3 ms·
Treating prop 13 tax discounts as debt would further discourage people from selling (never sell, because you have incurred infinite debt). It really should be
by hedora 8y ago
Treating prop 13 tax discounts as debt would further discourage people from selling (never sell, because you have incurred infinite debt).
It really should be eliminated for all but a family’s primary residence, and it really should reset at inheritance, or when commercial property changes hands.
That’d fix a big percentage of the problem, at least in the bay area, and it wouldn’t tax anyone out of their home.
Getting rid of the incentive for rental properties should immediately flood the market with no-longer-profitable investment homes.
I don’t see it increasing rent much, since rent levels are already above what most markets could bear.
- boulos 8y agoWould you also remove rent control in San Francisco then? (Rent control was added after Prop 13 on the argument that landlords should pass through their fixed price benefits). I would replace today’s rent control (based on building date) with a means-tested rent subsidy, and similarly replace Prop 13 with a means-tested property tax subsidy. This is what a lot of places do (e.g., several counties in New York state) and you don’t end up with the distortions or arbitrary cutoffs.
- hedora 8y agoCounterintuitively, (at least as implemented in most of the bay area) rent control increases the cost of rentals on the market by reducing supply (since it allows people that pay way below market to stay in housing that would otherwise be available for someone else). So, getting rid of rent control is kind of independent of the prop 13 thing. Both would depress the costs of the available units at the expense of long-time residents.
- nordsieck 8y ago> rent control increases the cost of rentals on the market by reducing supply (since it allows people that pay way below market to stay in housing that would otherwise be available for someone else) More importantly (when it comes to increasing the cost of rentals), rent control discourages new construction by reducing it's profitability (easy to see with a discounted cash flow[0] analysis). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discounted_cash_flow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discounted_cash_flow
- xivzgrev 8y agoDiscouraging new construction? If you are referring to San Francisco that is not correct. Here rent control only applies to building built before 1979. http://homeguides.sfgate.com/san-francisco-rent-control-information-43270.html http://homeguides.sfgate.com/san-francisco-rent-control-info...
- ScottBurson 8y ago> Treating prop 13 tax discounts as debt would further discourage people from selling (never sell, because you have incurred infinite debt). This is a common reaction to the author's suggestion (one I have made in comments here on HN several times), but it's wrong. The only way the tax debt gets to be large is if property values go up for a long time. If that happens, the gain on the sale is easily sufficient to pay off the lien. Remember that Prop. 13 allows a property owner's tax bill to increase by 2% annually. In the scenario where there's a sudden jump in property values followed by a long plateau, the payments will eventually catch up to the assessment. If we stipulate that the tax bill may increase by 2% annually as long as there is an outstanding balance (even if a sharp drop in property values reduces the assessment), then I don't think you can come up with a scenario where the lien value is excessive. Try it, with actual numbers; you'll see it's not so easy. (Oh, we do also have to assume that the interest rate is reasonable. I would be inclined to leave it at zero, given that this proposal is already going to be extremely difficult to sell the public on.)
- kd5bjo 8y agoIf there's another real estate crash, property values could fall below the accumulated property tax debt, leaving people who thought they owned their home outright underwater and unable to sell.
- ScottBurson 8y agoAs I said, you should try working out a scenario with actual numbers. The lien balance will just never get that large. Prop. 13 limited the tax rate to 1%. So to see how much the lien can increase by in a single year, you take 1% of the amount the property value increased, less 2% of the previous year's tax bill. Let's take, by way of example, a scenario where values have been flat (so the payment has been equal to the assessment, so there's no lien yet) and then jump 10% in a year. What happens? Let's say V is the property's value before the 10% jump. The assessment, after the jump, is for 1.1% of V; the tax bill is for 1.02% of V, creating a lien for 0.08% of V. If values plateau again, in the following year, the assessment will again be for 1.1% of V, but the bill will be about 1.04%, adding about 0.06% to the lien. It will take 5 years for the bill to catch up with the assessment, at which point the lien will total about 0.2% of V. 0.2% is just not a scary number; compare it to the 6% that an agent typically charges to sell the property. Even in a crash, it's just not going to make the difference between making it possible or impossible to sell. The only scenario under which the lien value grows to a significant number is the one in which property values go up a lot for a long time (as they have, in the SF Bay area, for the last 20 or 30 years). In that case, it would take a hell of a crash to bring values down to where some properties would be worth less than their liens. A 20% drop wouldn't do it; it would take something more like an 80% crash. An 80% crash is not going to happen. But if it makes you feel better, I would be willing to accept a provision that says that if the amount of the lien at the time the property is sold exceeds 50% of the gain on the sale, the difference is forgiven. (No refund is offered if the property is sold at a loss.)