3 ms·
> but this does not preclude imagining a p-zombie, any more than a knowledge of anatomy and aerodynamics precludes imagining a dragon. It kind of does. The arg
by naasking 8y ago
> but this does not preclude imagining a p-zombie, any more than a knowledge of anatomy and aerodynamics precludes imagining a dragon.
It kind of does. The argument goes: if you can imagine a p-zombie, then in your mind it's possible that consciousness is not tied to physical qualities. Therefore, physicalism would necessarily be false.
It took me awhile to accept this, but the solution is simple: p-zombies can't exist because I can't imagine them. And this is because consciousness must serve a functional purpose, and so p-zombies would be distinguishable from humans.
- aninhumer 8y ago>in your mind it's possible that consciousness is not tied to physical qualities. Therefore, physicalism would necessarily be false. I mean, yes? I tend to assume physicalism, but I don't take it as axiomatic. >And this is because consciousness must serve a functional purpose I don't see why that has to be true?
- naasking 8y ago> I don't see why that has to be true? It must be true if you accept physicalism.
- mikeash 8y agoWhy is the ability to imagine something at all relevant? I can imagine a world where there are no physical laws, everything is entirely random, and by an astonishing coincidence it just so happens to behave exactly like the world we observe in every single way. Does that mean it's possible that there are no physical laws and everything is completely random? Strictly speaking yes, it is possible, but the odds are indescribably remote, and it's a completely useless hypothesis anyway. I can imagine a p-zombie which somehow comes up with the idea of consciousness and starts discussing it despite having no experience of it, but it would have to be some bizarre random occurrence, and is not really useful to consider.
- naasking 8y ago> Why is the ability to imagine something at all relevant? https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/#3 https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/zombies/#3