3 ms·
Good points. I should have emphasized use of Whonix, which comprises Tor gateway and workspace VMs. Forwarding isn't enabled on the gateway or workspace, the ga
by mirimir 8y ago
Good points. I should have emphasized use of Whonix, which comprises Tor gateway and workspace VMs. Forwarding isn't enabled on the gateway or workspace, the gateway is firewalled, and it doesn't just use TransPort. It exposes a bunch of SocksPorts to the workspace VM, so each app gets its own SocksPort.
> all tor entry point traffic is logged and possibly has active mitm boxes
That's a broad claim. You need cites for that. Tor relays are run by a large collective of volunteers, and keeping something like that secret would be quite some achievement.
- angry_octet 8y agoOkay, not all gateways. But top by volume, yes. Not by the people running them, but at the network/ISP layer. There was some open source reporting about it in Singapore (not a democracy admittedly) I'll try to dig up. But on the 5th anniversary of the Snowden leaks, why do you find it strange?
- mirimir 8y agoOK, maybe at network/ISP level. There's no way for relay operators to know, of course. But if an operator learned of logging, I'd expect to see that reported on tor-relays@lists.torproject.org, and I don't recall that. This is yet another reason to hit Tor through a VPN service. Or better, a nested chain of VPN services. Edit: I do recall a post by Virgil Griffith about the situation in Singapore.[0] He says nothing explicitly about logging, but does note that Singapore's "love of anti-corruption exceeds its apprehension about human-rights-laden privacy enhancing technologies." And I don't find anything about logging of Tor relays there. But then, I'm searching in English :( 0) https://medium.com/@virgilgr/tors-branding-pivot-is-going-to-get-someone-killed-6ee45313b559 https://medium.com/@virgilgr/tors-branding-pivot-is-going-to...