3 ms·
You know what I would like to see? Tariffs on countries with sub-standard working conditions and environmental practices.
by colechristensen 8y ago
You know what I would like to see?
Tariffs on countries with sub-standard working conditions and environmental practices.
- p2t2p 8y agoSo they could starve with no employment in a field, right? Or die working in a farm with no any kind of mechanisation?
- colechristensen 8y agoSubsistence farming isn't so bad of a life, compared to 60 hour factory weeks. Lots of western elites see something like that as a luxurious retirement. I personally don't want to participate in a slave economy.
- wycs 8y agoTell that to the former subsistence farmers who show every indication of preferring assembly work. Life as a subsistence farmer is much worse than you can imagine. We know this because people overwhelmingly prefer factory work, even in terrible conditions.
- macspoofing 8y ago>Subsistence farming isn't so bad of a life, compared to 60 hour factory weeks. Wanna bet? Why do you think rural populations leave as soon as they are able and move to cities to work in factories. > Lots of western elites see something like that as a luxurious retirement. The bigger stereotype is rich westerners fetishizing harsh rural life - the kind of life they aren't willing to participate in but have no problem advocating for for the poor in developing nations.
- colechristensen 8y agoSome of them do, many, but not all. Surely some are surprised by the expectation vs reality of their new lives. I have spoken to many "rich westerners" about my (also western, not poor but rural) upbringing and gotten responses which were longing for that sort of life. It is possible to live very well by a certain standard, on a small amount of land by doing most of the things you need for yourself. There are a lot of people who want that instead of their city life. Not for others but for themselves. Very few people who didn't experience something like it have any idea at all what it might be like.
- macspoofing 8y ago>I have spoken to many "rich westerners" about my (also western, not poor but rural) upbringing and gotten responses which were longing for that sort of life. I bet. There is a romanticization of a back-to-basics lifestyle. But western farming is nothing like 3rd world subsistence farming. >It is possible to live very well by a certain standard, on a small amount of land by doing most of the things you need for yourself. There is a hidden assumption underneath your statement, namely that you have ready access to electricity, indoor plumbing, modern healthcare, and generally typical western infrastructure. So what you're describing is either cottage living, or a hobby farm. Those are nothing like 3rd world subsistence farming.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoThe suicide rate decreases when Chinese farmers move to cities, so it seems people prefer to live in cities than be subsistence farmers.
- jeffbax 8y agoPlease, go work on a field and get back to us.
- ekianjo 8y agoThats basically a tariff against developing countries you are asking for. How do you think the West got rich in the first place? With 30 hours work weeks?
- arentiright 8y agoThe railroads didn't build themselves
- MintTea 8y agoI agree with ekianjo in this sentiment, although we can pass some of our lessons to developing nations, preventing tragedies like the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Development doesn't happen immediately, but it can happen fairly rapidly (50 years for Korea vs 200+ for the US).
- colechristensen 8y ago>How do you think the West got rich in the first place? By increasing productivity through industrialization and technology advancements, and by doing those things before the rest of the world. (and by having economic systems that accomplished this faster/more effectively than others, possibly also as the result of plagues that decimated the population a few times)
- extradego 8y agoGood one. In case nobody gets the joke: the economic system was the plague.
- colechristensen 8y agoNo it wasn't. Don't be foolish.
- saagarjha 8y agoPlague? What plague? The west didn’t industrialize in the Middle Ages.
- phil248 8y agoAlternately, we could incentivize better working conditions and environmental practices by negotiating them in to trade deals.
- colechristensen 8y agoIs that not exactly what a tariff based on those metrics is? Making bad working conditions and lax environmental standards expenses instead of profit centers.
- emodendroket 8y agoIsn't that basically the same thing?
- almostApatriot1 8y agowe had some labor standards included in the TPP but obviously it was worth less than dirt when it came to public appeal
- extradego 8y agoAll for labor standards here, but I think you doing a disservice to dirt, something many Native Americans understand as one of the only things they have left.
- herval 8y agoI’ve lived through something like this in the past. What do you think happens to the country imposing the tariffs?
- colechristensen 8y agoDepends heavily on the country and the tariffs.
- djsumdog 8y agoYou should read The Dictator's Handbook. Tariffs and Foreign Aid server one purpose: to help democracies impose non-democratic policies in those countries. The US/EU/UK give foreign aid to States with resources they want. Thereby keeping autocrats in power (they take a huge cut of that aid; people typically get the scraps after they pay off essential supporters and generals). Foreign policy is always about resource management and almost always helps keep autocrats in power. When the nation runs out of resources and aid is cut, it typically promotes democratization because the leader can no longer pay supporters. They have to appeal to the people and increase the influence selectorate size. If they don't and the people rise up, they'll often win if the leader doesn't find a way to pay the police/army. States (both democratic and autocratic) exist because they have a monopoly on violence. Foreign aid really only helps autocrats maintain that monopoly.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoMost places with autocrats have no tradition of democracy and removing the autocrats often leads to civil war. This has been a recurring theme in Africa over the last half century. The West has made some disastrous foreign policy decisions, but I think the idea that we keep autocrats in power solely to extract foreign resources is not supported by the evidence. Also, here's a list of recipients of US foreign aid[0]. I don't see an obvious connection between material wealth and amount of aid spent. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_foreign_aid#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_foreign_aid#Over...
- colechristensen 8y agoWhile I don't doubt much of this has truth, it's a bit of a one dimensional look at foreign and trade policy. Nothing world powers do has "one purpose". Motivations, intentions, and outcomes are manifold. States don't exist because they have a monopoly on violence, it is just that a (at least semi-) monopoly on violence is a core trait of a state. Statehood is the evolutionarily stable outcome of any geographic population so far. An area without a state will, without exception, develop one.