10 ms·
The article makes an oblique reference to it, but it's worth noting that Fred Rogers graduated from a theological Seminary and his television show was his Presb
by gowld 8y ago
The article makes an oblique reference to it, but it's worth noting that Fred Rogers graduated from a theological Seminary and his television show was his Presbyterian ministry. Mr Rogers is at the same time a sort of stereotypical Christian character (imagine
The Simpsons' Flanders without the satirical comedy aspects) and also not the image of a Christian minister that we usually see in the mainstream media and popular culture.
Mr Rogers may be most intentionally-Christian cultural influence that wasn't widely noticed as "Christian", in the lives of millions of people -- for both many people who don't think Christianity is a part of their lives as well as for many people who do.
I write this not to proselytize or to suggest that you should become Christian if you respect Mr Rogers, but as a reminder that the image you have in your mind of an X (for whatever X that is a large weakly-connected community) should not generalize to all X, and some very X-ey people might not look X-ey at all.
The article also shows that there is often a lot of hard work and educated insight behind things that look very simple and basic.
- humanrebar 8y ago> Mr Rogers may be most intentionally-Christian cultural influence that wasn't widely noticed as "Christian", in the lives of millions of people I'd put Dr. King in the same category.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 8y agoAre you saying that not everyone knew he was a preacher? I don't have that impression.
- humanrebar 8y agoI think popular culture considers him an activist first and a preacher incidentally. When people condemn Christian culture and teaching as hateful, they are likely forgetting Dr. King is in the picture. > ...not the image of a Christian minister that we usually see in the mainstream media and popular culture. The trope of a Christian preacher in popular culture resembles Bakker or Osteen more than Rogers or King.
- adrianN 8y agoI just learned that he was a preacher.
- loco5niner 8y agoOther than the adultery, of course.
- StavrosK 8y agoI think we're letting our bias show in cases of religion. Why care what religion someone is, as long as they're ethical, accepting of others, and generally non-toxic? The fact that some Christians are intolerant of others doesn't mean all Christians are, and it's sad that we have to have a disclaimer such as yours, to "remember that not all Christians are bad".
- plink 8y agoYour comments about intolerance and toxicity is sequitur to what? Am I missing a deleted post or a radical edit to the parent to yours?
- quxbar 8y agoAlso worth noting that the it's often the most disagreeable people who shield their actions with the label of Christianity. And of course, far too much blood has already been shed over declaring who a 'true' Christian is.
- toasterlovin 8y agoShedding blood over identity is not unique to Christianity. It is a human universal.
- hobs 8y agoDying for what you believe in? Sure, I'll buy that. Killing for what you believe in? Nah, that's pretty much the realm of fanatical extremists, of which religion has its greater than fair share.
- toasterlovin 8y agoA peculiar feature of The Soviet Union and Maoist China is that they suppressed religion. As far as I’m aware, those two ideologies have the largest body counts ever recorded.
- Intermernet 8y agoI'm from Australia and therefore didn't have much exposure to Fred Rogers, but, from what I have seen, it seems that it doesn't really matter if the show was presented from a Christian viewpoint. As an athiest, I'm happy to see any ethical children's TV, no matter what faith, or lack thereof, the presenter may have. I agree that there is a cultural battle going on (not just in the US) regarding religion and faith, and I agree that most media representation of both sides leans towards the extremes. That's how the media works. I'm glad to say that Mr Rogers was a great example of moderate Christianity, and he represented what I'd like to say was the majority view of Christians around the world (in regards to how we treat people, especially in regards to tolerance). I'd also like to posit that most people, regardless of particular faith, lack of faith, difference of culture etc., would agree with Fred Rogers' general approach to teaching children, and indeed adults. Basically, I'm agreeing with you: People's preconceptions shouldn't be generalised based on faith or culture, but I'm pointing out that Mr Rogers' ministry goal wasn't just a Christian ideal, but is wide-spread across most people on the planet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- krapp 8y ago>Mr Rogers may be most intentionally-Christian cultural influence that wasn't widely noticed as "Christian", in the lives of millions of people -- for both many people who don't think Christianity is a part of their lives as well as for many people who do. It helps that, as far as I recall, he never actually mentioned Christ or tacked Christian doctrine onto any of his moral or ethical lessons.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maroonblazer 8y agoExactly. Christianity didn't invent "Treat others as you want to be treated" or "Everyone is worthwhile". People can subscribe to those beliefs without believing that Jesus was born of a virgin or died and was resurrected. If you believe in the former then Christianity is not necessarily a part of your life. If you also believe in the latter then it is.
- humanrebar 8y ago> Christianity didn't invent "Treat others as you want to be treated" or "Everyone is worthwhile". That's a theological claim. "Love your neighbor as yourself" is in Leviticus 19:18. In context, those are words spoken by God to His people. Presumably, at least in Judeo-Christian philosophy, God is the originator of that line of thinking. But, sure, the golden rule is a good idea. Who says it's unique to Christians? I don't see why Fred Rogers being a Christian and a teacher at the same time is the same as condemning non-Christians as amoral.
