3 ms·
If Tesla actually made Autopilot into an emergency braking (or, more generally, safety) system, it would be fine. All they’d have to do is make two changes: swi
by amluto 8y ago
If Tesla actually made Autopilot into an emergency braking (or, more generally, safety) system, it would be fine. All they’d have to do is make two changes: switch from automatic steering to a lane departure warning system (so the driver must keep their hands on the wheel and will always be paying attention) and possibly rename it.
Of course, their stock price might crash and a whole bunch of customers who paid for self-driving features might be seriously pissed.
- stevenwoo 8y agoBased on previous discussions Teslas cannot do what you are asking for without LIDAR, Musk would have to admit he made a mistake on not using LIDAR and invalidate the sensor suite on all Teslas on the road.
- ProblemFactory 8y agoTesla sold a $3000 "full self-driving hardware" upgrade for a while, and now advertises all cars with the same, while suggesting that the software update to enable it is just around the corner. If they admit that radar + optical cameras won't be good enough for full self driving, there may be a lot of refunds to process. From first principles, just optical cameras should be enough - humans can do it. But the software to make it work could be general AI level complex. Personally I think LIDAR self-driving will be available in less than 5 years, but optical may take 30 years. And the company who would be most capable of developing optical self-driving AI is Google, the fact that they are sticking to LIDAR is a good indication of the complexity of optical.
- martin_bech 8y agoTeslas already have emergency braking and lane departure warning...
- na85 8y agoDoesn't seem to be a working emergency braking system, as those poor souls who plowed into stationary obstacles found out.
- stephengillie 8y agoSupposedly automated braking is only in effect when the "driving assustance package"* is enabled in Teslas. *autopilot
- Someone1234 8y agoIt doesn't seem to even work then, considering the fatal accident had the vehicle ACCELERATING into the crash barrier on AutoPilot.
- amluto 8y agoFrom limited experience test-driving newish Tesla’s and driving other modern cars, Tesla’s system is quite weak. Audi cars seem to have a more accurate concept of where the lane is. And Audi cars won’t auto steer, so it’s a double win.
- trackofalljades 8y agoEver been in a Tesla? The current system requires you to keep your hands on the wheel, and they always have. In fact there are YouTube videos of idiots showing how they use clamps and other defeat devices to take their hands off the wheel, which the car is inherently designed NOT to let you do.
- amluto 8y agoYes, I’ve driven them. Given personal experience and Elon’s claims of drivers using autopilot with hands off the wheels, I believe you’re incorrect. To be clear, when I say the software should be changed to not automatically steer, I don’t mean that it should more aggressively complain about hands off the wheel. I mean that the car should drive in a straight line with hands off the wheel, and it should also alert the driver if it thinks that the driver is leaving the lane.