7 ms·
It would make me sad to remove windows on small commuter jets, since it's so much fun looking out the window and you spend a significant proportion of the fligh
by crazygringo 8y ago
It would make me sad to remove windows on small commuter jets, since it's so much fun looking out the window and you spend a significant proportion of the flight closer to the ground anyways, watching interesting things like cities.
But on long-haul flights like Emirates has? Only 2/10 people per row have a window seat to start with, and airlines usually require everyone to close their window shade anyways for much/most of the trip, for people who want to sleep.
Sure you lose a bit of romance, but honestly for the majority of the passengers and for most of the time there's going to be zero difference... except burning less fuel means being better for the environment and hopefully slightly cheaper tickets.
- Alex3917 8y agoIf it really saves 50% of the aircraft weight, it's crazy that long haul airplanes today are even allowed to have windows.
- degenerate 8y agoThat is the biggest 'wow' in the article, and I'd really love to see a source on that... but they don't provide a source and I cannot find this info when googling. Anyone can back up that claim?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cecilpl2 8y agoI can't believe that's possible. I really want to know where that number came from. Maybe you could reduce the weight of just the frame of the fuselage by 50%, but I bet you'd save at most 2-3% of the total takeoff weight, once you include fuel, wings, tail, engines, gear, cabin, baggage, people, cockpit, etc. Edited: I looked into this more deeply and found the following: https://aerospace-europe.eu/media/books/CEAS2015_211.pdf https://aerospace-europe.eu/media/books/CEAS2015_211.pdf It claims a total possible weight reduction on an A320 from 2155kg to 1560kg, or 600kg off the fuselage (plus an additional 150kg elsewhere for a total savings of 750kg). An A320 weighs 42,000kg empty and 78,000kg at takeoff. 2155kg is probably the weight of the fuselage frame sections containing the windows - makes sense that you could save 50% off that piece. That's a reduction of 1% or so off the takeoff weight. Also, note that cargo planes are already windowless. I couldn't find a good example of a plane that has both freight and passenger versions that are otherwise identical.
- ethagknight 8y agoNot to mention that their projection system will bring some weight and use energy, surly offsetting gains, so that whole sentence should be stricken from the article.
- kolinko 8y agoWell, it's not just the added weight of windows, but, I imagine, additional reinforcements for the structure that are needed when you have windows? (IANAPE - I'm not a plane expert :) )
- WalterBright 8y agoYou are correct. There's a forged doubler that goes around the window opening to reinforce it. The DeHaviland Comet lost several airplanes due to cracks starting from the windows; Boeing was having none of that.
- tikhonj 8y agoWhich is a real shame because that plane looked gorgeous, especially with square windows. It's always sad when physics gets in the way of aesthetics...
- manigandham 8y agoA fantastic video about the De Havilland Comet from one of my favorite channels: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v0Cg2ZeYa5E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v0Cg2ZeYa5E
- jacquesm 8y agoThat was more due to the shape of the windows then due to the fact that it had windows. Square holes are not a good idea in aluminum that's under tensile stress. For the same reason you end a straight cut into metal in a round hole, otherwise you'll surely end up with a stress fracture.
- WalterBright 8y ago
- chejazi 8y agoI imagine that's for the empty plane, and that passengers and luggage and fuel offset that % a fair amount.
- wavefunction 8y agoAny chance to reduce fuel consumption is a win.
- leesalminen 8y agoNot necessarily. Another commenter on this subthread found that the weight savings equate to 1-3% of total take off weight (fuselage, engines, fuel, people, cargo). There is a safety benefit to having windows (inspecting in-flight damage to aircraft). Is 1% weight savings enough to remove a safety feature? I don’t know the answer, but it certainly isn’t a clear-cut win.
- ravitation 8y agoTo be perfectly honest, this number sounds speculative at best (utter nonsense at worst). The fuselage is generally about 20-40% of the entire dry, empty weight of an aircraft (speaking strictly about large transport aircraft). So clearly seeing that kind of reduction in weight isn't really possible strictly from structurally modifying the fuselage (and even major modifications of the entire airframe). If we look at comparing planes with windows (like those operated by passenger airlines) to those without (like those operated by cargo airlines), loose estimates are less than 1% to around 1% weight savings from removing windows alone. Even if you assume massively increased returns on weight savings because of massive changes in airframe design it's probably no where near 50%... Keep in mind, even incredibly small weight reductions mean huge savings over the lifetime of an aircraft (especially if they are also carried out over an entire fleet).
