3 ms·
Closed shops have been illegal since 1947. What you're describing is an agency shop. That's not just pedantry because many people still believe that new employ
by wahern 8y ago
Closed shops have been illegal since 1947. What you're describing is an agency shop.
That's not just pedantry because many people still believe that new employees can be forced to join a union in a unionized workplace. Having to pay agency fees is a contentious issue but equivocating that with union membership as a non-negotiable term of employment isn't remotely the same thing, and simply furthers a particular (unfortunately very successful) political narrative.
Right-to-work is a classic political idiom that long predates pro-choice and pro-life. Using Google Ngram you can see it's use increase immediately after the 1947 outlawing of union shops. The whole point of "right-to-work" is to muddy the waters and confuse people. After outlawing union shops in 1947--which were just as controversial as they are today--Republicans needed a way to sustain widespread skepticism of union power. It's no coincidence that the vast majority of people assume right-to-work states are the only ones that ban union shops. If people realized union shops were already illegal nationwide it would seriously blunt public sympathy for Republican arguments. People can easily sympathize with arguments that one shouldn't be forced to join a union in order to be gainfully employed; but agency fees are much more technical and not something most people would have strong opinions about, especially because they generally only amount to a few dollars per month--mostly to cover the cost of the dispute resolution process, as mandated by the union contract, when an employee is penalized or terminated.
I don't have strong opinions about agency fees. But I do have strong opinions about transparent and honest public discourse.
- stale2002 8y agoYou are being pedantic. There is very little difference between being forced to join a union and being forced in an agency model. They are basically the same thing, and are different in name only. You still have to pay the same fees. You are still subject to the same rules. You are still subject to their collective bargaining agreement and are disallowed from negotiating on your own. There are close to zero defacto differences between the two, even if you give it a different name.
- wahern 8y agoIn the interest of full disclosure, here's an example structure from the University of California: https://ucnet.universityofcalifornia.edu/labor/fees-chart.html https://ucnet.universityofcalifornia.edu/labor/fees-chart.ht... Those agency fees, paid in lieu of membership dues (i.e. mutually exclusive), are indeed much higher than I expected. I've had professional experience with police unions, and the fee structure for campus police is indeed much more like what I was familiar with, where the agency fee is substantially less than the membership due.
- Spooky23 8y agoYou really have to look at the details, when I was in a union, the union actually administered some benefits which accounted for a lot of the cost.