4 ms·
The other options are to let everybody in or to suppose you already know the right criteria for who'd be the "best" immigrants. Hint: you don't. Genuinely rand
by tialaramex 8y ago
The other options are to let everybody in or to suppose you already know the right criteria for who'd be the "best" immigrants. Hint: you don't.
Genuinely random selection averts loads of really nasty problems in a system where you need to pick things even though humans tend to be sure some other approach would work better.
- mistermann 8y ago> The other options are to let everybody in or to suppose you already know the right criteria for who'd be the "best" immigrants. Hint: you don't. On an individual basis of course not, but you don't think in the aggregate better candidates can be chosen?
- forapurpose 8y agoNo. If the information is not about the individual, then it isn't useful in evaluating the individual. I know that sounds tautological, but it seems that obvious.
- mistermann 8y ago> No. If the information is not about the individual, then it isn't useful in evaluating the individual. But I very clearly was asking about the aggregate, in fact I specifically said it isn't useful on an individual basis. In the propaganda game, not showing one's cards is one of the first things to learn. > I know that sounds tautological Learning the meaning of words is pretty high on the list as well. Also humility. :)
- forapurpose 8y agoIt's worth noting that the parent admits to be playing a "propaganda game" on HN.