5 ms·
I'm all for solar. I use it myself. But I cannot wrap my head around these prices. They seem far too low. If this reality or is this companies trying to win
by sandworm101 8y ago
I'm all for solar. I use it myself. But I cannot wrap my head around these prices. They seem far too low. If this reality or is this companies trying to win bids, trying to get their feet into doors?
Solar takes space. It takes far more land than coal-fired plants. But land prices are going up and everyone expects interest rates to go up too. So how can they afford to acquire and maintain the needed land at these prices?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Abekkus 8y agoColorado has land to spare. That quote might even be based on zero-cost land.
- sandworm101 8y agoThen these prices are somewhat artificial. Even if you get the land for free, there are significant operating costs. Maintaining solar panels out in a field is very different than on the roof of a factory. In a place like Colorado (not a Nevada desert) you first have to cut down all the trees/bushes, which isn't a great image for green energy. Then someone has to keep the vegetation from growing back. Theft of panels does happen. So you need security guards. The costs aren't extreme, but at the quoted prices they are significant.
- greedo 8y agoYou can put it on grazing land and let the animals keep the vegetation under control.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sverige 8y agoLand is far from zero cost in Colorado. Assuming these solar farms would go on the eastern plains rather than in the even less productive (but more expensive) land in the mountains, it is true that much of that land can support only sparse grazing or sometimes wheat, since it is semi-arid (but not desert as in the Great Basin).
- zrobotics 8y agoHave you spent much time around Grand Junction? There's much more to western CO than just mountains. And the grazing land isn't terribly valuable. I don't know the CO specific figures, but the statewide average in Wyoming is 40 acres/1 head cattle, and western CO has a similar climate. Honestly, WY would be a better place for this, but the state government has its head way too far up the coal industries rear for that to get much traction.
- jartelt 8y agoYou are more likely to just need a fence with barbed wire and not active security guards. Theft of panels from utility scale solar installations is unlikely to impact cost much at all. Vegetation growth is a modest issue. Fortunately, the panels shade much of the ground, which reduces vegetation growth under the panels. Yes, you may need to mow every now and then, but the panels absorb most of the sun, which means the grass under them doesn't grow as much. As far as trees and bushes go, most solar installation are placed in open areas that either naturally don't have trees or have already been cleared of trees. People are mostly installing on converted empty lots or old agricultural land. Plus, if you cut down trees, you can always "offset" by planting new trees elsewhere. Ongoing maintenance on the panels is pretty low. Assuming you install in a place that receives rain every now and then, you may not even need to clean the panels of dust. Mother nature can sometimes clean the dust off on its own.
- philipkglass 8y agoTo put some numbers on it, at the end of 2016, average US utility-scale PV O&M costs were $18,000 per megawatt-AC per year (and still falling rapidly): https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/09/berkeley-labs-2016-utility-scale-solar-report-finds-solar-pv-increasingly-competitive/ https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/09/berkeley-labs-... Average capacity factor for utility scale solar PV is 27% in the US: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=epmt_6_07_b https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph... That would put O&M costs at 18000 / (24 * 365 * 0.27) = $7.60 per megawatt hour, out of a total price quoted by epistasis of $30-$32 per megawatt hour. O&M could be up to 25% of total costs. It is indeed, a significant part of total costs. It is also a smaller fraction of total costs dedicated to O&M than wind or fossil power (including fuel in O&M).
- TYPE_FASTER 8y agoThe eastern plains of Colorado are a pretty good place for solar I think. No trees, not much vegetation, lots and lots and lots of space that's not being used for anything today.
- zrobotics 8y agoNot being used for anything? What, exactly, do you think agriculture looks like?
- mikestew 8y agoIn a place like Colorado (not a Nevada desert) you first have to cut down all the trees/bushes Without numbers in front of me, I'd guess that most of Colorado is not trees and mountains. Plains on one side, desert on the other. Plenty of room to put up panels and not remove a single tree.
- metalliqaz 8y agoSome land is expensive, but outside of cities it need not be. And coal plants aren't exactly small. They are surrounded by all the apparatus necessary to move tons of fuel. And consider that even if the footprint of a coal plant is smaller, that doesn't mean it would be cheaper. Coal plants have huge construction costs, and unlike solar, have huge ongoing costs to remediate their waste products. Plus there's the cost of buying and trucking in the fuel.
- maxerickson 8y agoI just measured https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Bowen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_Bowen with a generous setback as about 2.5 square miles (so ~1600 acres). That's only accounting for the generator, not the mine or the train track easement, etc. Here's a 120 megawatt project advertised as needing 1000 acres: https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/04/120-mw-first-solar-project-texas-begins-commercial-operation/ https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/04/120-mw-first-s... So coal plants really are a lot more compact than solar, and they do their nameplate capacity nearly 24/7. Which hey, bring on the solar, but expect it to use a lot of land, especially when/if energy intensive industries switch to using it.
