noninvasively would be more possible and that is a far harder problem that would call for several chained breakthroughs. Forget a research team - one person could beat the market without so much as cracking a book! A perfect market requires perfect knowledge which in addition to requiring science fiction predictive abilities would have very weird implications given causality issues. Like loans being marginal in rates or not granted (if you know ahead of time they will be good for it is guaranteed profit and everyone with capital could give a small but net winning offer). If they knew they would lose nobody would give a lossy loan. The stock market would be bizarrely illiquid or obsolete as funding is already guaranteed. Few would sell for what they see as a worse investment. Being able to tell if loaning five billion to an eccentric scientist would pay off or not. Interesting hypotheticals aside it is important to remember that while good at managing supply and demand usually the market is not an oracle nor a god. Going against what everyone thinks is worthless is one way to strike it rich.
- notahacker 8y agoYeah. I'd take a lot of convincing that they hadn't just failed to specify adequate identification tests, since local newspaper closures and raised municipal borrowing costs are both clearly and obviously linked to local economic conditions, and the potential linkage between municipal bond rates and local newspaper scrutiny far more questionable.
- Eridrus 8y agoThe article links to the paper, where this is the number one concern they address. They seem to have a bunch of different ways of slicing the data to prove their effect, e.g. pairing demographically similar districts, looking at newspaper shutdowns likely induced by Craigslist, looking at number of newspapers in a district, looking at distance of political center to economic center. I don't know if this is a complete list of things that economists would look at, so I don't know if they're cherry-picking good ways to slice the data, but they have 47 pages of trying to convince you it's right if you want to dig that deep :) There could obviously be other explanations, e.g. markets thinking that less information rich environments are just riskier because they won't know what's going on, but they seem to have been fairly thorough in establishing the link between newspapers closing and bond rates increasing.
- mirimir 8y agoYes, they do lots of checking. But still, I don't see anything clear beyond the association of newspaper shutdowns and increasing bond rates. Nothing about mechanism except speculative argument. This is very much like epidemiology. And the literature is loaded with retrospective studies that found correlations which turned out to reflect selection bias and/or confounding. You really need prospective studies with carefully matched controls.