3 ms·
> The data stolen was of a highly sensitive nature despite being housed on the contractor’s unclassified network. Former government contractor here: Dumbasses
by walrus01 8y ago
> The data stolen was of a highly sensitive nature despite being housed on the contractor’s unclassified network.
Former government contractor here: Dumbasses need to keep their sensitive data air gapped and inside a SCIF.
If you need to network stuff, there are ways for contractors to implement NSA-approved "type 1" crypto with the appropriate personnel and infrastructure.
Also, I think whoever improperly classified that as not requiring SECRET level protections is going to have a hard time justifying it to their bosses.
- ManFromUranus 8y agoThere's stupid and then there's "stupid" putting my tinfoil hat on here: maybe they were allowed to steal the data. I mean really? Oh WOOOPS we stored 613 GB of classified data on an unsecured network in the EXACT place hackers would look... aww that sucks, welp we'll try to do better next time. I call BS, this level of incompetence smells more like treason disguised as stupidity.
- jessaustin 8y agoA true believer would say the point was to suggest intentionally bad technology (e.g. screen doors!), to retard progress in Chinese submarine design...
- lainga 8y agoExactly. Or trick them into thinking American technology is weaker than it really is (cue F-35 fanboys).
- geezerjay 8y agoForcing China to waste their spook manpower sifting through half a TB of crap data would also be quite funny.
- ManFromUranus 8y agoGood point, there's always free cheese in a mouse trap.
- jessaustin 8y agoAre there penalties written into contracts to address failures like this? ISTR when China got loads of F-35 data, Lockheed was "punished" by getting to spend another year and hundreds of millions more dollars "fixing" the plane.
- 1024core 8y ago> Are there penalties written into contracts to address failures like this? Of course not. Which is why this crap keeps happening.
- bb88 8y agoSo it's not like you're going to take the F-35 and move it over to another contractor. More likely, you'll just cancel it and start gain. The other aspect is that it's not really the contractor's fault if the exploit was done with a zero-day.
- jessaustin 8y agoWow I really disagree with that. 0-days are a fact of life. If billions of dollars aren't enough to set up a secure supply chain and air gaps, what would be?
- bb88 8y agoYou conflate the way the world is with the world you wish it would be.
- jessaustin 8y agoNo, I wish we didn't spend trillions of dollars on killing machines for no reason. It's pretty difficult to confuse that world with this one. Your magical phrase "zero-day" doesn't "win this argument" for you... You're imagining some Stuxnet-level pyramid of remote BIOS and NIC firmware hacks when we all know this was just a poorly configured firewall. That's why "TOP SECRET" exists, CYA.
- excalibur 8y agoThe article states clearly that this was Controlled Unclassified Information. Massive volumes of industrial data fit this description. It does call for special protections, which are outlined in NIST SP 800-171. Nowhere in this document does it imply that CUI data should be kept in a SCIF.
- LordHog 8y agoFrom the article, Cmdr. Bill Speaks, a Navy spokesman, said, “There are measures in place that require companies to notify the government when a ‘cyber incident’ has occurred that has actual or potential adverse effects on their networks that contain controlled unclassified information.” This does not indicate the data was or was not classified. Now, at the beginning of the article, "The data stolen was of a highly sensitive nature despite being housed on the contractor’s unclassified network. The officials said the material, when aggregated, could be considered classified, a fact that raises concerns about the Navy’s ability to oversee contractors tasked with developing cutting-edge weapons." The article suggest the data, in aggregated form, could be viewed as classified. I am quite sure not all the details have been made public nor will they be for some time. I am sure it will take many years for that true nature of the breach to enter public domain. Submarines are the US primary means of nuclear deterrence and any breach to limit that deterrence might be considered harmful.