7 ms·
>PG: Yes, so then I was reflecting on the universe expanding. We know that it is and can measure it, by the way time is operating, or by the way we see a star e
by andrepd 8y ago
>PG: Yes, so then I was reflecting on the universe expanding. We know that it is and can measure it, by the way time is operating, or by the way we see a star exploding far away. For various reasons, when a physicist tells me that the universe is expanding, I say “ok, let’s go back to the dance floor.” The dance floor is getting bigger, what does that mean? It means that time has to slow down.
>FF: And that is exactly what the physicists tell us is happening.
>PG: Yes, but when I talk to my son Marlowe and he says the summer went by very fast, and in my childhood the summer went by really slow—what if it’s really true that time is actually speeding up? One can say, oh, you’re just imagining it; of course I’m imagining it, but what if it’s really happening? In other words, for the universe to keep expanding, maybe time has to go faster too, in order to keep up.
>FF: It certainly feels that way.
>PG: Many of us have that feeling. Yesterday I was 20. Where did all the years go? “How can it go by so fast,” we say. But what if time is actually speeding up? If everything is changing at the same speed, there is no way to measure it. The summer of 1947 went by very slowly for me, and this summer flew by for both Marlowe and me. What I suggest is that these are not subjective, but rather objective experiences. It’s also a little terrifying. What if 1,000 years from now, a life span felt like it was only a few days?
Such quackery. Why do people feel it's valid to come up with fantastical conjectures about physics with absolutely no reason to do so?
- poirier 8y agoBecause he's an _artist_ interpreting his experience of the physics of time.
- andrepd 8y agoBut he is not interpreting his experience. If I understood him correctly, he is claiming his differing perception of time vs his grandchildren is due to some physical phenomenon. PS: Which is a funny thing, since this is another article trending right now at HN: https://www.wired.com/story/these-physicists-watched-a-clock-tick-for-14-years-straight/ https://www.wired.com/story/these-physicists-watched-a-clock...
- icebraining 8y agoI'd say he's wondering rather than claiming. Hence the use of "maybe" and question marks.
- whiddershins 8y agoOf all the hacker news comments I’ve ever read, yours made me feel the worst. One of the greatest living artists talking about the subjectivity of perception and you refer to it as quackery. It hurts my heart.
- kevinwang 8y agoYeah, but he was making some pseudoscientific conjecture about the objectivity of time and using "expansion of the universe" to justify it, not merely the subjectivity of time passage. I mean, it's an interesting hot take, but it's definitely reminiscent of pseudoscience quackery.
- braythwayt 8y agoAlso, his so-called "music." It's just basic arithmetic. Scales, for example, can be reduced to a simple 12-bit number: https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/ https://ianring.com/musictheory/scales/ All this fluff about a "major" scale and its "modes" when we could just say "2741" and derive other relationships from rotating bits and a few other simple relationships. Everything else, like the "subjective feeling of a Persian Scale" is just quackery. It's just someone who doesn't understand numbers making up nonsense words.
- ggg9990 8y agoHehe... nothing more HN than putting “music” in square quotes to summarily dismiss it. Please link ur Soundcloud
- braythwayt 8y agoYou got me! I am not a musician, I'm a bassist.
- lainga 8y agoactually nothing more HN than expressing doubt or disagreement by demanding credentials out of someone
- 8y ago
- lowtolerance 8y agoWhy does anyone do anything creative, if it’s not necessary to do so? Who are you to say that their feeling regarding the nature of a particular phenomenon is invalid?
- andrepd 8y agoI'm not sure I follow. He has no authority nor knowledge nor evidence to make those claims. Last year I had the immense privilege of attending a concert of perhaps the greatest piano virtuoso alive today. I was enthralled. Then after the concert finished, he expounded his views on why sound is a divine phenomenon, and that the wave theory of sound is a conspiracy peddled by scientists, easily disproven by simple experiments, as well as a confusing argument of why the sun revolves around the earth. Am I supposed to take this seriously because it's a, how do you put it, a creative view? I reiterate, nothing about my opinion of his performance changed due to this; those are entirely different concerns.
