3 ms·
"Being curious or "hormonally charged" seems normal, but people seriously looking to have sex in college seem to be in the minority. Otherwise, there would be a
by jseliger 16y ago
"Being curious or "hormonally charged" seems normal, but people seriously looking to have sex in college seem to be in the minority. Otherwise, there would be an orgy every weekend, right?"
If you replace "people" with "men," the answer is probably yes. Men on average tend to seek out far more sexual partners than women do; I remember one study that had attractive, opposite-sex college students approach other students and offer to sleep with them. 75% of males approached said yes; 0 females did. I think the study is discussed in Dan Ariely's _Predictably Irrational_. As Roy Baumeister points out in his book _What Are Men Good For_, famous men often sleep with many, many random young women, and appreciate it when young women offer them sex; famous women seldom do the same.
As for women, they are the sex that has to invest more in offspring; in virtually every species studied, the choosier sex is the one that has to invest more; see, for example, Robert Trivers' famous work, or Geoffrey Miller in _The Mating Mind_:
"As David Buss has emphasized, human sex differences are most apparent in short-term mating. Men are motivated to have short-term sexual flings with multiple partners than women are. Women are much choosier than men in the short term. Short-term mating is exciting and sexy, but it is not necessarily where sexual selection has the greatest effect" (95).
"Human males are generally not as choosy about short-term affairs as females. There is very little opportunity cost to short-term mating for men. It does not exclude other sexual options. But men get much choosier about medium- and long-term relationships, because their opportunity costs increase dramatically. If they are in a sexual relationship with one woman, it is very difficult to sustain a sexual relationship with another woman. They cannot give both their full attention. They must make choices—sexual choices" (95).
Note: this doesn't mean women aren't very sexual. They are. See, for example, Randy Thornhill's _The Evolution of Human Female Sexuality_. But they don't tend to seek out as many random encounters or as many concurrent, unknown partners as men do. Most sexually mature women are "seriously looking to have sex" because they like it as much or more as men do. But they aren't, on average, looking to have it as indiscriminately as men do.
The equilibrium isn't for "an orgy every weekend." There isn't a stable equilibrium if the number of males and females and fluctuating; for more on this and how small numbers of people influence mating/dating markets, see Tim Harford's _The Logic of Life_.
Note too that variations among individuals are greater than variations between groups, so those of you who are about to tell stories about your guy friend who is asexual and your female friend who hooks up with a new guy every weekend are not being inconsistent with the above, which has been established empirically through a variety of means discussed in the books referenced.
- sp332 16y ago> 75% of males approached said yes; 0 females did. > Note too that variations among individuals are greater than variations between groups This is actually my main problem with the idea. A few women will be on board with the campaign, but most women will feel like they're being "sold" to the men without really liking that idea. Secondarily, doubling the women/men ratio won't come close to doubling any particular guy's chances of having sex. So it's unfair and misleading to almost everyone.
- jewbacca 16y agoI agree that it would be degrading to market a college based on this, but I'd also imagine that in an environment with a severe gender imbalance there would be people of the over-represented gender (of either gender) who would welcome the idea of a greater pool of potential partners in that environment (perhaps not enough to be willing to be "sold", as you've said). > doubling the women/men ratio won't come close to doubling any particular guy's chances of having sex While doubling the women/men ratio won't necessarily double any particular guy's chances of having sex, it will certainly increase it, and I'm certain you're familiar with the lengths people of either gender will go to to increase their chances of ending up in their ideal mating situation (straightforward sex or otherwise) by even a vanishingly or imaginarily tiny amount. And a favorable gender ratio won't effect a player's chances of having sex all that much, but for an average or socially-stunted guy, it will certainly increase his chances. For one thing, a greater proportion of his interactions will be with women, increasing his chances by raw bayesian exposure, as well as by the greater socialization to women he will accrue. I do not reject the stereotype we all know, of guys who spend too much of their lives in environments with the opposite gender imbalance, as applicable in a large minority of cases; though I would be interested in hearing your experience and reasoning if you disagree. As well, as rare in this environment, these men will be more individually valuable to women seeking male partners than they would otherwise be (for whatever benefits of a mating/partnership would apply to the people involved, and could be categorized as valuable). I don't think this concept of "value" would have as much of an effect on the difference in the situation as the 1st reason, but it would exist. The degree to which it would be multiplied from what it would be in a gender-neutral environment would still be dependent on each individual, and a clueless total loss would probably still not get laid or dated or tied-up and pooed on or whatever they're looking for, but it would absolutely make each more appealing to some degree. And (if you are willing to grant that confidence is sexy in many cases), any experience which increases a person's experience in and competence with sex and relationships feeds back on itself, and increases the likelihood of more experience. So I think it would be pretty reasonable for most people to prefer a gender environment which is favourable to them. Of course, your expectation of the quality of an institution that would directly market itself based on this, and of the quality of the character of the people for whom this was not sufficiently distasteful to turn them away, might offset the benefits of the advertised gender environment. But having been an 18-year-old male and having known 18-year-old males, I do not think this is sufficient to nullify the appeal; and were this imbalance just known and not pimped, it would not be an entirely trivial factor in someone's choice of university. NB: Pronoun "his" used for readability's sake, though if you'd judge what I've described to be equally applicable to women who are attracted to men in the reciprocal environment, substitute the gender-neutral pronoun of your choice. I also initially included gay women with the men above, but I suppose the dynamic is totally different for them -- the people you're attracted to are also your potential competition. Holy shit.