- epistasis 8y agoLand is not a significant input to the cost of any of these projects. And in the US West, there's unbelievable amounts of open space, much of it unused. If the cost of land is going up, then it's an asset that after the 20-30 year lifetime of the project could be sold for a profit. Therefore, the "cost" of the land is just the financing cost, and the cost of capital has been very low up until now. We'll see what happens with interest rates... If the land is productive, i.e. for grazing or farming, then the profit from solar must be compared to the profit of the agricultural activity. But there's so much unproductive land that it's doubtless that solar makes a lot of sense. And even for agricultural activity, there's soooo much excess agricultural production of corn and soybeans, that with only very modest amounts of incentive (in the form of tax incentives), investors will put solar panels on land that had been farmed previously. You'll see it all over the countryside in Minnesota these days. Edit: Let me back this up with some numbers. Figure 28 of this NREL PDF [1] puts land acquisition at $0.03/W - $0.04/W out of the $1.03/Wdc cost of large fixed tilt systems. Here's an OSU article [2] that puts solar leases of farm land at $1600/acre/30years, which apparently looks to be a great deal for farmers in Ohio. [1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68925.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68925.pdf [2] https://u.osu.edu/extensioncd/2017/02/23/considerations-for-utility-scale-solar-farm-land-lease-agreements/comment-page-1/ https://u.osu.edu/extensioncd/2017/02/23/considerations-for-...
- sverige 8y agoInterestingly enough, many rural communities in the Midwest have been soundly rejecting wind farms, and some have voted down solar farms. The real problem with agriculture these days have been caused by subsidizing industrial production of basically two crops, corn and beans. Farms were smaller a generation ago, and produced more diverse kinds of crops as well -- actual food crops. For example, much of the corn goes straight to ethanol plants these days.
- btilly 8y agoFor example, much of the corn goes straight to ethanol plants these days. Ethanol that causes wear and tear on cars while producing approximately the same energy that was used in fossil fuels to produce the ethanol. Worse yet are the sugar tariffs. We would be better off if we got rid of the tariff then paid each person involved in growing sugarcane to not work. As https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2017/01/18/if-us-sugar-tariffs-make-americans-poorer-then-donald-trumps-tariffs-will-make-americans-what/#5fc77a7d2ec4 https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2017/01/18/if-us-su... says, this policy would be estimated to make the USA approximately $1 billion per year richer. Government intervention frequently results in perverse incentives that produce nonsensical results.
- throwaway5752 8y ago... Have you ever seen a coal mine? They take up a fair amount of space. Take a flight that passes over Kentucky or W. Virginia sometime. Whole mountains leveled for ... minutes or hours of domestic energy consumption per mountain. Plenty of room for solar and wind in the plains, and I'm not super sure you understand the relationship between land prices, fed fund rates, and the cost of land.
- mdorazio 8y agoSorry you were downvoted for asking a legitimate question. Other commenters have spoken to the land piece, but not to the actual solar/storage cost side. Most of these insanely low bids are produced based on extrapolating the cost decline of solar and storage to the future point where the plants will actually come into operation. If they had to buy everything right now, they might not be able to achieve those costs per kWh, but plants take time to build, so there is an assumption of further declines in acquisition and operating costs over the next several years baked in (in this case, the target date is 2023).
- epistasis 8y agoExcellent point about the install date. Most utility planning happens at longer time scales much longer than one year, as it well should. Prior to the 2000s, the electrical utilities had basically static and unchanging technology, which meant that utilities could use long-established price estimates when determining technologies. No longer is that possible, solar, wind and storage are dropping so fast in costs that it can be hard to keep pace. A California utility recently tried to get bids for a new gas peaker plant, unaware that storage was now cost competitive, because they were using cost estimates that were only a few years old. And the NextEra CEO, quoted in the article above I linked, said way back in 2015 that by 2020, no more gas peaker plants would be built. This is a revolution, where costs are falling faster than even the most enthusiastic boosters were expecting.
- sandworm101 8y agoIf these are speculative then I would call them artificially numbers, artificial because they are based on predicted markets rather than real market dynamics. I wonder though if it is safe to predict a continuous drop in panel prices. A few years ago Germany saw prices rise due to increased demand, demand fuels ironically by subsidies. And there is a good chance that the US administration might deliberately cripple the solar market, either by increasing costs or reducing demand (ie the proposed mandate to buy coal/nuclear energy first). Give that unpredictability, these low bids are more business strategy than a reflection of actual costs structures.
- 8y ago