2 ms·
I know only somewhat more than hearsay about clinical trials, so I'm not really qualified to have this discussion. I know that trials are not always between pl
by eesmith 8y ago
I know only somewhat more than hearsay about clinical trials, so I'm not really qualified to have this discussion.
I know that trials are not always between placebo/"no-influence" and "any-influence." They are sometimes between current best practice and possible new best practice.
I believe the recent case of the woman treated for breast cancer, which I mentioned previously, is an example of your "suppose" case.
Another might be the first trial of injectable penicillin was on Reserve Constable Albert Alexander. It was clear within 24 hours that it was effective.
So certainly it doesn't require randomized double-blind trials. Then again, Lowe said "controlled clinical trials", which I suspect may include more than the 'gold standard' of clinical trials.
There's an old joke about how there hasn't been a controlled trial about the effectiveness of parachutes. https://www.bmj.com/content/327/7429/1459 https://www.bmj.com/content/327/7429/1459 . I don't think the medical field as a whole agrees with "the most radical protagonists of evidence based medicine" (quoting from the abstract) to conclude that we therefore can't be certain about its effectiveness.
I read the comment from 2012 that you pointed to. I think it is an opinion with only a tenuous basis in evidence.
Other countries have different requirements for care. I pointed out elsewhere in this thread how people from the US go to Mexico for treatments which are illegal in the US. (Note: Mexico is not full of Nazis as moldbug exaggeratedly suggested must be the case for that to happen.)
If it were so simple as closing the OODA loop, then we would expect amazing treatments to come out of these countries. Or as Lowe pointed out in the quote I gave earlier:
> Many states have passed their own right-to-try laws (in various forms), and if there has been any decrease in human suffering or advance in medical knowledge through them, I have missed it. To get specific, when Colorado passed its own law in 2014, one of the first companies that announced plans to offer treatments under its provisions was a stem-cell company, Neuralstem. And guess what? None of their treatments ever worked. Most things don’t.
Since the lower standard doesn't seem to help, why lower the standard?
What evidence is there that 1000 or more patients die of neglect for every one which dies of quackery?