5 ms·
Meanwhile, Tesla is busy putting out press releases saying "We believe the driver was inattentive, and the car was warning him to put his hands on the wheel."
by FireBeyond 8y ago
Meanwhile, Tesla is busy putting out press releases saying "We believe the driver was inattentive, and the car was warning him to put his hands on the wheel."
I am utterly, completely lacking in surprise that they didn't provide the relevant context, "... fifteen minutes prior."
This just looks... really bad for Tesla. It's more important to them to protect their poor software than drivers.
- buvanshak 8y agoIf a company is this blatantly evil while still in a growing phase, I can only imagine what they would do once they are a established major player...
- megablast 8y agoIt is a car company. Their products directly kill over a million people every year. The injure 10x as many. Their pollution causes a similar number of deaths. They are responsible for so many horrible side effects, including dangerous city and suburbs to people taking up more and more space. You think this one crash makes them evil?
- buvanshak 8y agoNo, it is not the crash that makes the evil. It is how they handle it. And how they put blatantly misleading marketing out there, along with poorly researched features that may or may not have lead to overconfidence from the drivers along with half baked tech, that resulted in crashes such as these.
- megablast 8y agoYou just ignored every one of my points.
- JoshCole 8y agoThere haven't even been five deaths yet in the entire history of Tesla autopilot car accidents, but there are more than three thousand deaths a day due to car accidents. Tesla's safety record actually is such that if scaled up, their would be a massive drop in the number of deaths per day. Their marketing reflects this. So does their communication on the topic. I know it can sound offensive when they say that a driver died without his hands on the wheel in the six seconds leading up to the crash, but their communication is reflective of a desire to preserve life. So I wouldn't call it evil, let alone call it blatantly evil. Stepping back further, away from this accident, Tesla is also a leading player in moving away from destroying our planet. By that I mean they are pushing renewable energy. Again, not something I would call evil, let alone blatantly evil.
- blub 8y ago"Tesla's safety record" is misleading: * every update to the software makes the record irrelevant, because one is no longer driving the same car which set the previous record. Lane centering for instance was introduced in an OTA update and it likely contributed to this accident. * most of the safe miles driven by Teslas are not with autopilot on. The NTSB explicitly said they did not test autopilot. * finally, some HN users did the math and it turns out that humans have overall a better safety record than autopilot Teslas. To me it looks like Tesla's communication is only reflective of covering their asses. From blaming that journalist to the latest accident. Note: I work for a Tesla competitor.
- tigershark 8y agoYour first point is absolutely misleading. You can apply the same logic to the other cars saying that they are all different because of the different tyres, the different conditions of the tyres, of the brakes, the different degree of care and so on. You can’t just say that they are not the same cars because of the different variables.
- etaioinshrdlu 8y agoI think OTA driving software updates are a bigger variable than tires. I think you would too if you think about it more.
- CamelCaseName 8y agoYes, cars kill, injure, and create disease, but they also connect people across the world, to relatives, to work, to buy and deliver goods and services. Without cars, our level of productivity would be a fraction of what it is today as employment is confined to a tiny geography. Many more people would die from fires, disease, and crime as emergency services arrive on horse drawn carriage. Most people would never venture out of their hometowns. Car companies, for all their faults, for all their fraud and corruption, create products that immeasurably benefit us every day. Before we call them evil, we must look at the impact they have on each of us. That impact is decidedly positive, as evidenced by the widespread ownership of cars.
- MPSimmons 8y agoTesla kills a million people a year?