- lomnakkus 8y ago> "Treat others as you want to be treated" Just a random aside: If you think about it, this is kind of weird rule. Not everybody's into the same things. AFAICT it should be more like "Treat others as they want to be treated".
- Viliam1234 8y ago
- toasterlovin 8y agoWhenever hardcore atheists criticize the religious, they are inevitably focusing on the worst that is done in the name of religion and ignoring all the good that is done in the name of religion. I have consistently found intensely, cerebrally religious people to be some of my favorite people to talk to. And I see so much good come from people who seat religion at the head of their table, so to speak. I wish secular folk could see and appreciate all the good that religion does.
- eridius 8y agoThe people who do good in the name of religion, by and large, don't need religion to do good. They may (or may not) use religion as an excuse to explain why they do good, but that's just it, an excuse, and without religion they'd almost certainly still do good. On the other hand, there is a tremendous amount of evil done in the name of religion that wouldn't be done at all if it weren't for religion. An incredible amount of hate and bigotry and oppression and violence all rooted in dogma. People don't need to be taught how to love. But they do need to be taught how to hate.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y ago"...how much cruelty among Christians is acted under the colour of Religion; as if we could not be Christians, unless we crucify one another..." --Charles Stuart, _Eikon Basilike_
- acjacobson 8y agoHow do you know that same evil wouldn’t be done without religion? Hate and evil finds justification for itself wherever it can. Often it is religion but it can also be in culture, tradition, racism, otherness etc. I’m not convinced a lack of religion would correspond to a net reduction in that kind of evil. It might just shift somewhere else as humans try to justify their terrible actions.
- eridius 8y agoThe point is that religion taught them to hate in the first place. There is an incredible amount of hatred and discrimination in this world that can be traced back to the text in some book said that some particular group of people were bad and other people accepted that as the word of God. The only reason these people have to hate that group is because an authority figure (the authority figure) told them to.
- ThinkingGuy 8y agoI believe that there are a small number of people who are able to, as I call it, "straddle two worlds," and people like this fascinate me. Steve Jobs was famous for bridging the divide between "technology" and "design." Benjamin Franklin embraced science and the Enlightenment while maintaining his grounding in traditional Puritan values. Fred Rogers came from a very privileged background (white, upper-class, Protestant, etc), but consistently advocated on behalf of the least fortunate (children, the handicapped, the marginalized; i.e., those at whom public television was originally aimed). He was an ordained minister who, in the course of seeking out how best to install values in children, based his program on the latest scientific research of the time. He was a television performer who was the same person, whether talking to small children, or testifying in front of Congress. He was, in his own way, traditional and progressive at the same time. Further reading and watching: Walking The Beat In Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood https://www.npr.org/2016/03/11/469846519/walking-the-beat-in-mr-rogers-neighborhood-where-a-new-day-began-together https://www.npr.org/2016/03/11/469846519/walking-the-beat-in... Mr. Rogers On Arsenio Hall https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1geWczVpUbE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1geWczVpUbE http://neighborhoodarchive.com/ http://neighborhoodarchive.com/
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> whether talking to small children, or testifying in front of Congress. You say that like these are two different things.
- mariodiana 8y agoFor further reading, a must read is "Can you say…Hero?" by Tom Junod, which originally appeared in Esquire in 1998. https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a27134/can-you-say-hero-esq1198/ https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/tv/a27134/can-you-say-... You may not know me, but trust me.
- dorfcakeling 8y agoHis show was an exhibition of positive philosophy. Calling it a Christian show is pushing a misleading narrative. Also, Christianity is not just the positive parts. Selectively emphasizing only those parts means leaving out much of what makes up Christianity, now and throughout history.
- Waterluvian 8y agoFrom my perspective, it's about people who see religion as the point versus religion as a tool to get to the point. For Mr. Rogers the point wasn't conversion. He didn't set out to make people Christian. He set out to foster kindness, caring, understanding, and happiness. And for him, Christianity was a pretty darn good playbook to gain inspiration from. I've often said that being a good person looks strikingly like the fundamentals of most religions.
- maconic 8y agoI am not religious so I won't make any comment on that part, but I do hope we can culturally somehow figure out how to avoid someone like Mr. Rogers being considered a pedophile (and maybe he was a pedophile or a serial killer I don't know). Otherwise, all of our kids will be trained by AI robots that aren't capable of emotion to avoid any possibility that a human being could have a sinister motive as opposed to just trying to leave humanity in a better place than what they were born into? :) I haven't checked all of them, but I suspect if you search for any famous people that worked with kids (their fault for trying to influence the lives of more kids on television of course) and add the word pedophile to the search query, you will never fail to find results. So I don't want to speak about Christians specifically, I do very much appreciate people willing to teach the next generation, likely for a lot less money than they could earn elsewhere, out of some sense of compassion or duty.