10 ms·
No, sorry. AirBnB is creating immense problems in tourist destinations, to the point where people in major cities in Greece (and other countries) are having tro
by StavrosK 8y ago
No, sorry. AirBnB is creating immense problems in tourist destinations, to the point where people in major cities in Greece (and other countries) are having trouble finding affordable permanent housing.
Barcelona and Rome are overrun with tourists, and it's killing the cities. AirBnB should just go away, the market worked very well before it, even if things were a bit more expensive.
- ng12 8y ago> the market worked very well before it I don't think AirBnB was the cause of the Greek debt crisis.
- piyh 8y agoLet's go back to taxis while we're at it.
- StavrosK 8y agoTaxis are a problem, but Uber is not the solution.
- xapata 8y agoOh? What is? Uber/Lyft seem like a great solution to me.
- danudey 8y agoUber is a great concept, but the reality is that Uber has shown us time and time again why taxis cost what they do: regulation to protect users and our cities. Uber, like AirBnB and a lot of other startups, are 'disrupting' industries by entering them and taking them over by ignoring regulations, insurance, and even laws to keep costs low and make a profit. In this day and age, they can grow fast enough that by the time cities see the repercussions and react to them, the companies are big enough and rich enough (and flush enough with VC money) to fight back, and are already entrenched with a loud and enthusiastic user base. In other words, Uber is great if you ignore the various safety and insurance regulations, background checks, licensing, etc. that taxis have to comply with.
- xapata 8y agoUber provides commercial insurance, no? Other than that, I generally feel safer in an Uber ride than in a taxi.
- xapata 8y agoTo explain: I've never been yelled at by an Uber driver. I have been cursed at by taxi drivers. Yes, more than one. They often don't like my destination and get mad at me for being in their cab. "I've been waiting for two hours, and you're going to Chinatown!? Fuck you!" (Not far enough) "Brooklyn?! Fuck you!" (Wants to stay in Manhattan) One cabbie was so pissed he went 70 in a 35 zone to demonstrate how annoying my destination was. Cabbies pretend to get lost so that the fare is longer. Uber will refund the difference. Etc. Etc.
- jstarfish 8y agoRegulation also limits the number of taxis out on the streets (for better or worse). Uber has no incentive to limit the number of drivers they employ. Our small streets are jammed with Uber/Lyft cars endlessly driving back and forth.
- xapata 8y agoDo they circle while not carrying passengers or going to pick up? I've observed them usually waiting by the curb for the next hail.
- Tiktaalik 8y agoPeople without as much money as you would probably prefer more robust public transportation systems, which Uber/Lyft compete against.
- xapata 8y agoOh, sure, I'd prefer a better transit system, too. But in the meantime, I'd rather have more choice than less. Uber costs less than a taxi, so this is giving poor(er) people more choice.
- vuln 8y agoUntil the VC money runs out and the poor(er) have zero choice. Those people chose to give their money to Lyft / Uber instead of supporting their local public transit. Fast forward through Uber/Lyft's 'disruption' the local public transit shuts down due to lack of funds for maintenance, upgrades, etc. The public transportation ridership will be at an all time low, so it would be very hard to get tax payers to shoulder the burden of the costs... Seems like a sad state for the future.
- jessaustin 8y agoI also prefer more robust public transit, but I know of no community who decided against a public transit project because Uber was meeting their needs.
- cornholio 8y agoUber has a low cost because it doesn't use monopoly power to gouge consumers like cities do when issuing medallions. So Uber's secret sauce is the fact that it breaks the law, not VC money. The medallion laws are unjust and should be broken, other laws like insurance, driver training and vehicle safety are not. This is what makes the debate so complex and passionate, with people taking one side or the other depending on their personal incentives and political bias.
- newfoundglory 8y ago
- mmt 8y agoI wonder, though, if the original iteration of Uber (now Uber Black?), their actual commercial car/driver version of the service, is the solution. It didn't have the hyper-growth potential of the current model, but it didn't draw most of the ethical/moral objections, while still providing at least some "disruption" to the taxi monopolies.
- StavrosK 8y agoYes, that's much better. We have something similar here, called Beat, which I like much more. It's just taxis, but you can see and leave reviews, you get an estimated price, you can pay by card, etc.
- soperj 8y agoDepends on who you are. It worked terribly for people with young families or families that were over 4 people.
- StavrosK 8y agoWhy? Can those families find housing more easily?
- xevb3k 8y agoHotels suck for families is what the comment is trying to say I think. With young kids, you often what your own cooking/food preparation facilities. Sleep arrangements are often easier in a house too. Ironically, it seems like hotels with food preparation areas are more common in Japan (weekly mansion/business type hotels).
- StavrosK 8y agoYes, but I'm saying "AirBnB sucks for people living in the city" and you're saying "it's great for if you want to travel there".
