4 ms·
Taxation of carried interest as capital gains makes absolutely no sense - I can't think of a better example really to illustrate "one set of rules for the rich
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Taxation of carried interest as capital gains makes absolutely no sense - I can't think of a better example really to illustrate "one set of rules for the rich and another for everyone else.'
- MR4D 8y agoCarried interest is effectively the General Partners share of the dividend. Dividends are taxed at a lower rate than ordinary income, so this is as well. This is true whether you’re poor and own one share of a dividend paying stock, or you’re Ray Dalio. Here a pretty good breakdown of how it works and why it makes sense [0]. To be clear, I’m not saying you have to like it, but the rich have been getting richer since the beginning of time. I don’t expect that will ever change. It’s as true with humans as with animals like lions (albeit the measures are different, as lions have no care about dollars). [0] https://www.cnbc.com/2014/03/04/cnbc-explains-carried-interest.html https://www.cnbc.com/2014/03/04/cnbc-explains-carried-intere...
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYes, but as the parent article states, and even what is pointed out in your own link, while dividends are taxed at a lower rate, the manager is paid the lower rate on capital that is not his to begin with. That's the part that makes no sense to me. It is quite simply an incentive payment for his labor: it's income that investors pay him for his expertise, and as such should be taxed at income rates.
- harryh 8y agoYou & I start a company. I provide $100,000 in seed money but little actual work/time. You provide no seed money but a lot of work & time. We agree to split ownership of the company 50/50. 5 years go by. We sell the company for $1,000,000. You get $500,000, I get $500,000. Should I get to pay a lower tax rate than you?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThen let hedge fund managers organize their funds as equity purchases from their investors. To use your analogy, if managers were deserving of 20% of the profits, then structure it as investors own 80% and managers own 20%. Of course, that would make many hedge funds a lot less attractive for many investors. Hedge fund managers want to have their cake and eat it too.
- harryh 8y agoThat is (more or less) what hedge fund managers do.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI know they are organized as partnerships, but the managers don't really have any equity rights to the committed capital, only the profits. But I guess that's really no different than an investor with preference rights in a startup. In any case, thanks very much for your explanations, really helped me think about the issue in a different way.
- harryh 8y agoHappy to help out! In any case, as I stated elsewhere(1), I'm actually not sure what I believe on this topic. I can really see it both ways. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17276214 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17276214
- freeone3000 8y agoNo. You shouldn't. The person doing the actual work should be paying it as tax on labor, and the person who put up the funds should be paying it as capital gains. And obviously, capital gains should be taxed at a rate greater than labor.
- harryh 8y agoThat is a fine point of view, but perhaps outside the scope of the topic under discussion.
- MR4D 8y agoI think harryh ‘s comment states everything I could but much more succinctly, so I’ll just second his statement.
- harryh 8y ago:)
- guelo 8y agoIf the point of lower capital gains tax rate is to incentivize risking capital then the carried interest loophole makes no sense because the noney manager isn't risking his capital. His "share of the dividend" is just another fee that should be taxed as any other income.
- MR4D 8y agoIf you want to discuss “fair”, I’d tend to agree with you. But taxing them while not screwing out all the other business structures that look just like this (see harryh’s example above) is damn near impossible. Which is why the exemption is in there. Figure that out and it might change. Until then, you risk screwing up all sorts of businesses that are not financial let alone hedge funds.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- forapurpose 8y ago> the rich have been getting richer since the beginning of time That's not true and we must be careful not to accept an aristocracy (or oligarchy) as inevitable. That the wealthy will inevitably hold and consolidate power is counter to the history of democracy, a specific rejection of aristocracy, and a system which has worked the other way in country after country to great success economically and politically - great news and great hope for humanity in these times. The foundation of the U.S. is that all are created equal, and after that it's a land of opportunity where merit wins out, not inherited wealth and corruption. If by that you mean that rich have been getting richer relative to others, that's certainly not true. In the U.S. it's been true since the 1980s, but it fluctuates and in most other advanced economies the proportional difference (the disparity) is much less. If you mean that there is not downward social mobility for the rich, that's also not true. I don't have the numbers, but I've read about research that overall social mobility (up and down) is significantly less than it was before Reagan. There's also the old American family story: Rags to rags in 3 generations. More concretely, the U.S. used to have higher taxes on the high income, and more importantly, a (much higher?) estate tax: Inherited wealth is not merit, but effective aristocracy. That said, I don't know the inter-generational overall trends of wealthy families. (Or maybe the parent means something else.) EDIT: Some clarification + the last sentence
- extradego 8y agoThe idea of democracy as a “rejection of aristocracy” has been well discredited for centuries now. The topic of discussion here is not “social” but economic mobility. Let’s not mix them up so carelessly. Economic mobility is a measure of ability, or potential, not concrete events. To discuss “downward” economic mobility is to imagine wealth being forced upon these folk.
- MR4D 8y agoI’ll pick out one point that you seem to miss - when the US taxed the heck out of people with high incomes, you still had people like Howard Hughes, Warren Buffet, and John Paul Getty becoming even richer than they were before. So yes, the rich get richer, and high taxes do not stop that (but present the illusion that it stops ). I’ll gladly admit I’m wrong if you can disprove my three simple examples. Last I hexked, they were R I C H.
- Alex3917 8y ago> one set of rules for the rich and another for everyone else The rich (LPs) aren't the ones getting carry, it's the GPs who get carry.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoMany hedge fund managers are plenty rich, oftentimes orders of magnitude more than some of their clients.
- Alex3917 8y agoYeah and there is that one chef at Google who made $45M. But the average wealth manager has less money than the average founder, and the average founder is broke as shit.
- noobermin 8y agoThere are people much more broke than the average founder but they don't get wealth manager's or founder's standard of life.