3 ms·
Counter to narrative, there is/was some US based panel production capacity, we do still make things here! We don't make as many things as in, say, Germany, but
by epistasis 8y ago
Counter to narrative, there is/was some US based panel production capacity, we do still make things here! We don't make as many things as in, say, Germany, but there is manufacturing.
The whole reason that these tariffs came in to effect was that some failed manufacturers brought the issue. My understanding is that the manufacturers failed not because it's impossible to do in the US, but simply because of poor management decisions or betting on the wrong technology.
The real question is whether the tariffs will be around long enough to incentivize any new manufacturing capacity in the US. They will almost certainly be slapped down by the WTO in a short amount of time, as previous tariffs like this have been. So by the time anybody could make more manufacturing capacity, it seems likely that the tariffs will no longer be around to support the facility. So new facilities must be planned on the basis of profitability without the tariffs.
Even in this environment, there is new production being planned. However, the jobs associated with this are dwarfed by the number of jobs related to installation of panels. So while this will certainly be a net negative to the US economy in the short term, without much opportunity to provide positive impact.
Basically, just a meaningless PR move by a politician. I don't think it will cause hugely detrimental effects either, it's just stupid.
- gascan 8y agoCounter to narrative, there is/was some US based panel production capacity, we do still make things here! True, except those operations are owned by foreign companies, right? Particularly... Germany and China.
- epistasis 8y agoI believe so. That may be due to several rounds of consolidation; it's a tough business and there's a lot of periods of oversupply, which brings down prices.
- drak0n1c 8y agoFor perspective, the Obama Administration already imposed solar panel tariffs twice and directly propped up Solyndra and US solar investors in general - the ones who now want another tariff bailout. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/business/energy-environment/-us-imposes-steep-tariffs-on-chinese-solar-panels.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/business/energy-environme... http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/261363-us-hits-china-with-solar-tariffs http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/261363-us-hits-...
- epistasis 8y agoI'm not sure how that adds any perspective to my comment, or relates to it. But because it's a common politically driven meme, I'd like to address it. Obama doing something bad does not justify current bad actions. It does not make complaining about the current tariffs hypocritical. I would agree 100% with Jigar Shah's opinion about the prior tariffs: >“Taxing solar trade undermines both the spirit and efficacy of pledges made by the U.S. and China to work together in the battle against global warming,” Jigar Shah, president of the Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy, said in a statement. But those prior tariffs were not identical in their form. The Obama tariffs were on a single country, China, for specific actions. The current tariffs are almost worldwide, for no clear reason at all. They benefit few jobs, and the investors that benefit are not from the US. Obama's actions were less than ideal, but at least they made a tiny bit of sense.
- TooBrokeToBeg 8y ago> not because it's impossible to do in the US The US manufacturers couldn't compete on cost because critical materials were either solely available or so low cost, from China, that it drove competition out of the material markets in the US. This is one of those, ask any manufacturer, rather than a guess. Then factor in labor costs and you ended up with yet-another-chinese-dominant market where improvements were done in China snowballing the situation to today.
- epistasis 8y agoPerhaps if you're trying to compete on bottom of the barrel costs, but that's only one segment of the market. Panels themselves are only about a third in the cost; therefore it rarely makes sense to go with the cheapest panels. Higher quality, longer life span, higher cost panels tend to win out because higher efficiency means more energy per panel and those other costs are often per panel. This is more extreme in the residential market where the panel costs are an even smaller fraction of the cost.
- chopin 8y agoMake them cheap to mount. At least here in Europe that is the most limiting factor with regards to cost.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt's pretty hard for a privately-funded company to compete against dozens of state-sponsored companies that receive government funding for the sole purpose of driving out their foreign competitors.