- soperj 8y ago> the market worked very well before it That's specifically what I was replying to. I live(and rent) in a city that is tourist based and less affordable because of airb&b and the like. It has a vacancy rate of under 1%. So i completely understand what you're saying. I just disagree that the market for staying somewhere worked well before airb&b.
- StavrosK 8y agoOh, I see. Maybe, I don't really have experience with traveling with a family.
- 8y ago
- Fede_V 8y agoI can't wrap my mind around people that think that 'too many tourists' or 'too many jobs' are a problem. Those are 'problems' that most cities in the world would kill for: if we consider them problems it's because we are not nearly creative enough to take advantage of them. As a simple example: if we have too many tourists, give a progressive daily tax that's charged to every visitor that automatically includes museum visits/etc. Use that revenue to build more housing for local residents (and if some dipshit points out that more housing ruins a neighboorhood's character, ask yourself if Paris or suburbia has more character) or to subsidize local transport infrastructure.
- Sangermaine 8y ago>I can't wrap my mind around people that think that 'too many tourists' or 'too many jobs' are a problem. Step outside of theoretical economic thought experiments and try living in a formerly quiet neighborhood or building suddenly experiencing an influx of loud drunk littering assholes. Residential areas are desired as residential areas for a reason. I live in NYC and sure as hell don't want to live around Times Square. There are actual people living in these cities who want a decent quality of life where they live. Echoing many others in the this thread, in a previous apartment in a residential area of Manhattan someone down the hall starting renting their unit to Airbnb visitors. It was a nightmare, but thankfully the landlord caught wind in a few weeks and kicked the person out.
- robertAngst 8y agoThis sounds like those cities do not have an educated/skilled workforce. Sure there are spots near the Roman forum you would expect to have lots of tourists(basically inside the Aurellian walls). But outside of that its a 20+ minute drive for a tourist to popular areas. If a 50$ airbnb is beating out a $1,000/mo rent its because people cannot afford $1000 in rent. We host an airbnb ourselves, lots of business travelers in our area. If people are coming to visit what humans did 2000 years ago and not visiting the humans there today, I dont think the problem is Airbnb.
- StavrosK 8y agoI'm not sure I understand what you mean, but nobody is going to be able to afford to pay hotel rates for their permanent residence.
- xapata 8y agoDepends on the kind of hotel. And after the market settles, hotel rates may not be as high. A key aspect of hotel rates is that they fluctuate with demand. When you come into town for the big event, the rates may be 4 times higher than staying on a cold, boring night. A long-term stay will be much cheaper per-night than a nightly rate.
- jessaustin 8y agoIn my part of midwest USA, multiple giant hotels seem to be nearing completion: EIFS is nearly complete, windows have been in a couple of months, concrete parking lot is poured, etc. Apparently investors are expecting a lot more travelers to this thoroughly ordinary area.
- robertAngst 8y agoAirbnbs are not passive income. You need to take down sheets, wash them, remake the bed, clean the bathroom, buy fruit/food every ~3 days, vacuum, be available for your guests. When you have tenets, its passive income. You clean up every 6 months to 3+ years. Airbnb pays better, but its labor. The ~300$/mo difference can easily be accounted for with that. Not to mention the cost of food(always HQ), electricity, water, heat/AC. The items I listed are not optional, people can give you a bad review regardless what expectations you set with prices + description.
- Thriptic 8y agoI can't speak to this problem in tourist destinations or Europe generally as I don't have enough data to have an opinion, but I frequently see Airbnb blamed for high housing costs in some American cities and it strikes me as being a bunch of bullshit. Sure Airbnb doesn't help the rental problem and it is a contributor to rising rents, but the primary problem isn't Airbnb, it's lack of supply of high density apartment living options. Many US cities are composed primarily of 2-3 story houses which have been converted into dingy expensive apartments. This is utterly unacceptable from an efficiency standpoint. Many of these units need to be bulldozed and replaced with high rise apartments if cities are to become affordable again.
- jaytong 8y agoand to top it all off, the zoning laws in some cities...
- StavrosK 8y agoThe situation in Greece is very different, as everything is a highrise (sadly, because we tore down a lot of beautiful centuries-old antique villas to do that). The situation used to be much better, but the start of the problem coincides suspiciously with the rise of AirBnB, and you'd expect housing prices to drop in a recession, not rise. That's why I think it's fair to blame AirBnB for that. We'll see what happens in Tokyo, Madrid and other cities where they're severely restricting usage.
- distances 8y agoBut apartments in Athens are very affordable still, aren't they?
- ferongr 8y agoYes, as well as rents. A 1BR apartment can be as low as 150€/mo or even a bit lower. It's only a few "hip" neighborhoods that are affected. Still, Athens is relatively compact and mass transit is excellent so you can easily find cheap places to live that are require less than 30 minutes of commute each way to work.
- eanzenberg 8y ago>> the market worked very well before it You mean during the recession?
- StavrosK 8y agoThat would imply things got better in some way, which they haven't. We're still in a recession and deteriorating.