the issues with amp arent that its not closed source, the issues with amp is that: 1) you either use amp or you lose out massively in google search rank (as in

the issues with amp arent that its not closed source, the issues with amp is that: 1) you either use amp or you lose out massively in google search rank (as in the links that appear at the top of the page, regaurdless of what semantic games you want to identify them with) 2) by using amp, you hand over all your search traffic to google. No amount of "shut up and code" is going to fix this, because it is a business decision by Google, not a technical decision that they are going to entertain arguements about. The open source aspect is a total smokescreen.