3 ms·
Because it's "reason," an online libertarian "thinkpiece." This is the ideal story for them: it involves regulation (a priori bad), and it's regulation concerni
by woodruffw 8y ago
Because it's "reason," an online libertarian "thinkpiece." This is the ideal story for them: it involves regulation (a priori bad), and it's regulation concerning speech directed at minors (perfect for painting anybody left of them as illiberal).
Note that it's already illegal to harass people, and NY already has anti-bullying laws for minors[1]. This new law is the legal extension of existing protections into a domain that minors already inhabit. In other words, this law brings existing protections into the 21st century.
Note, also, that the standard for prosecution under this new law is precise: the minor's status as a minor must be known by the harasser, and the harassment must be part of a repeated course of action.
Volokh's examples (except for maybe the first) conveniently gloss over these conditions. His third, fourth, and fifth examples also conveniently muddle the legal process: nobody is a criminal until convicted, and the fact that any group of people "can be prosecuted" is not any sort of evidence of either guilt or innocence.
[1]: https://www.stopbullying.gov/laws/new-york/index.html https://www.stopbullying.gov/laws/new-york/index.html
- true_religion 8y agoI don't understand why existing protections must be brought into the 21st century. Was it not already illegal to harass minors, regardless of how you do it? Were people able to say 'Oh, I only wrote words about it, and didn't verbalize it so it doesn't count'?
- woodruffw 8y agoIt was already illegal, but poorly scoped. We now know how effective of a medium the internet can be for harassment, and our legislation should reflect that. Mechanically, this sort of legislation is no different from proposed modernizations of things like the CFAA.