4 ms·
As long as I'm allowed to circumvent it if I can, sure. Mostly I object to any legal mechanism that would cause a product I physically own to have restrictions
by _delirium 16y ago
As long as I'm allowed to circumvent it if I can, sure. Mostly I object to any legal mechanism that would cause a product I physically own to have restrictions on how I can modify it in my own home. But if it's just a technological restriction, sure, they can put whatever unlocking mechanism they want on their chips. I think people should be legally allowed to modify their own property however they want, but manufacturers aren't under any obligation to sell products that are easy to modify.
Alternately, if they want it enforced via contract, they could go the old-school IBM route of renting me equipment rather than selling it. But then they had better be prepared to take on all the legal obligations that someone renting equipment has.
- tptacek 16y agoOne downside to the geeky demand for an inalienable right to circumvent technological controls is that it drives vendors towards technologies that degrade the end-user experience; for example: * Games designed to depend on servers run by the game companies * Movies that only play on players that license and maintain a virtual machine designed for content protection * Software that installs kernel modules to hook the idle loop of your OS to monitor itself I could go on and on. Geeks tend to see themselves in a narrative where they're locked in mortal kombat with big dumb companies. After all, how dumb do you have to be to believe that you can keep information restricted? Well, it turns out money can buy some pretty excellent geeks. You may not be on the winning side of this battle! When's the last time you saw a satellite TV hack?
- _delirium 16y agoYeah, I don't necessarily think geeks will come out on top as far as these particular technologies go. Mostly I object on principle to the government enforcing controls on how I can modify/use/destroy/whatever my property. To me that principle's more important than any particular battle over circumventing dongles or whatever.
- tptacek 16y agoI think (say) AMD probably cares a lot less about what you do with what they sell in your own home, and a lot more about how you propagate the information you obtain from reverse engineering it. Of course, the subtext to the "right to circumvent" is "the right to publish circumvention techniques".
- demallien 16y agoOh, satellite TV hacks exist - up until about 12 months ago I used to work for one of the companies that provides Content Access systems for satellite, and it was my personal job to reverse engineer competitors' systems, to see how they worked. As with every other DRM scheme out there, they can be cracked. What the manufacturers have managed to do though, is make the systems hard to crack globally - each box has to be cracked individually, you can't crack one and then apply to the whole park. But then, who cares? If one can be cracked, the torrents of the programs being aired will be up on the trackers the next day, and everyone else can just watch on their PC...
- tptacek 16y agoOk. What you can't do is buy an H card off eBay anymore. The cryptography and ASIC-level systems design that goes into preventing that is pretty sophisticated. Incidentally, when one compromise ends up costing a lot of money, the economics start to work for watermarking.