5 ms·
Open-source developers: "Microsoft should embrace open source, it's the one true way!" Microsoft: embraces open source Open-source developers: "They're trying
by netsharc 8y ago
Open-source developers: "Microsoft should embrace open source, it's the one true way!"
Microsoft: embraces open source
Open-source developers: "They're trying to control us! They're trying to control us!".
- Sylos 8y agoYou don't embrace open-source by buying a major code hosting platform.
- cupofjoakim 8y agoThat does depend on the situation. We know that google wanted to buy Github, so a (very unlikely) motivation could be that microsoft bought github to "protect it" from google, or in case of no deal happening, financial instability. That being said, we have no way of knowing what the true motive of the move is - being sceptical/critical is indeed the correct reaction.
- ggregoire 8y agoMS is the biggest open source contributor on GitHub.
- mikece 8y agoUsually you buy something in order to make a profit from it. In the case of GitHub, Microsoft is committed to losing money from now until they cease to exist to continue GitHub as a going concern, that will never implode for lack of funds, as a place where open source projects can be freely hosted and open source developers can find a sense of community. This is more magnanimous than anything Google, Amazon, Facebook, Apple, and Twitter have done -- COMBINED!
- IncRnd 8y ago> Microsoft is committed to losing money from now until they cease to exist to continue GitHub as a going concern Is that your belief, or do you know that to be true?
- mikece 8y agoGitHub has never made money. Microsoft buys GitHub and says we're going to let them operate independently as they see fit. Where do you see the profit motive?
- IncRnd 8y ago> Where do you see the profit motive? I never wrote anything abut profit motives. You just made the same leap of logic again. Do you know factually that , "Microsoft is committed to losing money from now until they cease to exist to continue GitHub as a going concern."
- parvenu74 8y agoThe fact that Microsoft tried as many times as they did to push Windows Phone -- even buying Nokia to have a captive device maker -- shows how committed they can be to losing money.
- linuxftw 8y agoI agree with you here. I doubt Microsoft is committed to losing money on a product. There could be a direct (selling subscriptions / additional addon products) or indirect (marketing dollars, community goodwill, 'mindshare) profit motivations. I think Microsoft sees this as a way to get into businesses that would have never entertained a relationship with them. When those github enterprise contracts come up for renewal, I expect large discounts for trying Azure and other Microsoft products to come with them.
- chomp 8y agoMicrosoft's been orienting themselves as a developer services company over the past few years. Azure, vscode, open source dotnet, they want free onramps onto their services. They were missing CI/CD tools, and source control. They had VSTS and Team Foundation Server but there's no way theyd beat the ubiquity of git. I'm betting they're going to now start offering CI via GitHub like Gitlab (or offering a unified marketplace to allow other companies to fill this role and they take a cut) and then folding GitHub Enterprise into their suite of developer tools. Just like Visual Studio is vscode++, GitHub Enterprise will be invested in to where it does a whole lot more fancy things, and free GitHub is the onramp. And then Microsoft will have a portfolio that spans the entire code development pipeline.
- syshum 8y agoYes but MS has now moved beyond Embrace, to the Extend phase... Those of us that have seen this play before know what comes after Extend in the 3 Phases of EEE
- Kipters 8y agoHow, exactly? I'm genuinely curious, I haven't seen any sign of "extension" like IE6 extensions to web standards
- syshum 8y agoGithub itself extends Git in a closed and proprietary way... Github is the extend part or EEE, Git is the Standard, Github is the extension... -- Edit since I being prevented from responding I will edit this to address the idea that "Github is not an extension of git" Yes, it is. While you can still use git with out Github, you could also use "the web" with out IE6, GitHub however had workflow and process improvements over standard git, just like Active X added workflow and process improvements over HTML Standard. GitHub adds things like Issues, Pull Requests, "Social Coding, unified Login, Access Controls, Project Discovery and about 100+ other things on top of git that using git alone does not get you. This is text book example of EXTEND it is insane to me how people do not see it. Further to address "I have to be insane to believe GitHub was started by MS" well I never said that, Simply because Github was not created by MS, does not change the fact that their buying Github is part of the EEE model
- jhall1468 8y agoGitHub is a set of UI tools built on top of a command line interface. It is not an extension to git. You can still use git normally. You can use other UI tools built on top of git. That, by definition, is not an extension. And the logical leap required to think that somehow GitHub was built, years ago, as part of a strategy for Microsoft is bordering on insanity.
- pizza234 8y agoI remember a certain Microsoft executive stating: "Linux is a cancer that attaches itself in an intellectual property sense to everything it touches" Times have changed, however it's reasonable to question if the Microsoft DNA radically changed or "not really".
- onion2k 8y agoThat was Steve Ballmer, and he was talking about how using libraries licensed under the GPL affects the software built on it. His words were very poorly chosen[1] but his sentiment is actually one that a lot of people in open source seemingly agree with - we have the LGPL and many other licenses because people don't agree that the way one dependency is licensed should affect the whole application. [1] https://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/06/02/ballmer_linux_is_a_cancer/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/06/02/ballmer_linux_is_a_...
- syshum 8y agoWhat you see there is the different between open source and Free Software Free Software is a ethical movement and position around software and information Open Source is a business model for collaborative development where most often the end product is not open but the tools used to create the end product are. Thus you can not use Copy-left Licenses if you intend to close source your final product. Free Software is about Developer and User freedom Open Source is about developer freedom exclusively Ballmer's Microsoft disliked both Open Source and Free Software. Today's Microsoft sees the profitability that can some from Free labor of open source, but continues to be Hostile to Free Software
- jhall1468 8y agoHoly crap this thread is getting absurd. > Today's Microsoft sees the profitability that can some from Free labor of open source, but continues to be Hostile to Free Software Microsoft donates more dev time to open source then they will EVER get out of their own use of it. But sure, let's pretend the multi-billion dollar company is spending billions upon billions on open source in order to save money. That makes SO much sense!
