3 ms·
No, that's a purely semantic argument, with no moral or practical meat. RMS is quite clear about what he means by "freedom", there are whole essays on the subj
by ajross 8y ago
No, that's a purely semantic argument, with no moral or practical meat. RMS is quite clear about what he means by "freedom", there are whole essays on the subject. You guys don't have to view that kind of "freedom" as a valuable goal, but you don't get to dismiss the notion out of hand just because you don't like the word he used.
This is exactly the same flawed logic that leads people to cry "But free speech!" every time they get yelled at in public for a offering an unpopular opinion. They're substituting the idea of "freedom from criticism" for "freedom to express" and claiming victory by linguistic trickery instead of moral philosophy.
- greyman 8y agoThen why the expression of freedom-as-defined-by-RMS is that I shouldn't use Github? I think Lubos is right.
- ajross 8y agoYou're welcome to "think" Lubos is right, you have the freedom (heh) to hold whatever opinions you like. But "because RMS uses the word differently than I do" is not a justification for that belief.
- greyman 8y agoI agree, that isn't the justification. But I see it is hard to argue with RMS and his fans, since every response is essentially "Software freedom means this, and you are wrong if you think it means something else". If you think RMS is correct, that yes, from that viewpoint other people are not.