4 ms·
RMS has been doing his blood boiling nonsense schtick for going on 40 years now, citing all sorts of nonsensical/utopian/nitpicky/you-name-it balderdash in purs
by ajross 8y ago
RMS has been doing his blood boiling nonsense schtick for going on 40 years now, citing all sorts of nonsensical/utopian/nitpicky/you-name-it balderdash in pursuit of goals that, well, OK, actually are pretty sound but damn are his methods crazy, amiright?
And he's been right about things. Almost every time. I post this basic quip every time one of these threads comes up. After the fifteenth "Oh, yeah, I guess he was right" you start to cut the guy a ton of slack.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoWithout being too reductive, Stallman and others apply extreme cynicism (assume the worst case scenario will happen), and they are "always right" because the naysayers seem to apply undeserved optimism. Companies like Slack initially try to appeal to the freedom crowd (IRC gateway), until they decide it impedes their business model. Stallman can see it coming from a mile away because he correctly views people and entities from a cynical perspective that many others aren't used to doing.
- fwdpropaganda 8y agoThis chronic downvoting on HN is getting boring. This is an excellent comment because it explains Stallman's accuracy (vs his opponents) not in terms of the fundamentals of their reasoning but in terms of their heuristics for judging motivations.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoNot only that - respected HN citizens need to create new throwaway accounts on order to speak their mind. It's becoming a new normal. That's ridiculous.
- andrewmcwatters 8y agoYou shouldn't even have to be respected: it's tiring to express your opinion here and contribute to a conversation only to have it downvoted because it wasn't the right contribution.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoI stopped caring about these things at all. When you need to speak up, you just do it without thinking about downvoting. Otherwise HN will just become another echo chamber, and that would be really bad for everyone. By the way, it always seemed to me that by civilized discussion once can learn the opponent's point of view and maybe even reach a compromise, but it seems HN works in a different way, hiding downvoted posts. When I expand them, I'm often surprised to see they're not spam nor offensive content, but just statements many people don't agree with.
- jaredklewis 8y agoWhat exactly is has RMS been right about? That closed source software will be used for all kinds of evil purposes? Well no shit sherlock! No one anywhere has ever made the argument that closed source is a good idea because it allows people to do bad things with software. The argument for closed source software (and indeed intellectual property in general) is that it incentivizes creation by giving creators a means to profit from their ideas. Now RMS of course has his own arguments on that point, which is great. But, my point is that predicting that people will sometimes do bad things with closed source software doesn't make you a prophet. It means you have an IQ above 15. It would be like if I "predicted" that baseball bats would be used for violence and then every time a crime was committed with a baseball bat, everyone was all like, "oh, he was right again about the bats!" Everyone everywhere knows that bats are sometimes abused for violence. That's not foresight, it's common sense.
- acct1771 8y agoYour simplification of his breakdown re: the specific methods is disappointing at best.