5 ms·
Gotta feel bad for SourceForge the new owners reversed the malpractices of its previous owners immediately and yet the damage is permanently done. I'll never un
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
Gotta feel bad for SourceForge the new owners reversed the malpractices of its previous owners immediately and yet the damage is permanently done. I'll never understand why some think distributing spyware / malware for money is even remotely right in any way, shape, and form. How is any of it legal half the time...
- swalladge 8y agoI find it slightly odd that sourceforge is so highly shunned after the malware incidents, while various other large companies [eg. microsoft (dodgy behaviour in skype, etc.), facebook (spying, selling data), lenovo (superfish), etc.] have been caught doing similar dodgy things and yet it feels like the general community has forgiven or at least grudgingly overlooking them. May or may not be true - that's just the feel I'm getting.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoIf they start buying up some startups and giving YC an exit or two, the community may forgive SourceForge.
- xyrouter 8y agoWe also need to think a little about how the times were. Sourceforge rose to popularity in the early 2000s. Free and open source software (FOSS) was not just a matter of pragmatism or convenience. It was an ideology, a philosophy, and a movement strongly pushed forward by FSF, Open Source Initiative, various LUGs, and various special interest groups. Open source enthusiasts used to have very active and influential LUGs all throughout the world. There used to be free and open source software conferences all over the world with the sole agenda of increasing open source awareness among the general public. In those years, most of the developers who chose to host their projects on Sourceforge strongly believed in this ideology. GPLv2 was the most popular open source license then. Given all this, it makes sense that those early users who held freedom of software to be sacred were very pissed when Sourceforge decided to bundle closed source adware into the binaries of these open source projects without the explicit permission of these open source developers. Times have changed a lot since then. GPLv2/v3 license is now considered too restrictive and the MIT license is more popular. Most of the tech community understands the concept of open source more or less. The movement in favor of software freedom has begun to lose momentum. Open source software makes a lot of business sense, so we don't need the push for open source software anymore like we used to in the early 2000s. Even some people like me who once would run nothing but completely free operating system with free tools have now begun to use proprietary drivers because as we have grown older, got busy, with kids and family, the time spent tinkering with open source drivers is not worth it, we would rather use something that just works. When we use Microsoft and Facebook we know what we are getting into and most of us are more or less okay with it. It's different times and different kinds of users. That explains why Microsoft and Facebook do not get penalized as heavily as Sourceforge did. Sourceforge violated something that was held sacred during those times. Microsoft and Facebook have no notion of sacred-anything.
- dpark 8y agoSourceForge gets shunned first because it’s easy. There are lots of great alternatives to SourceForge. SourceForge was already on the decline before their adware bundling fiasco so continuing to not use SourceForge is no burden for most devs. Second, what SourceForge did was worse than your examples. They modified trusted applications to add essentially a malware payload. This is worse than Facebook collecting too much data and being shady with it. SourceForge was installing spyware on machines without permission. This betrayed the trust of both users and publishers and even damaged users’ trust in those publishers. The only one of your examples that is comparable is Lenovo’s Superfish mess, and in that case they only betrayed users, not publishers. Not that it actually makes it better, but it changes the impact to Lenovo. Disclosure: Microsoft employee.
- JohnTHaller 8y agoIt's worth noting that SourceForge didn't modify trusted applications. They switched their download buttons on the site to download an "installer app" by default that would act as the installer, offer bundleware, and then live download the actual app installer as part of the install process. Apps like GIMP etc were never, to my knowledge, modified to bundle GIMP and bundleware within a single installer. Source: I was hosted on SourceForge at the time and approached about participating in DevShare. I researched it extensively and saved copies of the stub installers for things like GIMP as part of that research.
- loganabbott 8y agoMy company had nothing to do with it, but it's worth noting you're one of the few people who actually remembers the actual non-revisionist history.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoThanks for sharing the highly relevant piece of information. It always bothered me someone had to go through the effort to download the original source and rebuild the projects, just the thought of all the effort taken to do that... It seemed odd, I can imagine some projects having some obscure build processes (it happens) and the amount of effort taken to add in their spyware installer seemed a little crazy to me.
- duxup 8y agoThey had to know when they bought it. Can't feel that bad for them, they knew.
- exikyut 8y agoHmm. I wonder what their agenda is. Not assuming absolute malice, but I am really curious.
- duxup 8y agoI wonder too. A legacy brand sometimes has value, or at least is valued, but this one has a lot of tarnish. They're still around (surprising) so maybe they're kinda ... making something money wise? I dunno...
- loganabbott 8y agoYeah we're profitable now without DevShare. Lotta people hated what happened to SourceForge, including me. That's why I bought it and removed DevShare.
- pknopf 8y agoThis reminds me of MySpace. What's going on over there now?
- loganabbott 8y agoOur agenda was removing bundled adware and improving user experience. Mystery solved.
- mandeepj 8y agoNew owners should have rebranded it to drop the baggage
- loganabbott 8y agoOther than these uninformed HN threads, most people can distinguish between the owners that did the bad stuff, and the owners that bought it specifically to undo the bad stuff.
- loganabbott 8y agoWhy would you feel bad for us? We removed the malpractices right away, became profitable, improved the experience for over a million daily users, and are growing at a rate not seen since before the problems. I'd say we have the opposite of a problem. A few random armchair quarterbacks on Hackers News aren't gonna get us down.
- craftyguy 8y ago... which is exactly what you're expected to say. It's extremely rare to come across any meaningful projects these days that decide to associate themselves with sourceforge.
- loganabbott 8y agoThat just tells me your breadth of knowledge of the open source landscape is limited. You can scroll down this thread to see plenty of big projects still at SourceForge.
- craftyguy 8y agoYea, publicly attacking folks is a sure way to get yourself more users! /s
- loganabbott 8y agoMan, the definition of the word "attack" has really changed recently.
- true_religion 8y agoYou said his company was permanently cursed. He showed up to cheerfully deny the curse existed, then you called him a liar and said no one important used Sourceforge. Now you say he is “publically attacking” you just by saying you are wrong. Ok. I am going to give him the benefit of the doubt and not believe you.
- 8y ago
- craftyguy 8y agoI feel bad for them because they (naiively?) bought a sinking ship.
- loganabbott 8y agoI feel bad for you because you (naively?) have no idea about what you're talking about. We bought the ship to save it. You can give us flak if you want, but we felt strongly enough about the projects on SourceForge to put our neck on the line to save it. Didn't see anyone else doing that, despite their complaints.
- craftyguy 8y agoYea, publicly attacking folks is a sure way to get yourself more users! /s
- loganabbott 8y agoI don't think "attacking" means what you think it means. Why do you keep posting the same comment over and over?