3 ms·
Good observation about different challenges. Different people like different things. I like games that allows mastery of complex control scheme, and exercises
by ajuc 16y ago
Good observation about different challenges.
Different people like different things. I like games that allows mastery of complex control scheme, and exercises reflex. It's great feeling, when you have complete control.
Some games are based on logical thinking, story, strategy, etc - in these games difficult controls is just distraction, and it makes experience worse. Control schemes evolved, so older games had worse than new games (also computers evolved, now it's easier to do good ui than 10 years ago).
For me one of the best games was "Icy Tower" - very simple concept, simple graphic, no story to speak of. It aged very well.
Doom - the same - the feeling of nicely timed double shotgun shot is very rewarding, it doesn't matter you are shooting to rectangles.
I've seen in some game design book the distinction between a game and a toy.
Toy is when you are given some cool object to manipulate, and some constraints, and that's it.
Game has rules and objectives, you must solve some problem.
You can make a game without a toy - when there is no pleasure apart from solving problems.
You can also make a toy without making a game - it will be boring after a while, because there will be no objective, no problems to solve.
But great game is when you have cool toy and interesting problem to solve with it - these games plays great even after years.
- Xurinos 16y ago> Doom - the same - the feeling of nicely timed double shotgun shot is very rewarding, it doesn't matter you are shooting to rectangles. I always like how people bring up Doom as opposed to, say, Wolfenstein or one of the other 3D shooters of the time. What made Doom feel different with the controls was two subtle things: head bob and acceleration. In the same vein, there were other side-scrollers that featured characters jumping around. The side-scrollers that added acceleration physics (Mario, Metroid) were the really popular ones. I am trying to consider Castlevania as an exception to my acceleration theory, particularly the limited jumping movement in Castlevania 1 (similar to 8 Eyes, which allowed you to have neat two-player coop action but somehow was not as popular).