3 ms·
> I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but that cooler is smaller than the Threadripper socket. Yes, I am aware of that (it's not news to me). The cooler is s
by loeg 8y ago
> I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but that cooler is smaller than the Threadripper socket.
Yes, I am aware of that (it's not news to me). The cooler is smaller than the integrated heat spreader (the visible metal cover on the top of the CPU), but it does fully cover all four (two active) CCX dies and conducts plenty of heat away.
I know you can get TR4-shaped coolers today, and they perform marginally better, but they were not available at the time. With all cores busy, this thing keeps the CPU at 50°C or less in ~25°C ambient (stock clocks/boost). That is totally sufficient — the CPU is rated to 68°C (and oddly, the Ryzen 1800X is rated to 95°C, so it's unclear why the TR isn't rated up to 95°C as well).
> Anyway, the bigger heat-plate makes a big difference. People have measured somewhere on the order of ~10C to ~20C cooler.
Yes, absolutely it makes a difference; something like ~10°C, at least under fairly common conditions, from my reading. 20°C probably indicates an incorrectly installed cooler.
- dragontamer 8y ago> Yes, I am aware of that (it's not news to me). The cooler is smaller than the integrated heat spreader (the visible metal cover on the top of the CPU), but it does fully cover all four (two active) CCX dies and conducts plenty of heat away. https://www.gamersnexus.net/images/media/2017/CPUs/tr-1950x/amd-threadripper-grid-2.jpg https://www.gamersnexus.net/images/media/2017/CPUs/tr-1950x/... Technically covers, but you can see that the screw-holes of the cooler go right over the dies. So you've got some air-pockets over the most-important parts to cool. > Yes, absolutely it makes a difference; something like ~10°C, at least under fairly common conditions, from my reading. 20°C probably indicates an incorrectly installed cooler. I was looking at overclocked numbers at the ~20C metrics btw. 10C was closer to the "normal use" situation. Overclocking adds a lot of heat, and benefits from a cooler with a larger connection.
- loeg 8y ago> Technically covers, but you can see that the screw-holes of the cooler go right over the dies. So you've got some air-pockets over the most-important parts to cool. Sorry, I don't see any screw holes overlapping dies in that image; can you point them out? Also, won't screw holes generally have screws in them, which are both conductive and not air?
- dragontamer 8y agohttps://i.imgur.com/A7h22DB.jpg https://i.imgur.com/A7h22DB.jpg I added a few arrows to make it more obvious. Here's the article these pics are from: https://www.gamersnexus.net/news-pc/3008-threadripper-cooler-and-thermalpaste-coverage-vs-die-ihs https://www.gamersnexus.net/news-pc/3008-threadripper-cooler... > Also, won't screw holes generally have screws in them, which are both conductive and not air? https://static.arctic.ac/media/wysiwyg/Products/Liquid_Freezer_360/Feature/Liquid_Freezer_360_f04.jpg https://static.arctic.ac/media/wysiwyg/Products/Liquid_Freez... Screws have heads, and those heads have divots and are simply not a perfectly-flat surface. I mean, nothing is perfectly flat. That's why we use thermal compound / thermal paste to connect things together. (Thermal compound is worse than copper at thermal exchange, but its way, way WAY better than air-gaps). So you use thermal-paste to fill in any air-gaps. If you are going to use a "regular size" cooler, you probably should put thermal paste in all of those screw-heads, for a slightly better connection.