- mikec3010 8y agoIt's probably done using Hollywood accounting: 50% lighter for the specific oval region where there used to be glass. Probably only a 7% gain for the total fuselage. Also Windows play a role in emergencies: "that sides on fire, let's open the other escape door"
- paulcole 8y ago> Also Windows play a role in emergencies: "that sides on fire, let's open the other escape door" That seems extremely hypothetical and optimistic. If your large passenger plane is on fire you're probably already dead.
- Declanomous 8y agoWindows actually are used for visual inspection in flight in a number of cases. You can actually see markings above certain rows where a pilot or a flight attendant could look out and inspect something. I think the types of things they would be looking for are flap deployment, icing, damage to the wing, gear deployment (though there is usually a window in the floor for this), etc. There's a great YouTube channel called Mentour Pilot that covers a lot of stuff like this, but I can't find his video that discusses visual inspections. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwpHKudUkP5tNgmMdexB3ow/featured https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwpHKudUkP5tNgmMdexB3ow/fea...
- matt4077 8y agoThe emergency door exit instructions specifically mention checking for fire outside as one of the steps. It's also one of the requirements for starts and landings, along with "make sure your seat back and folding trays are in their full upright position".
- paulcole 8y agoYeah, I'm sure Emirates forget about this before considering a windowless plane. Or maybe there are other ways to check for fire?
- 8y ago
- vram22 8y ago>watching interesting things like cities. Not only cities, watching natural formations like lakes, rivers, fields, forests, hills and mountains from above is a unique perspective (compared to seeing the same from land), and very cool too. I remember being glued to the window, for tens of minutes (at least), on a flight from Europe to the US, when passing over the Arctic (or near it, not sure, but northern seas anyway), seeing vast expanses of ice floes and blue-green water glittering in the sunshine from high above. Then passing over Goose Bay as we crossed over Canada into the US, that was great too. Miles of green meadows or grassland.
- trhway 8y agoWith LCD screens say on the floor you can have glass bridge flying over Alps experience for every passenger independent of seat. Add magnification and AR.
- asadlionpk 8y agomight as well just watch over google maps. It's not the same thing sadly.
- mikeash 8y agoI’ve had the good fortune to see auroras on two overnight flights near the North Pole. Fantastic sight. A video screen won’t do it justice.
- vram22 8y agoI googled for images of aurora borealis and saw a good video, it was at a place in Scotland. But you're right that the real thing would be better.
- vvanders 8y agoUp here in the PNW I've seen some spectacular views of Mt Rainer, Mt St Helens and Mt Hood on approach/departure. Being up in the air lends to a great sense of scale and if you catch them during golden hour very few views compare. I happily took window seat on 13hr direct flights for the chance of seeing them back when I traveled more often.
- zwily 8y agoYou still see outside with the fake windows... It's just a display instead. According to The Points Guy you even get a better view.
- repsilat 8y agoDoes the "camera" point downwards? Straight out? The available views from a window seat are pretty close to a 180 degree half sphere. That won't be possible with a screen unless there's some way to pan. Also no rays of sunlight :-/. If there is some way to pan, it could be better than looking out the side for most passengers, if it's super HD. It presumably won't be blocked by the wing, and could encourage carriers to put nice outward-facing views on the seatback screens for passengers in other seats. IMO it's definitely going to be a minor downgrade to the experience, offset by lower ticket prices.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWith a few cameras in strategic locations, you could build a 360 spherical view of the entire outside for passengers.
- reaperducer 8y agoIf the point of removing windows is to save weight, it doesn't make sense to add cameras, screens, cables, power distribution, etc... which all add weight.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- volkk 8y agowell it does make sense...if that weight is negligible compared to the amount saved from removing the windows
- brownkonas 8y agoI wonder what radiation insulation benefits this also provides?