5 ms·
Alphabet shareholders reject diversity proposal backed by employees
- eulers__number 8y agodiversity promotion is just another system not based on merit but a system based on discrimination and "affirmative" action
- adamnemecek 8y agoThis is an honest question to people who side with the proposal. At what point would these measures become unnecessary? What are the conditions? Btw what is the name of the ideology that one would use to justify this?
- sz4kerto 8y agoThe other question is for people who side with the proposal: what would be considered 'too much effort' when it comes to inclusion and equitability?
- malvosenior 8y agoIt’s not about effort. It’s aboit discriminating against people to fill quotas and turning away qualified candidates when they’re not the “correct” gender or race.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- diminoten 8y agoIt's wrong to claim that qualified candidates are being rejected in favor of less qualified, but diverse, candidates. No position in this argument supports anything like that.
- adamnemecek 8y agohttps://www.fastcompany.com/40538483/youtube-sued-for-limiting-white-asian-male-hires-for-diversity-purposes https://www.fastcompany.com/40538483/youtube-sued-for-limiti...
- diminoten 8y agoAt no point in that article does it mention hiring unqualified candidates. To be a bit blunter, there are plenty of great engineers out there, and some of them happen to not be white/Asian. I don't know if what YouTube did was right or wrong, but pretending like only white/Asian people can be good at computers is quite insane.
- adamnemecek 8y agoIf you reject candidates based on race, the probability of that having happened is very high.
- diminoten 8y agoSorry, but that's simply not true. There are plenty of qualified candidates, all of whom can do any given engineering job. The probability of hiring an under qualified candidate is entirely unaffected by refusing to interview white/Asian people. Edit: Replying here, since I'm now rate limited... I can see how you might think you're not selecting the "most qualified candidate" by limiting who you interview based on diversity criteria, if you believed hiring was very precise, but in my experience, hiring is much fuzzier than that. "The most qualified candidate" is not an objective number you reach after plugging values into a formula (please, show me the formula that can accurately calculate "fit"), and saying there is a singular objective "most qualified candidate" isn't actually how the hiring process works. Further, if you identify a competitive disadvantage among your teams related to diversity, hiring someone who doesn't diversify your team (though is otherwise qualified) may actually hurt your ability to meet team goals and deliver (in this case) quality software. That "most qualified candidate" may not be qualified to provide the viewpoints you need for you team to thrive.
- lixtra 8y agoThe answer to this question I usually get is that you cannot oversteer because a) we are still far away from a fair state and b) even if you oversteer it’s fair to make up for past injustice.
- UncleMeat 8y agoThis is a hard question to answer. But I'd consider something like racial bussing in the 60s. This was a positive step and was enacted without explicit exit conditions. Such exit conditions are not necessarily a requirement for these sorts of initiatives.
- adamnemecek 8y agoThe two are very different tho. One is in some sense removing a rule, one is adding it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- camelite 8y agoBussing is actually a classic example of a well intentioned policy most supported for its symbolism which ended up damaging its supposed beneficieries because it ignored the necessity of matching peoples' abilities with the expectations placed on them. Putting 2nd-grade readers in classes with 4th-grade readers is a recipe for frustration and failure, not matter how pure your heart.
- bjornstjerne 8y ago> This is an honest question to people who side with the proposal. At what point would these measures become unnecessary? What are the conditions? > Btw what is the name of the ideology that one would use to justify this? I'm not one of the supporters, but I've talked many times to such people and have encountered a lot of resistance to them laying out stopping or success conditions. I'm of the option that the diversity activists want these diversity programs to continue until they are happy with the results, which (more than likely) will be never. I've also seen a lot of resistance the idea considering the perspectives of anyone who's not a member of one of these "victim"-groups (at least not until their group has experienced "10,000 years of oppression and discrimination."
- malvosenior 8y agoI wish the article had more details on why the propositions were rejected. It makes sense though, Alphabet is there to make money not foster an ultra political working environment. After the Damore incident, I wouldn't consider working there, but this does offer some hope to those who aren't far-left leaning.
- peteretep 8y agoI wonder how you came to the determination that those who support equality are far left, rather than just left?
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoHe didn’t come to that determination. People pushing these don’t support equality or anything close to it.
- scryfish 8y agoForced equal outcome? Reasonable to call that far left
- ihsw2 8y agoThere is a difference between the groups that advocate for generous social welfare programs and steep progressive taxation, and the groups that advocate for radical societal shifts justified by cultural/class Marxism. The former are left and the latter are far left, and (more to the point) the former are representative of the general population while the latter a dangerous minority within an already-dangerous minority.
- dokein 8y agoTo what extent should diversity be the responsibility of companies? I would argue the responsibility is in proportion to added-discrimination, so to speak (kind of like your profit should be in proportion to your added value). So, as an example, if 90% of your applicants are male and 10% are female, presuming quality is randomly distributed, the default assumption is that the company ends up with 90% male employees and 10% female employees. You might make some adjustments arguing that diversity is better for work environment / productivity / decision-making but that's a post-hoc adjustment. If that is the case at Google (and I have no way of knowing), then I would argue the burden falls on society for having 90% of applicants be male and 10% of the applicants be female in the first place. That sharp of a gender gap is not the case in Eastern Europe. The solution is obviously best targeted toward the problem and not the symptom. If you have a fever because of a bacterial pneumonia, antibiotics are much better than Tylenol.
