7 ms·
It's interesting to contrast this with further details released recently from Xcel Energy's competitive bidding in Colorado, which had some unbelievably low pri
by epistasis 8y ago
It's interesting to contrast this with further details released recently from Xcel Energy's competitive bidding in Colorado, which had some unbelievably low prices for wind, solar, and solar combined with storage:
https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/06/07/worlds-largest-lithium-ion-battery-1-gwh-solarpower-xcel-energy-colorado-wind-power/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/06/07/worlds-largest-lithiu...
They're planning a GWh of grid storage attached to 700MW of solar, at a cost of 3.0-3.2 cents/kWh, which completely beats the cost of coal. And that's without taking in to account coal's massive costs that it doesn't pay, in terms of our health (COPD, mercury consumption in fish, etc...).
We have some absolutely awful leadership in this area that is trying to kneecap the future of our country. Colorado's process makes me hopeful that by 2022, this will mostly be in our past. But losing several years of a technology shift is nothing good for the US.
- oblio 8y ago> They're planning a GWh of grid storage attached to 700MW of solar, at a cost of 3.0-3.2 cents/kWh, which completely beats the cost of solar. I'm assuming you meant "it beats the cost of coal"?
- epistasis 8y agoYes, thank you, corrected!
- StavrosK 8y ago> which completely beats the cost of solar. And that's without taking in to account coal's massive costs that it doesn't pay Sorry, I'm confused. Did you mean the other in one of those two sentences, or am I misreading? If you did, which one? EDIT: Ah, I see the sibling comment, thanks.
- sandworm101 8y agoI'm all for solar. I use it myself. But I cannot wrap my head around these prices. They seem far too low. If this reality or is this companies trying to win bids, trying to get their feet into doors? Solar takes space. It takes far more land than coal-fired plants. But land prices are going up and everyone expects interest rates to go up too. So how can they afford to acquire and maintain the needed land at these prices?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Abekkus 8y agoColorado has land to spare. That quote might even be based on zero-cost land.
- sandworm101 8y agoThen these prices are somewhat artificial. Even if you get the land for free, there are significant operating costs. Maintaining solar panels out in a field is very different than on the roof of a factory. In a place like Colorado (not a Nevada desert) you first have to cut down all the trees/bushes, which isn't a great image for green energy. Then someone has to keep the vegetation from growing back. Theft of panels does happen. So you need security guards. The costs aren't extreme, but at the quoted prices they are significant.
- greedo 8y agoYou can put it on grazing land and let the animals keep the vegetation under control.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sverige 8y agoLand is far from zero cost in Colorado. Assuming these solar farms would go on the eastern plains rather than in the even less productive (but more expensive) land in the mountains, it is true that much of that land can support only sparse grazing or sometimes wheat, since it is semi-arid (but not desert as in the Great Basin).
- zrobotics 8y agoHave you spent much time around Grand Junction? There's much more to western CO than just mountains. And the grazing land isn't terribly valuable. I don't know the CO specific figures, but the statewide average in Wyoming is 40 acres/1 head cattle, and western CO has a similar climate. Honestly, WY would be a better place for this, but the state government has its head way too far up the coal industries rear for that to get much traction.
- jseliger 8y agoWe have some absolutely awful leadership in this area that is trying to kneecap the future of our country Indeed: this policy, like many others, just makes me think, "own goal."
- TooBrokeToBeg 8y agoThe majority of people I know, would disagree. It just happens that "own goal" coincides with what I think is a good idea. Not to say that all the decisions are good enough to vote for, but these tariffs are a solid move imo.
- J5892 8y agoWhy do you think they're a solid move? I'm genuinely interested in hearing your reasoning.
- TooBrokeToBeg 8y agoThere's a bunch of different good results (along with the bad). The first, from the Chinese side, is the demonstration that the US can and will impact the immediate Chinese economy. That coldwar tactic is on the table (while open warfare in the south sea is not). Take the tariffs off, move on to a tariff on toys tomorrow. From the US side, the government has a tacit approval to bring up other relationship imbalances that have gone on for too long. The fact that my machines are attacked by Chinese IPs more often than any other locality (via casual IP lookups) makes me think that this is actually part of a greater response to various Chinese incursions into various arenas in the world (not the least of which is the US infrastructure). Another good is in regard to the impact on the US manufacturing base. Dealing with the fact that costing in existing processes and materials (based on abroad cheap labor and materials) is not reliable, is an important step. This will force higher capital investment into experimental materials and processes for alternatives (maybe with other 3rd party countries). There will also be a boon to choice US companies that the federal government favor, through existing and new contracts where these tariffs will otherwise be abated. It's not going to kill every existing company, but it hurts a lot. This is a future-investment move. It's possible it's a misstep and we will never have anything better than steel and cheap plastics, but I doubt it. There is the geo-political arena to consider. The US has been in a cold war with China since after WW2, same as we have with Russia. The moves with regard to North Korea are suspicious. North Korea has been the heel of China for some time. NK has had no way to bargain, with anyone, much less their greatest benefactor. Setting a stake against China then making overtures to NK allows NK (KimJong) to consider becoming a valuable Geopolitical figure and US partner in a critical area, surpassing south korea (for once). It just happened to coincide (I have a feeling Trump is ironically talented at speaking to KJ) and happened to influence the ultimate decision to place the tariffs at this time.
- aphextron 8y agoCan the US even manufacture panels? I was under the impression our infrastructure had almost completely gone away over the last 10 years with the rise of cheap Chinese panels. And would we even be able to produce them at a competitive price with the tariffs, anyways? Would we even want to? The margins are tiny, it's a commodity product. Highly doubtful. I'm seriously baffled here as to who is supposed to benefit from this. The only possibility is some kind of misguided attempt at forestalling the draw down of fossil fuels, which is inevitable.
- post_break 8y agoFirst solar in Toledo manufactures solar panels. Almost 100% of their output was sold to Germany because they were subsidizing them.
- epistasis 8y agoCounter to narrative, there is/was some US based panel production capacity, we do still make things here! We don't make as many things as in, say, Germany, but there is manufacturing. The whole reason that these tariffs came in to effect was that some failed manufacturers brought the issue. My understanding is that the manufacturers failed not because it's impossible to do in the US, but simply because of poor management decisions or betting on the wrong technology. The real question is whether the tariffs will be around long enough to incentivize any new manufacturing capacity in the US. They will almost certainly be slapped down by the WTO in a short amount of time, as previous tariffs like this have been. So by the time anybody could make more manufacturing capacity, it seems likely that the tariffs will no longer be around to support the facility. So new facilities must be planned on the basis of profitability without the tariffs. Even in this environment, there is new production being planned. However, the jobs associated with this are dwarfed by the number of jobs related to installation of panels. So while this will certainly be a net negative to the US economy in the short term, without much opportunity to provide positive impact. Basically, just a meaningless PR move by a politician. I don't think it will cause hugely detrimental effects either, it's just stupid.
- gascan 8y ago
- micajah 8y agoYou are right. And to think I worked at a place that made silicon wafers in the 80s in Pennsylvania