3 ms·
I've come to believe that that isn't the case, but that's a position which isn't scientific. In any event, it's a reasonable theory on which to proceed with a
by carapace 8y ago
I've come to believe that that isn't the case, but that's a position which isn't scientific. In any event, it's a reasonable theory on which to proceed with a scientific investigation of consciousness.
- - - -
Time is subordinate to consciousness, in the sense that "now" is a synonym for "you".
This is a really subtle point, and not easy to convey. I've deleted a half a dozen elaborations before posting this.
Whenever we are conscious it's always now. (You were conscious five minutes ago, but the only reason you know that is because you are aware of memories of it now.) It's never not now, or if it is you're not there.
Since it's never now without you, and you're never there except now, there's nothing to distinguish between "now" and "you". It is literally impossible to separate "you" and "now".
I think this must have some sort of physical (as in Physics) meaning or significance.
- monktastic1 8y agoHi there. I once read a post by you[1] that I vibed with. It reminded me of an interesting forum post that you might like, and I wanted to share[2]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13026758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13026758 [2] http://web.archive.org/web/20141010211838/http://forums.philosophyforums.com:80/threads/is-there-a-hard-problem-of-consciousness-67768-2.html http://web.archive.org/web/20141010211838/http://forums.phil...
- carapace 8y agoOhai! I recall your username from somewhere as well. Cheers! That discussion was interesting, it even included the observation, quite correct, that [the concept of] consciousness is useless. > If the concept is so vague as to be completely devoid of utility, then it is hard to understand how discourse about it amounts to anything more than a form of poetic or mystical expression. That's the unnerving thing about it: it's useless yet the most significant "thing" in the world... I have deliberately adopted the habit of mentioning the possibility of merging consciousness when the subject comes up, because it's one way of breaking the stalemate around the Hard Problem. You can't make a consciousness-o-meter but you can know the consciousness of some "other" person. Whether that counts as empirical is beyond me. :-)