- sincerely 8y agoSometimes it's interesting to hear what incredibly talented creative people think, from their perspective, because their understanding of the world likely in some way influences their work. That doesn't mean we should accept it as factual of course (especially in cases where it is trivially untrue to people who are educated in the field) but it still has some interest to other creatives, etc. I don't think you're supposed to "take it seriously" i.e. consider it a genuine contender for an objective truth but instead think about how it may inform a creative process to believe in a world with different fundamental principles etc. Or at least that's how I interpret this kind of material. But I tend to give everybody way too much credit and maybe this is being peddled as hack psuedoscience but hey, death of the author ;P
- khazhoux 8y agoPro-tip: don't look to artists to learn about physics. You called out trivially refutable points of this interview. What I find more interesting is the connection (if any) between this disconnect from reality, and the genius of his music. I've come to believe that there's a reason so many great creative artists are not "normal". If they were, they'd just do normal things and get normal jobs.
- whatshisface 8y agoIt's not a disconnect from reality, older people do actually feel like time is "going faster." It's a common perception that might have something to do with the fact that a year is 100% of your life when you're 1 and 1% of your life when you're 100. There's a big stack of effects that reached all the way from SR to perception.
- homonculus1 8y agoGlass is claiming the opposite, that it's not subjective. That is disconnected.
- aoner 8y agoThere is actually a somewhat explain able effect going on with the perception of time vs age: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_perception#Changes_with_age https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_perception#Changes_with... Psychologists have found that the subjective perception of the passing of time tends to speed up with increasing age in humans. This often causes people to increasingly underestimate a given interval of time as they age. This fact can likely be attributed to a variety of age-related changes in the aging brain, such as the lowering in dopaminergic levels with older age; however, the details are still being debated.[51][52][53] In an experimental study involving a group of subjects aged between 19 and 24 and a group between 60 and 80, the participants' abilities to estimate 3 minutes of time were compared. The study found that an average of 3 minutes and 3 seconds passed when participants in the younger group estimated that 3 minutes had passed, whereas the older group's estimate for when 3 minutes had passed came after an average of 3 minutes and 40 seconds. One day to an 11-year-old would be approximately 1/4,000 of their life, while one day to a 55-year-old would be approximately 1/20,000 of their life. This helps to explain why a random, ordinary day may therefore appear longer for a young child than an adult.
- majos 8y ago"We read, we learn, we experience, we make adjustments. Then one day we reach the point where all the necessary distances have been set, all the necessary systems have been put in place. That is when time begins to pick up speed. It no longer meets any obstacles, everything is set, time races through our lives, the days pass by in a flash and before we know what is happening we are forty, fifty, sixty..." (Knausgaard, My Struggle, Book 1)
- owens99 8y agoI've heard this called the Logarithmic Theory of Time.
- CalRobert 8y agoPhysics is something that is fascinating to anyone with a bit of curiosity, intimately part of the human experience on every scale, and difficult to work through in its more advanced (or nuanced) features. I'd rather he came up with fantastical conjectures than felt like it was forbidden to him. As long as people take it as the musings of a musician and he never presents them as supported by evidence, of course. Also, "objective experience" is kind of a misnomer I suppose. Is "experience" inherently subjective? Hell, actual physicists allow themselves to flirt with non-falsifiable ideas. Regardless, I found it to be apt, and a better description than most of the changing experience of time as we age - and also, perhaps, as our culture changes as well.
- coldtea 8y ago>Such quackery. Why do people feel it's valid to come up with fantastical conjectures about physics with absolutely no reason to do so? Because people have inner lives and feelings and dreams and imaginations. The explanations given by physics are not the be all end all for their needs.
- whatshisface 8y ago>The explanations given by physics are not the be all end all for their needs. If someone needs to service some kind of inner desire by making confused conjectures so be it, but let's not treat them like a sage for doing it.