5 ms·
Yeah, and MSN and Facebook block messages containing ThePirateBay.org. You can argue both ThePirateBay.org and Mega.co.nz are very likely copyright infringement
by Fnoord 8y ago
Yeah, and MSN and Facebook block messages containing ThePirateBay.org. You can argue both ThePirateBay.org and Mega.co.nz are very likely copyright infringement material.
Also, these are not private messages. That's why Tweakers.net calls private messages "direct messages" (DMs) and not "private messages" (PMs). They scan them, they read them back in case of a dispute, but apart from the moderator team other users cannot read them.
The title of this subject seems to call it DM whereas Reddit appears to call their system PMs. Either way, Reddit falls under a different jurisdiction than Tweakers.
A simple solution could be using GPG, or a different method of communication e.g. using JS over a less censoring platform. By using GPG (or some other form of public key cryptography), the messages are private, and the integrity of the data can be guaranteed.
- tom_ 8y agoThey are private because other users can't see them. I wouldn't advise reading anything more into the terminology than this.
- duxup 8y agoLegally it might be a good call to avoid the word private.
- userbinator 8y agoBy using GPG (or some other form of public key cryptography), the messages are private, and the integrity of the data can be guaranteed. Until they start blocking that (it's very easy to detect excessively high entropy, in fact one of the properties of good encryption is that output is indistinguishable from random noise) --- in which case, start using stenography...
- eco 8y agoAren't stenotypes pretty expensive though?
- goldenkey 8y agoI believe he meant concealment in plain sight aka https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography
- throwawaymath 8y ago> in fact one of the properties of good encryption is that output is indistinguishable from random noise Technically this is not correct, though your point about high entropy nonetheless stands. Ciphertext indistinguishability (IND, and more generally computational indistinguishability) refers to the inability of a polynomial-time algorithm to differentiate between two different output streams of data, given some input stream of data. To be precise, it is sufficient for a ciphertext to achieve indistinguishability under an adaptive chosen ciphertext attack (IND-CCA2) if an attacker cannot distinguish which of two ciphertexts corresponds to a plaintext message with greater with 50% probability in polynomial time, even when they can arbitrarily decrypt ciphertexts of their choosing. Academically speaking, distinguishability against a set of uniformly random bits is a nice model and a bar to strive for. In practice it's not necessary, and it's harder to achieve with public-key cryptography than secret key cryptography. AES's substitution permutation network should generally have output that appears uniform (except for special cases, like GCM). But public-key cryptosystems like RSA rely on so much algebraic structure to achieve their encryption that it's very regular to find some latent structure which clearly distinguishes ciphertext data from random data. This doesn't diminish the security, because you still can't distinguish between ciphertexts themselves in polynomial time. But from the perspective of attackers and onlookers, if it's not already obvious how a ciphertext was generated from context, it's usually not infeasible to figure it out by looking directly at the ciphertexts or their accompanying metadata. It is much harder to do this with hash functions. There is not much research in cryptographically secure stenography because that sort of obscurity is usually not desirable except for very special cases. To combat the appearance of high entropy, I would use a specialized encoding algorithm that breaks the ciphertext into many short, variable-length fragments, then intersperses it into a commensurately larger corpus of randomly generated plaintext. Localized pockets of entropy would still be evident even if it's less "loud", so I'd then disguise them by putting them into e.g. very long URLs, which often have great length and pseudorandomly generated tokens. With an actual research team and a few months I'm confident you could massage this plan into something pretty decently secure as long as the underlying cryptography wasn't too radical. The real question is why go through all the effort to impose secrecy on a platform that's clear antagonistic to it? If you're at the point of considering stenography for a direct messaging system, just message a redditor and ask them to chat with you on a different system for security.
- flatline 8y agoBoy, if you think getting people to use encrypted email is hard, I can only imagine trying to convince reddit users. Why would you even use reddit to send an actual, private communique? If you know the person through some other channel, why prefer a pseudonymous platform controlled by a third party, that is notoriously unreliable? If you don’t know them outside of Reddit, I find the odds of wanting or needing truly private communications very small, and a DM could easily be used to establish a more secure connection elsewhere.
- mirimir 8y agoMaybe ROT13 is good enough?
- Fnoord 8y ago> If you know the person through some other channel My assumption is that you don't. A transparent browser addon using JS and redditcensored.com would take care of that. ProtonMail is also browser-based and user-friendly. Meanwhile, ROT13 (or a variation) could be a useful alternative for the time being. Has anyone tested it?
- chatmasta 8y agoYou don’t need to know them outside of Reddit, just outside of the DM. I can easily imagine a situation where members of a subreddit might want to DM each other securely. For example users of a marketplace subreddit might want to DM each other to negotiate transactions. In that case I could imagine the OP providing a GPG public key in a post and asking anyone who sends a DM to send it GPG encrypted with that key. Also, convincing reddit users to use GPG is definitely easier than convincing email users, because it only needs to happen for specific subsets of them, and many already use it (eg in the old /r/DarkNetMarkets).
- __john 8y agoThat thing about Facebook blocking messages with links to the thepiratebay.org doesn't seem to be true. I just tested it. Maybe it's a regional thing (i.e. it works in the US but not in the EU).
- Fnoord 8y agoHere is my source [1]. Perhaps it refers to sharing links in posts but direct message still works? Either way, I can't test it. [1] https://torrentfreak.com/facebook-blocks-all-pirate-bay-links-090408/ https://torrentfreak.com/facebook-blocks-all-pirate-bay-link...