3 ms·
I've always felt that charging money for software is dumb. I, as a programmer, think about saying to other people that they cannot use a piece of software that
by carapace 8y ago
I've always felt that charging money for software is dumb.
I, as a programmer, think about saying to other people that they cannot use a piece of software that is already written unless they give me money, is a damn ridiculous idea.
Software is wealth.
If I had a gold coin that had the property that I could give it to you and still have it, and that both coins would increase in value when I did, and that you and I both can repeat the process endlessly, then there is no good reason not to give out the coin copies freely.
One model of a computer is a set of automatic functions that each solve some human problem or need. We should all be working together to expand that library of functions as rapidly as responsibly possible.
Attempting to extract value from the economy per-copy is retarding the whole system. It's a selfish local optimization. My basic argument is that we should use computers and software to globally maximize human happiness and contentment, and avoid local optima.
tl;dr: "Don't be greedy."
So how do you make money? First, if you want a lot of money, open a bank. Let's narrow the question: How do I make a living? House, picket fence, family, doge and qat, gotta have a car, etc... Let's put a ceiling on it, even if it's high. Let's also avoid discussion of financial meta-games, you save and invest, so if you avoid misfortune you're more or less going to be okay, right?
So, how are programmers supposed to make enough money to live the dream if we don't charge per copy?
First of all, the best way to do it since the dawn of the internet is simple: Get 10,000 fans who love you and sell them stuff. (Or just ask them to support you, like the Zig creator is doing.) This is a simple, easy, universally accessible method that's pretty much guaranteed to work.
Second best way: get paid to solve new problems (one thing I am not saying is that you shouldn't charge people to work on a problem you otherwise wouldn't work on, that's fine. Charging people to use your solution after it's been developed is the stupid thing to do, IMO.)
Third(-ish, this list isn't precise nor prescriptive) teach people. I think that learning the Turing Machine trick makes people think better, and learning to program obviously empowers them. (I remember the first time I used an iPad, I thought "this isn't a computer, it's a mall in your hand") The information revolution is still happening, and people need your help to navigate it and reap the full benefits.
Fourth, here's the meta-most: You should be living in a very-low-overhead way right now anyway. We have to learn to live in harmony with Nature or we are about to tank our whole civilization. Go outside, it's June, where are all the bugs?
- decebalus1 8y ago> doge and qat I'm not a native English speaker. What are those?
- cesarb 8y agoDoge is a common Internet mispronouncing of "dog" (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doge_%28meme%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doge_%28meme%29), so I'm guessing that the other one is likewise for "cat".
- dman 8y agoI agree with large parts of what you are saying - the law of scarcity does not apply to software. As a free software advocate however there are a lot of subtle questions to which I have no answer, listing them here in case others can chime in with thoughts a. Entire categories of software (debuggers, databases, compilers) are now in a state where we have trained users to expect them for free. If you like to spend most of your time writing software then the easiest way to work on such software now is to work for a large company who needs to develop such software to solve their business needs. How do we create solutions such that small indie developers can make a living building software in these categories. b. Even software that is immensely successful at getting industrial adoption struggles to get any revenue from its users. (OpenSSL / Numpy / Pandas / ZeroMQ etc). Inside a megacorp the person using the software faces an uphill battle fighting a bureaucracy to pay for software that is "free". How do we create platforms / delivery systems where large users of open source can pay for the services. c. Our collective inability to solve the basic economic problem of delivering a stable revenue for free software has unfortunate side effects where software moves into the cloud or becomes a service because that is the only way to get users to pay on a recurring basis. In my mind this is unfortunate because it lessens the amount of control on execution that the end user has. d. Developer tools still strongly resemble what was available in the 70s / 80s. I suspect some of this has to do with the fact that there is no easy business model for building developer tools.
- afarrell 8y ago> Charging people to use your solution after it's been developed is the stupid thing to do, IMO I think this is the core of what I disagree with in your post. Imagine 3 scenarios: 1) I have a problem that I'd like solved and I go searching for a solution. After a while, I come across a reddit post where someone says "oh, you're trying to reticulate splines? You should buy ReticulatorPro for $50. I use it and its great!" I see that someone built it 3 years ago and I go and download the 1 month free trial, I'm happy with it and in 1 month, $50 comes out of my bank account. 2) I have a problem that I'd like solved and I go searching for a solution. After a while, I come across a reddit post where someone says "oh, you're trying to reticulate splines? Someone is trying to fundraise to build it and they seem pretty serious." I see that they've been trying for 6 months and they are 70% of the way toward their goal. So I pitch in $50, but then I'm waiting as the uncertainty of fundraising and software schedules takes its toll. 18 months later the solution is released. I am less happy. 3) I have a problem that I'd like solved and I go searching for a solution. After a while, I come across a reddit post where someone says "oh, you're trying to reticulate splines? Someone is trying to fundraise to build that." I see that someone built it 1 year ago and I go and download it for free and I am happy. In the current world, all of these are possible. In the world you propose, option #1 is impossible. I argue that a world with Option #1 available is a better world for everyone. Why? Because in the world of option #2/#3, the only time period during which the developer can raise money is before the product has been created. That means only products with sufficiently good pre-development marketing can be successful. (note: "Get 10,000 fans who love you" isn't "easy" but at least moderately difficult.) In the world of #1, someone who isn't good at pre-development marketing but is good at building a product and using the quality of the product to do post-development marketing can succeed. I want a world where someone can build a good product and get funding mostly on the strength of their product. > teach people Is a valuable but different skill from building products.