3 ms·
There's a few problems with your premise... First, evil has been done without religion. For examples look at the millions of deaths in the ex-Soviet Union, Chin
by finder83 8y ago
There's a few problems with your premise...
First, evil has been done without religion. For examples look at the millions of deaths in the ex-Soviet Union, China, North Korea...atheism can be just as dogmatic and evil as religion can be, and the horrors that are done in the name of idealism happen with or without religion. I suppose this depends on your definition of religion and if atheism can be a form of religion, but I would argue that at the very least, every person has a list of presuppositions that make up their worldview, and in some ways every person is ideological (though not every person is violent, both from those that are religious and those that are not).
Secondly, it doesn't take a spiritual belief to be dogmatic. Look at politics, or baseball fans, or some vegans. People generally are dogmatic over their belief systems, whatever they're composed of, religion or not. I imagine that evil stems from the intensity and nature of the belief systems, but also the person and the circumstances.
Finally, people are taught to both love and hate at a VERY early age, regardless of the influence of religion. Society does a fine job of this, my 1 1/2 year old is just as capable of being a kind and loving son as he is being selfish and mean. Now perhaps you mean more developmentally, but every human is just as capable of love as they are of hate, I would say regardless of religion. Some religions may encourage one or the other more than others, just as some teachers do in the classrooms or in certain subject areas. I imagine what you're referring to are the studies that showed that racism is taught (and it is), but racism is not a necessary component of evil. Selfishness or greed can be just as effective as a root cause of evil as racism. How much evil has been done in the name of money, separated from beliefs?
Religion is just the scapegoat in your argument, when the things you're stating are more general to human nature.
- thisrod 8y agoThe most intelligent Christians I know regard communism as a Christian heresy. As a minimum, communists had sacred beliefs, which sounded more like those of a Western religion than an Eastern one. The trumpet shall sound, and we shall be changed etc.