- lmkg 8y agoFrom the article: > the company remains committed to an internal goal to reach > "market supply" representation of women and minorities by 2020. The term "market supply" isn't defined in the article, but I assume it's basically what you're talking about (except overall job market, not just applicants). If that's true, then Google is already accounting for that factor but minorities are still underrepresented.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoCompanies have a huge influence over the distribution of who applies by the wording and placement of their job adverts.
- barrkel 8y agoWatch out for variance too. If variance is different in the two populations then a high hiring bar will overweight the high variance population.
- vlovich123 8y ago
- calibas 8y agoSeems like there's a lot of internal conflict in Google at the moment.
- RpFLCL 8y agoPrevious discussion yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17251371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17251371
- random_user456 8y agoWhy do companies hire all these diversity administration in the first place? It burns epic amounts of money, and sows discontent, when there message and answer to everything is we need more diversity for all leadership and tech positions,(aka quotas of people with subpar skillsets). Instead of merely hiring on skill.
- ddppee 8y agoThe thing is that people aren't hired based solely on skill. There is some degree of bias that needs to be addressed.
- adamnemecek 8y agoThis bias goes well beyond racial and gender diversity. Why are these the only types of diversity that are ever discussed. And pls don’t misunderstand this argument, but could the same argument not be used for say diversity of skill? Like how come a company can reject me due to lack of skill?
- daveFNbuck 8y ago> And pls don’t misunderstand this argument, but could the same argument not be used for say diversity of skill? Like how come a company can reject me due to lack of skill? The argument is that it's unfair and harmful to the individual, your company, and society to not hire someone because their skin is too dark. Do you think that's true of not hiring someone who isn't qualified?
- adamnemecek 8y ago> society to not hire someone because their skin is too dark. In SV, I can't imagine this being that common. However let's take an example. There's an interview for a position and the interviewer is a white American. Two applicants of equal skill apply. One of them is African American who's attended the same high school as the interviewer. The other one is a recent emigrant from Russia who is skilled technically however his "cultural awareness" might be lacking. Who is more likely to get hired? This is a rhetorical question. I actually don't know.
- lainga 8y agoIf we aren't going to mark this as dupe, I'll repeat my comment from the thread yesterday: Per the article, backed by "several hundred employees" out of a 2017 Alphabet headcount of 80,110.
- ihsw2 8y agoPopularity is not a measure of validity.
- lainga 8y agoI'll also repeat sonnyblarney's comment: What's also kind of buried [in the article] is that the 'employees' are a small fraction of Google's staff and do not represent the overall staff at company, as the headline kind of implies.
- hyperbovine 8y agoSure it is, when the rulemaking procedure is by majority vote.
- jonlucc 8y agoThe rule making procedure, if I’m not mistaken, is majority vote of shares. That’s why the article says that the proposals did not pass.
- ryanmarsh 8y agoIf Google continues to advertise a strong stance on diversity the problem may solve itself, for them. I say this because I’ve noticed that my clients with a strong LGBT pride message tend to further attract people from that community. Resulting in an amplification. In one such company this was very pronounced. The reverse (people not from that community self selecting out) might also be true but I don’t have anything to back that up with.
- arkem 8y agoFor interest here's where you can find the relevant motions being referred to in the article: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918000222/lgoog2018-def14a.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918... The ones being referred to are: Proposal Number 6 Stockholder Proposal Regarding a Report on Gender Pay Proposal Number 9 Stockholder Proposal Regarding Board Diversity and Qualifications Proposal Number 10 Stockholder Proposal Regarding a Report on Content Governance I'm not that familiar with corporate motions so I might be misinterpreting what I'm reading but it looks like the motions are for Alphabet to produce a report about gender pay discrimination, to disclose the qualifications of the board (including ideological leanings and biographical data), and to produce a report on the efficacy of Alphabet's terms of service enforcement (in particular around user uploaded content). Alphabet's disagreeing statements on the first one is largely of the form "we think gender pay is an important issue (see existing published reports) but we don't think this is motion is a good idea". The second one they actually support saying "sure, a diverse board is a good idea". For the third one their response is along the lines of "We take this seriously to the tune of hiring thousands of people to enforce our terms of service". My biggest surprise after seeing the article and reading the materials myself was that the second proposal (board diversity) claims that Alphabet is known to "operate in ideological hegemony that eschews conservative people" which is not the impression I took away from the article.
- bayfullofrays 8y agoI like what we are doing at our company, an unofficial 1:5, where for every over represented candidate, we aggressively pursue five underrepresented candidates. It is a lot easier to train people for tech than it is to "train" someone to come from a oppressed community.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- swebs 8y agoI believe these are the proposals in question: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918000222/lgoog2018-def14a.htm#lgoog2018def14aa065 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918... https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918000222/lgoog2018-def14a.htm#lgoog2018def14aa068 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1652044/000130817918...
- greggeter 8y agoI'll agree diversity in hiring is important across the board when school systems fight to hire more men.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]