3 ms·
Shutting up has nothing to do with karma. You should shut up if you have nothing to say. In response, your karma won't take a hit for saying stupid or pointle
by wccrawford 16y ago
Shutting up has nothing to do with karma. You should shut up if you have nothing to say. In response, your karma won't take a hit for saying stupid or pointless things, but the karma is not the -reason-. It is a symptom.
That's why karma exists. It shows the people who consistently have things to say, versus those who just yammer on to hear their own voice.
And that's why downvotes are necessary. If someone says interesting things occasionally, and never says pointless things, they add to the signal (rather than noise). If someone says just as many interesting things, but 100x as many pointless things, their karma would look exactly the same as the person who only added signal. Downvotes are the only way to distinguish those 2 people.
- OoTheNigerian 16y ago"You should shut up if you have nothing to say" ...that goes with the herd look at this http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1722384 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1722384 as an example. If someone says interesting things occasionally, and never says pointless things, they add to the signal (rather than noise). not in all cases. Do you think anyone can successfully argue in favour of communism without being voted into oblivion?
- shadowsun7 16y agoI haven't argued in favour of communism, but I have expressed opinions on HN that went against the herd, and I have fared well. (See: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1661588 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1661588) I've said this before, and I'll say it again: HN is largely self-correcting. The trick is to write a response when you get downvoted (unfairly, that is), because the downvote is usually a signal that either: a) you wrote a lousy one-liner or b) you didn't express your opinion in a clear manner - see (a). Flesh out your argument, tell people that you do have a point, and say that you don't think the downvotes were fair. You'd likely see a correction within the next couple of hours. This of course assumes that you do have something intelligent to say. If you don't, the downvotes are deserved. Also, I note that in your response to the parent's comment you've not articulated your arguments. You merely make assertions. not in all cases. What does that mean? Why do you think so? What counter-examples can you give us? that goes with the herd What does? Why? And you link to a HN thread, expecting us to see ... what? What is it that you see in it that you want us to notice, as well? HN karma rewards the most cogent, the most intelligent comments. Those are usually well articulated ones. Simple assertions are not well articulated arguments, even if they are true. A simple format for writing a clear argument is to use the framework of: Assertion -> Reasoning -> Example. HN may occasionally downvote comments based on content. But only if the argument isn't well articulated. That's been my experience, at least. PS: if you're a karma lover, you may be in this for the wrong reasons.
- DJN 16y agoI think @oothenigerian's point is that downvoting comments simply because they express a contrarian view is bad form. It requires a certain level of maturity, introspection, humility and openness to not simply tag opposing views as pointless and therefore worthy of a downvote. Another way to express it is this - is it possible to upvote a comment that you disagree with? i.e. simply on the ability of the author to substantiate his points? Perhaps we should introduce transparent algorithmic voting. Hmmm....