3 ms·
Not sure about Qualia, but for free will it seems like everyone with an opinion on this defines free and will differently. For example from my point of view, f
by simonh 8y ago
Not sure about Qualia, but for free will it seems like everyone with an opinion on this defines free and will differently.
For example from my point of view, for a decision to be mine it absolutely has to depend on my own mental state prior to and while making it. If it doesn’t it might be free, but it isn’t mine. The less deterministic my decisions are and the less determined by my mental state (memories, opinions, etc) a decision is, the less it’s mine.
So at that level I’m really not worried by determinism or theoretical predictability, in fact I embrace them, because without them there is no responsibility or agency or self. This seems fundamentally at odds with some other people’s definition of free will which to me seem perplexingly ephemeral and indistinct.