- mikece 8y agoThis is a reaction that is both funny and frustrating. While there is enlightened self-interest for Microsoft to buy GitHub (they rely on GitHub for a lot of their open source work as well as their documentation websites) buying GitHub and saying "We're going to let it operate independently as before while we fund the project knowing it will never turn a profit -- that's how important Open Source is to us, we're willing to lose money every quarter to ensure GitHub will never implode for want of money" STILL brings distrust. And yet, the hue and cry is "Unless you open source every byte of GitHub's code and infrastructure you're just evil monopolists trying to smother us!" Given all that Microsoft has done to embrace and support open source I think the onus is now on the Open Source community to justify their distrust of Microsoft because "Duh, it's Microsoft" simply doesn't fly as a legitimate argument anymore.
- zimablue 8y agoMicrosoft is the heart of corporate America, it's a facepalm to imagine that any dollar they spend isn't in their own long term interest to make money. It would be illegal for them not to. You can apply that to any large corporation but the problem is by definition how Microsoft makes money. How does Microsoft make money? They make money by renting from a platform which is monopolistic and enforced. What do they do to maintain this? They deliberately force people onto their platform by abusing their market position, and try to crush any opposition by any possible tactic, including dubious legal cases designed just to bankrupt their opposition. What else do they do? EEE, and also just blatant unnecessary reinvention /ripping off and lock-in when they get the chance. They didn't abandon some of the visible tactics and start paying open source because they had a moral revelation, it's a company with the same business model it's not possible. Those tactics were just inneffective and co-opting, more subtle EEE has to be the game plan. Why does that make me angrier than equally evil Facebook/Apple? Well if I was a farmer driving around one of those trucks with source code preventing me from fixing it I'd be pretty personally furious. But I'm not, I'm a developer and those guys are the ones trying to make everyone drive the coding equivalent. But it's worse, because coding isn't just my livelihood, it's a lot of how I think and express my thoughts. They're not messing with my job they're trying to restrict the way I think, so their shareholders can make a buck. "Microsoft is running Github for charity" have a word with yourself.
- thezultimate 8y agoAFAIK, Windows is still closed source. I guess some parts of Microsoft have not embraced open source :)
- jhall1468 8y agoSo are parts of Red Hat. I guess Red Hat hasn't embraced open source.
- thezultimate 8y agoI thought we are talking about Microsoft? But yes, some parts of Red Hat do not embrace open source :)
- jhall1468 8y agoMy point was that your comment was absolutely silly. Embracing open source doesn't mean never producing closed source. Contributing in commits and/or money is also embracing open source. You confuse embrace with replace.
- thezultimate 8y agoOK if that's your definition of embracing. Btw, you can make your point without bringing in Red Hat. It sounds absolutely silly to me :)
- justinclift 8y agoOut of curiosity, which parts of Red Hat don't embrace Open Source? I'm trying to think of some, and drawing a blank so far...
- thezultimate 8y agoMaybe I was wrong. I thought OpenShift is a proprietary product, but they actually open source it.
- 8y ago
- ilovecaching 8y agoEmbracing open source means contributing to open source and using open source. Buying a company to take advantage of open source has nothing to do with embracing open source.
- jhall1468 8y agoMicrosoft is one of the largest open-source contributors in the world AND they bought an unprofitable, but widely liked company that supports a significant number of open-source products.
- occams_chainsaw 8y agoIt's almost like people can have differing opinions from one another
- wdr1 8y ago> Microsoft: embraces open source Oh please. Microsoft has not embraced open source. Is their web browser open source? No. Is Word, Excel, or Powerpoint open source? No. Do they even push for open standards of those products? No. Is Windows open source? No. Is the C# compiler open source? No. Microsoft may have taken some positive steps to support Linux on Azure & other things -- things possibility necessitated by market demands -- as well some contributions to open source. But to say they have embraced open source is patently false.
- linuxftw 8y agoAll very true. Their core business is not free and open source software, they haven't embraced anything.
- amanzi 8y ago> Is their web browser open source? No. Their Edge browser engine is proprietary but is built to work with open standards - no more pushing their own proprietary standards like ActiveX. > Is Word, Excel, or Powerpoint open source? No > Do they even push for open standards of those products? No. The default file format for recent Office versions is based on Office Open XML which is a published standard that anyone can interoperate with. Also, Office apps can save to the OpenDocument format too. Yes, there is a lot of proprietary stuff inside of Office, but they also have 20+ years of backwards compatibility to deal with. > Is Windows open source? No. Are there any examples of a company taking something as large as Windows OS and converting the whole thing from closed to open source? It's not like they can just flip a switch and let the whole world see the source code? > Is the C# compiler open source? No. Look at what they are doing in the .Net Core space for an indication of where this is going... > But to say they have embraced open source is patently false. I disagree with this and most who have followed Microsoft's actions over the last few years would also disagree with you. They have embraced open source way more than could be expected of any other company with a huge portfolio of closed source software.
- justinclift 8y ago> Are there any examples of a company taking something as large as Windows OS and converting the whole thing from closed to open source? It's not like they can just flip a switch and let the whole world see the source code? Maybe when Sun Open Sourced Solaris? It took them quite some time to get it done, but with significant effort they got it over the line.
- pasbesoin 8y agoopt in versus opt out. You can opt in to using .NET. This purchase makes you decide whether to opt out of your existing Github use. Or at least worry whether its usability (on whatever dimensions matter to you) will decline.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agoThis PR campaign is bullshit.