2 ms·
why would Facebook attempt to portray changing the privacy settings on a post hours/days after it goes out with the wrong privacy settings, as a sensible plan o
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
why would Facebook attempt to portray changing the privacy settings on a post hours/days after it goes out with the wrong privacy settings, as a sensible plan of action to suggest for fixing the problem they created?
Because they are a huge company with a great deal more experience handling PR gaffs than most people posting on HN. Whatever their shortcomings in other areas, this advice actually is pretty much gold standard.
First, it prevents more eyes on it. This mitigates the damage. A lot of traffic occurs well after the first few hours.
Second, it allows people to forget. People don't have perfect memories. Some people have quite poor memories. Removing it from public view denies them the ability to return to a written record and get all hot under the collar all over again, reread it until they have essentially memorized it, etc.
Third, posting some kind of apology or something to total strangers who don't know you tends to go super badly. It gets interpreted as an admission of guilt which just fuels the fire. Most people aren't that great at giving public apologies. Public faux apologies just put out the fire with gasoline.
Fourth, if you take the advice and do what FB told you to do, you have the defensible position that FB screwed up, go be mad at them, not me. You don't get that shield if you then add more public commentary on the issue. In fact, you are just making an ass of yourself and looking like you are taking advantage of the breach to piss on strangers who don't agree with your point of view.
(edit: also, why on earth would you apologize when it is, in fact, Facebook's error?)
I wish social stuff was as straightforward as you seem to think it is. It's not. And PR is absolutely one of the few things large companies typically know more about in spades than the average person. Their advice may not be what you want to hear, but it is the least worst thing to do in a situation like this.
- derefr 8y ago> also, why on earth would you apologize when it is, in fact, Facebook's error? Because you're not apologizing that they saw your post; you're apologizing for the content of your posts. Like, imagine that you're a [race A] guy with [race B] friends, who is also secretly super-racist against [race B], making [race B]-disparaging posts that are only visible to your [race A] friends. One of those posts ends up visible to your [race B] friends. Is the sensible suggestion "hide it and hope they didn't see it/hope they forget"? Or is the sensible suggestion "hide it or delete it; and then—now that the fact that you're a racist is out in the open—start doing damage control, e.g. by profusely apologizing for your comments and trying to skew things in such a way that it makes it seem that this was a one-off thing rather than your usual secret behaviour"? (Or, for another obvious one: what if a private post to your secret lover is made public to your spouse?) IMHO these are the kinds of problems that are important to suggest a response for—the ones where Facebook could make a suggestion of a response that would create the most net utility, since a lack of any intervention in these cases has the potential to create the most net disutility. Compared to these cases, the ones where someone's parents saw their pictures of them partying or what-have-you are effectively irrelevant, and shouldn't be brought into Facebook's moral calculus re: appropriate responses.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't see any reason why Facebook should be held responsible for advising racists on how to successfully save face and do damage control while not in any way changing their attitude. I also see no reason why Facebook should be giving advice to people being unfaithful and using their platform to facilitate it. To be perfectly clear, I had an illicit affair in my youth and I am often quite sympathetic to the person cheating. I'm a woman, so I sometimes get women dumping on me about their cheating husband. They inevitably expect me to automatically side with them and agree that everything wrong in the marriage is his fault and to generally hate on men by default. Those conversations don't go like those women expect. But I can't imagine using Facebook for such covert activities and if you have such a scenario on your hands, there are going to be very serious consequences for being outed. That goes well beyond PR gaff and is far outside the scope of what Facebook should be expected to try to manage on your behalf. There are very serious matters that I think Facebook should take more responsibility for, such as their role in fueling longstanding feuds in some countries. They should take measures to stop being a means to pour gasoline on those fires. But your specific concerns are not anything I feel Facebook needs to take responsibility for. I will add that even in the scenarios you posit, the gold standard is to hide the post and hope they didn't see it. If they did, PR measures will not help you.